• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Body
  • Daily Resist
  • POLITICS
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Film
  • TV
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Men
  • Marriage Equality
  • Space
  • Trans Rights
  • Books
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • TowleREAD

The First Amendment Canard

January 12, 2011 by Ari Ezra Waldman

BY ARI EZRA WALDMAN

Ari Ezra Waldman is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. After practicing in New York for five years and clerking at a federal appellate court in Washington, D.C., Ari is now on the faculty at California Western School of Law in San Diego, California. His areas of expertise are criminal law, criminal procedure, LGBT law and law and economics. Ari will be writing biweekly posts on law and various LGBT issues. 

Follow Ari on Twitter at @ariezrawaldman.

The tragedy in Tucson has spawned the repetition of a false understanding of the First Amendment. By now, we all know about Sarah Palin's virtual target on Representative Gabrielle Giffords's district, Rep. Giffords's November opponent and his constant gun references, Glenn Beck's odd request to keep the peace next to a jack Bauer-esque photo of him ready to fire a weapon and the harsh invectives that have more recently characterized our political discourse. We also probably know about Ms. Palin's defense — they were surveyor marks, not rifle targets, and besides, it is our First Amendment right to say what we want.

Plin Setting aside the fact that the surveyor mark argument does not pass the smell test, it is the First Amendment argument that I would like to discuss today. We've heard it a lot. Free speech allows the Westboro Baptist Church to protest military funerals and say the most terrible things about America, gays and pretty much everyone else. It allows Virginia Foxx to call gays demented and a more serious threat to national security than the Taliban. It even allows us to use the Internet to verbally harass our peers to some extent. Of course, there are exceptions, but the First Amendment allows us to say terrible things because in our tradition, we worry less about the free flow of crappy ideas and more about the totalitarian implications of no flow of ideas in the first place.

But, whether you can say something is different from whether you should say it.

And, that is what the discourse about civility in Washington is about. It is not about our right to say stupid things, but our loss of control over the propriety of what we say. This makes waving the flag of the First Amendment irrelevant, and a red herring that people like Ms. Palin use to not only absolve themselves of responsibility, but also to avoid expressing any hint of contrition. Herein lies the problem.

I have yet to find an article, op-ed piece or back-of-the-napkin doodle in which Ms. Palin's favorite monsters — the so-called "main stream media" and the "looney left" — have argued that the target map should be illegal or a type of banned speech. Most of the articles I have read that called for some legal changes have jumped the gun (no pun intended) and called for strong gun control laws, but those laws ban guns, not speech. Some pundits have called for greater protections for members of Congress, but an increase in security does not hinder speech.

Horrible invectives, vicious attacks and bellicose hateful speech may not have caused a wacko like Jared Loughner to pull the trigger, but that does not mean we cannot use his heinous act as a springboard for discussing civility in Washington. Nor should the First Amendment be used to short circuit that discussion. The First Amendment sets a floor of what the government can or cannot censor. It expresses no normative opinion as to the merit or value or (im)morality of what speech it allows in to the public sphere. That is not its job. As such, it is no defense to the Ms. Palin's of the world who fail to show the judgment of mature adults (let alone statements) when they take the great power given them by the First Amendment and use it irresponsibly. And, irresponsible and immature use of our freedoms merits condemnation.

Filed Under: News Tagged With: Ari Ezra Waldman, Law - Gay, LGBT, News

Recent Posts

  • Stephen Colbert, Joe Scarborough, White House Resignations, Ivanka’s Patriots, RuPaul, Justin Laevens: HOT LINKS

    Stephen Colbert, Joe Scarborough, White House Resignations, Ivanka’s Patriots, RuPaul, Justin Laevens: HOT LINKS

    13 hours ago
  • Bipartisan Calls Grow for 25th Amendment Removal of Trump from Office

    Bipartisan Calls Grow for 25th Amendment Removal of Trump from Office

    16 hours ago
  • Mark Zuckerberg: Facebook Has Banned Trump Until Transition of Power to Biden is Over

    Mark Zuckerberg: Facebook Has Banned Trump Until Transition of Power to Biden is Over

    18 hours ago
  • ‘Co-Conspirators in Sedition’: Here Are the Names of Every Republican Who Voted to Overturn Election Results

    ‘Co-Conspirators in Sedition’: Here Are the Names of Every Republican Who Voted to Overturn Election Results

    19 hours ago
Previous Post: « Lesbian Trainers Sue NYC’s David Barton Gym for Harassment
Next Post: News: John Travolta, Maryland, Stephanie Seymour, Yale, Odors »

Primary Sidebar

  • Stephen Colbert, Joe Scarborough, White House Resignations, Ivanka’s Patriots, RuPaul, Justin Laevens: HOT LINKS

  • Bipartisan Calls Grow for 25th Amendment Removal of Trump from Office

  • Mark Zuckerberg: Facebook Has Banned Trump Until Transition of Power to Biden is Over

Recent Posts

  • Stephen Colbert, Joe Scarborough, White House Resignations, Ivanka’s Patriots, RuPaul, Justin Laevens: HOT LINKS

    Stephen Colbert, Joe Scarborough, White House Resignations, Ivanka’s Patriots, RuPaul, Justin Laevens: HOT LINKS

    13 hours ago
  • Bipartisan Calls Grow for 25th Amendment Removal of Trump from Office

    Bipartisan Calls Grow for 25th Amendment Removal of Trump from Office

    16 hours ago
  • Mark Zuckerberg: Facebook Has Banned Trump Until Transition of Power to Biden is Over

    Mark Zuckerberg: Facebook Has Banned Trump Until Transition of Power to Biden is Over

    18 hours ago
  • ‘Co-Conspirators in Sedition’: Here Are the Names of Every Republican Who Voted to Overturn Election Results

    ‘Co-Conspirators in Sedition’: Here Are the Names of Every Republican Who Voted to Overturn Election Results

    19 hours ago
  • Woman Shot to Death During Pro-Trump Capitol Rampage Was QAnon Zealot, Said She Was Putting Politicos ‘On Notice’ in Social Media Videos: WATCH

    Woman Shot to Death During Pro-Trump Capitol Rampage Was QAnon Zealot, Said She Was Putting Politicos ‘On Notice’ in Social Media Videos: WATCH

    20 hours ago
  • FOX News’ Ainsley Earhardt: I Hope That Trump ‘Will Be Able to Forgive’ Mike Pence for Not Helping Him Overturn Election: WATCH

    FOX News’ Ainsley Earhardt: I Hope That Trump ‘Will Be Able to Forgive’ Mike Pence for Not Helping Him Overturn Election: WATCH

    20 hours ago
  • Lindsey Graham, Who Has Enabled Trump for Years, Rants ‘Count Me Out, Enough is Enough, I’ve Tried to Be Helpful’ After U.S. Capitol Attack: WATCH

    Lindsey Graham, Who Has Enabled Trump for Years, Rants ‘Count Me Out, Enough is Enough, I’ve Tried to Be Helpful’ After U.S. Capitol Attack: WATCH

    21 hours ago
  • GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz Claims Violent Rioters That Stormed U.S. Capitol Were Antifa Members Dressed as Trump Supporters: WATCH

    GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz Claims Violent Rioters That Stormed U.S. Capitol Were Antifa Members Dressed as Trump Supporters: WATCH

    21 hours ago
  • Overhead Video Shows Moment Trump Mob Broke Through U.S. Capitol Barricade: WATCH

    Overhead Video Shows Moment Trump Mob Broke Through U.S. Capitol Barricade: WATCH

    21 hours ago
  • Trump Commits to Orderly Transition of Power After Pushing Violent Mob to Attack U.S. Capitol

    Trump Commits to Orderly Transition of Power After Pushing Violent Mob to Attack U.S. Capitol

    21 hours ago

Most Commented

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Footer

Copyright © 2021 ยท Log in