Like

Towleroad

  • Body
  • Daily Resist
  • POLITICS
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Film
  • TV
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Men
  • Marriage Equality
  • Space
  • Trans Rights
  • Books
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • TowleREAD

BREAKING: Janelle Monáe Comes Out as Queer, Pansexual: ‘I Consider Myself to Be a Free-Ass Motherf–ker’

Supreme Court Shuffle: Did Conservatives Grant the Prop 8 Case?

PreviousPrevious StoryMarie Osmond Speaks Out for Marriage Equality: VIDEO
NextNext StoryAbout: Steve Pep

by Andy Towle
March 30, 2013 | 8:26am

Share Comments

Adam Liptak at the NYT finds the "aha moment" in the Supreme Court's Prop. 8 transcript signaling who likely voted to take up the case, and proposes a theory about why it was taken and the exit points that may shuffle it back to California where the ruling striking it down would stand.

A_scaliaWrites Liptak:

After Justice Anthony M. Kennedy suggested that the court should dismiss the case, Justice Antonin Scalia tipped his hand.

“It’s too late for that now, isn’t it?” he said, a note of glee in his voice.

“We have crossed that river,” he said.

That was a signal that it was a conservative grant.

And how did that happen?

Justice Scalia, almost certainly joined by Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel A. Alito Jr., apparently made a twofold calculation: that their odds of winning would not improve as same-sex marriage grows more popular and more commonplace, and that Justice Kennedy, who is likely to write the decision in the case concerning the 1996 law, would lock himself into rhetoric and logic that would compel him to vote for a constitutional right to same-sex marriage in a later case.

It is not that the conservatives felt certain they would win. It is that their chances would not improve in the years ahead.

That leaves the question of the fourth vote. The most likely answer is that it was that of Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., though he did not sound at all pleased on Tuesday to have the case before him.

There is also a chance that the fourth vote came from Justice Kennedy himself, and his very questioning provides support for that theory.

“I just wonder,” he said, sounding a little plaintive and a little angry, “if the case was properly granted.”


Who Wanted to Take the Case on Gay Marriage? Ask Scalia [nyt]

If you missed Ari Ezra Waldman's Prop 8 analysis from earlier in the week you can find it HERE (Part 1) and HERE (Part 2).

PreviousPrevious StoryMarie Osmond Speaks Out for Marriage Equality: VIDEO
NextNext StoryAbout: Steve Pep
Share Like Comments

Posted March 30, 2013 at 8:26am ETC by Andy Towle
in Antonin Scalia, Federal Prop 8 Trial, gay marriage, News, proposition 8, Supreme Court

Follow Us

Like Towleroad

Towleroad

Video

gay panic

Austin Man Gets 10 Years Probation for Murder of Neighbor After Using ‘Gay Panic’ Defense

Share154 Like154

Alex V

Mike Pompeo, Bill Cosby, Prince Harry, Shawn Mendes, Avengers, Kanye West, Robert Mueller: HOT LINKS

Share14 Like14

balboa inn

3 Men Sue Newport Beach Restaurant for ‘Gay Bashing’ After Being Violently Thrown Out on Street: VIDEOS

Share123 Like123

matt and dan watch what happens live

Matt and Dan Stripped Down for Andy Cohen (and Attention) on ‘Watch What Happens Live!’

Share99 Like99

sean spicer wax melania

Sean Spicer’s Latest Gig: Presiding Over the Unveiling of the Wax Melania Trump – WATCH

Share29 Like29

chris hemsworth

Chris Hemsworth and Ellen Review the Best Moments of His Career (Spoiler: They’re All Shirtless) – WATCH

Share74 Like74

Hunk of the Day

matt and dan watch what happens live

Matt and Dan Stripped Down for Andy Cohen (and Attention) on ‘Watch What Happens Live!’

Share99 Like99

Columns

  • Theatre Review In ‘Transfers,’ a Shot at Privilege Means Reckoning with Stacked Odds: REVIEW
  • Recap The Queens On ‘RuPaul’s Drag Race’ Talk the Talk [RECAP and RANKING]
  • Theatre Review Time’s Up? Not So Fast: ‘Carousel’ Is Back on Broadway: REVIEW
  • Theatre Review In ‘This Flat Earth,’ Growing Up in the Shadow of a School Shooting
  • Recap ‘RuPaul’s Drag Race’ Queens Get App Happy and Flocked Up on the Runway [RECAP and RANKING]
  • Theatre Review In ‘Three Tall Women’ and ‘Yerma,’ Stunning Portraits of Women on the Verge: REVIEW
  • Theatre Review Chris Evans and Michael Cera Are Men in Uniform in Kenneth Lonergan’s Superb ‘Lobby Hero’: REVIEW
  • Theatre Review Andrew Garfield and Nathan Lane Star in Electrifying ‘Angels in America’: REVIEW
  • Theatre Review A Slushy ‘Frozen’ Opens on Broadway: REVIEW
  • Recap It All Comes To An End On ‘Versace: American Crime Story’ Finale: RECAP

Latest Posts

  • all blacks rainbow jerseyRugby Team’s Jersey Shows Support for Diversity and Inclusion by Making a Rainbow When It Stretches2 hours ago
  • gay panicAustin Man Gets 10 Years Probation for Murder of Neighbor After Using ‘Gay Panic’ Defense2 hours ago
  • Richard GrenellRichard Grenell Confirmed as Ambassador to Germany, is Highest Ranking Openly Gay Trump Appointee3 hours ago
  • Alex VMike Pompeo, Bill Cosby, Prince Harry, Shawn Mendes, Avengers, Kanye West, Robert Mueller: HOT LINKS5 hours ago
  • balboa inn3 Men Sue Newport Beach Restaurant for ‘Gay Bashing’ After Being Violently Thrown Out on Street: VIDEOS6 hours ago
  • matt and dan watch what happens liveMatt and Dan Stripped Down for Andy Cohen (and Attention) on ‘Watch What Happens Live!’8 hours ago
  • Phoenix Approves Rainbow Crosswalks to Support the LGBTQ Community9 hours ago
  • transgender bridgeportTransgender Woman Shot in the Face in Her Own Home9 hours ago
  • sean spicer wax melaniaSean Spicer’s Latest Gig: Presiding Over the Unveiling of the Wax Melania Trump – WATCH9 hours ago
  • Joy ReidThe Daily Beast Will ‘Hit Pause’ on Joy Reid’s Columns Amid Blog Post Controversy10 hours ago
  • Janelle MonaeJanelle Monáe Comes Out as Queer, Pansexual: ‘I Consider Myself to Be a Free-Ass Motherf–ker’11 hours ago
  • trump meltdownTrump Has Raging Meltdown on FOX & Friends Over James Comey, Michael Cohen, Ronny Jackson: WATCH11 hours ago
  • chris hemsworthChris Hemsworth and Ellen Review the Best Moments of His Career (Spoiler: They’re All Shirtless) – WATCH12 hours ago
  • Olly Alexander Announces ‘Years & Years’ Second Studio Album, ‘Palo Santo’12 hours ago
  • ronny jackson obese trumpTrump VA Pick Ronny Jackson Withdraws Nomination13 hours ago
  • hulmet muller estrada miami beach honorsMiami Beach Honors Man Who Stepped in to Help Gay Couple During Pride Attack: WATCH13 hours ago
  • theresa may gayTrump Will Be Going to UK in July But Won’t Be Honored with a State Banquet or Carriage Procession13 hours ago
  • ronny jackson obese trumpTrump VA Pick Ronny Jackson Prescribed Himself Drugs, Wrecked Government Vehicle While Drunk1 day ago

You Might Also Like

  • cynthia nixon governorgay marriage Marriage Equality Advocates Call Out Cynthia Nixon for Flip-Flop in Praise for Cuomo
  • gay marriage COSTA RICA: With Vow to Legalize Gay Marriage, Carlos Alvarado Quesada Wins Presidential Election
  • judge stephen reinhardtgay marriage 9th Circuit Judge Stephen Reinhardt, Who Struck Down Prop 8, Gay Marriage Bans, Dies
  • gay marriage Romania’s Ruling Party Leader Considering Same-Sex Civil Partnership Legislation
  • gym ruth bader ginsburgSupreme Court Stephen Colbert Hits the Gym with Ruth Bader Ginsburg: WATCH
  • gay obituarygay marriage Texas Paper Removes Gay Man’s Husband from Mom’s Obituary for ‘Religious and Ethical’ Reasons

Latest Posts

  • all blacks rainbow jersey

    Rugby Team’s Jersey Shows Support for Diversity and Inclusion by Making a Rainbow When It Stretches

    New Zealand’s world-famous All Blacks and Black Ferns rugby teams are the centerpiece of a new campaign for diversity and inclusion, wearing a specially-crafted jersey that creates a rainbow when the fabric is stretched. Insurance Company AIG J…
    Read

  • gay panic

    Austin Man Gets 10 Years Probation for Murder of Neighbor After Using ‘Gay Panic’ Defense

     James Miller, an Austin man, was sentenced to 10 years probation for the “criminally negligent homicide” of his neighbor Daniel Spencer after arguing that he killed in self-defense after Spencer came on to him. KXAN reports: The defense…
    Read

  • Richard Grenell

    Richard Grenell Confirmed as Ambassador to Germany, is Highest Ranking Openly Gay Trump Appointee

    Richard Grenell, former spokesman for the U.S. mission to the United Nations under President George W. Bush, has been confirmed by the Senate in a 56-42 vote as ambassador to Germany. Grenell is now the highest-ranking openly gay appointee of the Tru…
    Read

  • Richard Grenell

    Supreme Court Shuffle: Did Conservatives Grant the Prop 8 Case?

    MIKE POMPEO. Senate confirms anti-LGBTQ Mike Pompeo as next Secretary of State: “The split vote — 57 to 42 — represents the political scrutiny Pompeo is likely to encounter as he moves from the CIA to the State Department, where he’ll face the…
    Read

  • Richard Grenell

    Supreme Court Shuffle: Did Conservatives Grant the Prop 8 Case?

    Three men are suing Newport Beach, California’s Balboa Inn for “gay bashing,” civil rights violations, and mental distress after they were literally thrown out of the inn’s Siena restaurant and called homophobic slurs. Angel B…
    Read

  • Richard Grenell

    Supreme Court Shuffle: Did Conservatives Grant the Prop 8 Case?

    Matthew Wilkas and Daniel Vincent Gordh, of the web series Matt & Dan, were invited to be bartenders on Watch What Happens Live! and made the most of their moment, possibly sacrificing a few chest hairs in the process. If you weren’t aware that @…
    Read

  • Richard Grenell

    Supreme Court Shuffle: Did Conservatives Grant the Prop 8 Case?

    Arizona’s Family Phoenix, Arizona’s mayor and city council have approved the installation of two rainbow crosswalks to support the LGBTQ community in that city. AZFamily reports: “The rainbow-painted crosswalks are proposed to be in…
    Read

  • transgender bridgeport

    Transgender Woman Shot in the Face in Her Own Home

    A transgender woman, prominent and popular in her neighborhood, was shot in the face and several times in her arm in her home in Bridgeport, Connecticut and police are investigating it as a possible hate crime. News12 reports: “Witnesses say th…
    Read

  • sean spicer wax melania

    Sean Spicer’s Latest Gig: Presiding Over the Unveiling of the Wax Melania Trump – WATCH

    The jokes really just write themselves, so here’s former White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer presiding over the unveiling yesterday, at Madame Tussauds, of the wax Melania Trump. Enjoy:…
    Read

  • Joy Reid

    The Daily Beast Will ‘Hit Pause’ on Joy Reid’s Columns Amid Blog Post Controversy

    The Daily Beast says it will “hit pause” on columns by MSBNC political analyst Joy Reid after new allegations of homophobic blog posts surfaced this week. Reid claims that her blog was hacked and the posts fabricated. The new posts were a…
    Read

Most Commented

Hot Reads

  • America’s Top Crime Family: The Trumps
  • High Stakes for LGBTQ Equality in the Anti-Gay Baker Case at the Supreme Court
  • State Department ‘Deeply Disturbed’ by Reports of Detention, Torture, and Murder of Gay Men in Chechnya
  • Anti-Gay Pastor Who Said Orlando Victims ‘Got What They Deserved’ Guilty of Sexually Molesting Boy and Girl
  • Neil Gorsuch is Trump’s Terrible, No Good Nominee for the Supreme Court: An Analysis
  • 2017 Resolutions All Gay Men Should Consider
  • Comedian Eric Andre: The Gay Interview

Today's News

Jump To Day: Choose
  • Rugby Team’s Jersey Shows Support for Diversity and Inclusion by Making a Rainbow When It Stretches
  • Austin Man Gets 10 Years Probation for Murder of Neighbor After Using ‘Gay Panic’ Defense
  • Richard Grenell Confirmed as Ambassador to Germany, is Highest Ranking Openly Gay Trump Appointee
  • Mike Pompeo, Bill Cosby, Prince Harry, Shawn Mendes, Avengers, Kanye West, Robert Mueller: HOT LINKS
  • 3 Men Sue Newport Beach Restaurant for ‘Gay Bashing’ After Being Violently Thrown Out on Street: VIDEOS
  • Matt and Dan Stripped Down for Andy Cohen (and Attention) on ‘Watch What Happens Live!’
  • Phoenix Approves Rainbow Crosswalks to Support the LGBTQ Community
  • Transgender Woman Shot in the Face in Her Own Home
  • Sean Spicer’s Latest Gig: Presiding Over the Unveiling of the Wax Melania Trump – WATCH
  • The Daily Beast Will ‘Hit Pause’ on Joy Reid’s Columns Amid Blog Post Controversy
  • Janelle Monáe Comes Out as Queer, Pansexual: ‘I Consider Myself to Be a Free-Ass Motherf–ker’
  • Trump Has Raging Meltdown on FOX & Friends Over James Comey, Michael Cohen, Ronny Jackson: WATCH
  • Chris Hemsworth and Ellen Review the Best Moments of His Career (Spoiler: They’re All Shirtless) – WATCH
  • Olly Alexander Announces ‘Years & Years’ Second Studio Album, ‘Palo Santo’
  • Trump VA Pick Ronny Jackson Withdraws Nomination
  • Miami Beach Honors Man Who Stepped in to Help Gay Couple During Pride Attack: WATCH
  • Trump Will Be Going to UK in July But Won’t Be Honored with a State Banquet or Carriage Procession

Share This

Share3.3k Like3.3k

Read

  • Politics
  • Travel
  • Film
  • Theatre
  • Television
  • Science
  • Law – LGBT Rights
  • Columns
  • Specials

About

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Contributors
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us

© 2014 Towleroad. All Rights Reserved.