• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Jennifer Lopez tells Britney Spears to ‘stay strong’
  • Meta will hold the first ever drag show in the metaverse
  • Billy Eichner needed Bros to be ‘authentic’

Prop 8 and DOMA: The Amicus Brief and the Primacy of Law

Ari Ezra Waldman November 9, 2011

Amicus

BY ARI EZRA WALDMAN

In separate cases over the last few weeks, various parties have filed what laywers call amicus curiae briefs arguing that Proposition 8 and the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) are unconstitutional.

SupremecourtAmicus briefs are "friend of the court" submissions where individuals or groups with an interest in ongoing litigation but are not parties to that litigation let the court know their views. So, the Chamber of Commerce often files amicus briefs in business cases; the ACLU often submits amicus briefs in civil rights cases. Lambda Legal has had great success filing amicus briefs in gay rights cases and having their submissions quoted in final decisions.

The amicus brief recognizes that there are other people out there who will be impacted by the result in a given case, and these parties may have a unique perspective on the legal issues involved. It understands that a court's job is to search for truth, an endeavor that can usually benefit from more than merely the two perspective of adverse parties and an endeavor that is rarely possible in the political arena.

I argue that the amicus brief is yet another reason why we should ignore the minority of activists who want to return to the ballot to try to overturn Prop 8 in California.

To see the connection between the amicus brief and the primacy of a legal strategy in Perry v. Brown, I am going to use the example of an amicus brief recently filed in a DOMA case out of the First Circuit. These are different cases for sure. But, while we are not actively debating a different strategy to overturn DOMA (the current Republican House makes that impossible), the poignant examples of arguments put forth by recent amici in DOMA cases show why sticking to AFER's legal strategy in the Prop 8 case is a good idea. 

CONTINUED, AFTER THE JUMP…

StarbucksConsider the amicus brief recently filed by Google, CBS, Starbucks and approximately 70 other companies and cities that argues that DOMA is anti-business. To succeed in any competitive business environment, companies cannot discriminate and have to offer benefits and a “workplace ethos of transparent fairness." But, DOMA denies business that chance: “DOMA forces amici to investigate the gender of the spouses of our lawfully married employees and then to single out those employees with a same-​sex spouse. DOMA enforces discriminatory tax treatment of spousal health care benefits.”

DOMA is also a burdensome federal regulation that prevents business growth. Companies not only spend time, money, and energy separating out their married gay employees, they spend time, money, and energy discriminating against them. Businesses have “to maintain two sets of books [, …] and "[t]he double entries ripple through human resources, payroll, and benefits administration." In order to keep track of straight married couples, gay married couples and their varied benefits, some businesses hire outside firms: “These dual regimes have spawned an industry of costly compliance specialists." That means that "[t]he burden on the small employer is especially onerous." After all, small businesses cannot afford these extra compliance costs; therefore, “such burdens, standing alone, might chill a smaller employer from employing an otherwise qualified employee because she happens to be married to a same-​sex spouse.”

We have discussed the constitutional problems with DOMA: It violates the 10th Amendment, it interjects the federal government into an area that was previously the exclusive realm of the states, it changed federal policy toward state marriage law as opposed to enshrining the status quo while the states work out their same-sex marriage rules, and so on. We have also discussed how DOMA discriminates against legally married gay couples when it comes to tax law, immigration law, and health care law. But, the ways in which DOMA harms business and impairs job creation has never been the constiutional lawyer's primary concern.

Briefs also have page limits. Depending on what court is making the rules, primary and amicus briefs can be restricted to as few at 10 pages, leaving little room for secondary (but no less important) arguments. The amicus brief allows those important arguments that may not make it into the primary brief for whatever reason to see the light of day and, perhaps, influence the judge or panel of judges.

Amicus brief arguments have a long history of making their way into final court decisions. As the solicitor-general, future Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis pioneered not only the use of sociological evidence and data in primary briefs, but popularized the coordinated efforts of large groups of third parties that wanted to add their two cents. Amici's arguments influenced the majority in Lawrence v. Texas and even one of my amicus briefs in a case involving English-language learner funding in Arizona was quoted in a Supreme Court decision.

Why might the opportunity and power of amicus briefs counsel in favor of sticking with the successful legal strategy in Perry v. Brown rather than destroying that precedent by going to the ballot in 2012 and mooting the case?

The issue is the sanctity of truth. Amicus briefs are the legal equivalent to third-party advertisements in an election, but unlike those third-party spots, amicus briefs do not cost millions of dollars and force thid parties to be honest about their arguments. A traditional marriage advocacy group could spend a million dollars falsely arguing that overtuning Prop 8 would mean that California public schools would be teaching anal sex in health class. That demonstrably ridiculous claim could scare an ill-informed voter, but the only impact it could have on a judge is to prove how empty the anti-gay side of the case really is.

A legal strategy in the Perry case ensures that the debate over same-sex marriage in California will not be influenced by lies, distortions, and flagrant hate, all of which are available tools in an election campaign where any side can pretty much say whatever it wants. The amicus brief allows third parties, like business, labor, law professors, teachers, parents, and so on, to register their views — thereby expanding the information the court has at its disposal — at little cost and limited by the compulsion to tell the truth.

That is the kind of restriction we want.

***

Ari Ezra Waldman is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. After practicing in New York for five years and clerking at a federal appellate court in Washington, D.C., Ari is now on the faculty at California Western School of Law in San Diego, California. His research focuses on gay rights and the First Amendment. Ari will be writing weekly posts on law and various LGBT issues.

Follow Ari on Twitter at @ariezrawaldman.

Topics: Business, History, News More Posts About: Ari Ezra Waldman, DOMA, DOMA, Federal Prop 8 Trial, Law - Gay, LGBT, News, proposition 8

Related Posts
  • Russia Blocks Facebook, Accusing it of Restricting Access to Russian Media;
  • Duran Duran Has New Music And You Are About To Enjoy it. It’s 2021. Seriously.
  • ‘Mayor Pete’ Trailer; Papa Pete Pwns Tucker; 4-Stars for Dr. Rachel Levine; JoJo Siwa’s Perfect 10s; Lynda Carter’s 8 Wonder-full Words: GOOD NEWS
  • Meta will hold the first ever drag show in the metaverse

    Meta will hold the first ever drag show in the metaverse

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Meta will hold the first ever drag show in the metaverse. Facebook’s parent company is planning to throw a kiki in their virtual universe, titled ‘Queens of the Metaverse’, which will …Read More »
  • Billy Eichner needed Bros to be ‘authentic’

    Billy Eichner needed Bros to be ‘authentic’

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Billy Eichner wouldn’t have signed up for ‘Bros’ if it wasn’t “authentic to gay audiences”. The 43-year-old comedian was first approached about the movie by producer Judd Apatow and director and …Read More »
  • Michelle Visage shocked by ‘introverted’ RuPaul

    Michelle Visage shocked by ‘introverted’ RuPaul

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Michelle Visage was shocked by how much of an “introvert” RuPaul is. The ‘RuPaul’s Drag Race’ judge says the 61-year-old flamboyant drag legend and television star is actually “very reserved and …Read More »
  • U.S. House gives Biden a win with massive bill on climate change, drug prices

    U.S. House gives Biden a win with massive bill on climate change, drug prices

    Published by Reuters By David Morgan, Moira Warburton and Rose Horowitch WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The Democratic-led U.S. House of Representatives approved a $430 billion bill on Friday that is seen as the biggest climate package in U.S. …Read More »
Previous Post: « Last Night, This $4.3 Million Andreas Gursky Photograph Became the Most Expensive Ever Sold at Auction
Next Post: Eddie Murphy Out as Oscar Host »

Primary Sidebar

Adjacent News

  • Trump vs Biden again? The documents scandal makes it more likely

    Trump vs Biden again? The documents scandal makes it more likely

  • White House to circulate Afghanistan memo defending U.S. withdrawal – Axios report

    White House to circulate Afghanistan memo defending U.S. withdrawal – Axios report

  • Russian propagandists claim Moscow has been ‘studying’ Mar-a-Lago nuclear documents ‘for a while’

    Russian propagandists claim Moscow has been ‘studying’ Mar-a-Lago nuclear documents ‘for a while’

Good Trash: Going to Read It Somewhere, Y’know

  • Ellen Has Not Contacted Ex-Lover Anne Heche Following Fiery Crash Into LA Home

    Ellen Has Not Contacted Ex-Lover Anne Heche Following Fiery Crash Into LA Home

  • Pete Davidson Proposed to Kim Kardashian Before Their Breakup

    Pete Davidson Proposed to Kim Kardashian Before Their Breakup

  • New bombshell book on Trump reveals he wanted to be treated like Hitler: ‘Totally loyal’

    New bombshell book on Trump reveals he wanted to be treated like Hitler: ‘Totally loyal’

RSS Partner Links

  • Sofia Carson Dishes On If 'Purple Hearts' Will Have A Sequel
  • Gay History Lesson
  • Open Post: Hosted By The Thief Who Hid In A Giant Teddy Bear
  • The FBI Says That The Gun In The “Rust” Shooting Could Not Have Gone Off By Itself And The Trigger Was Pulled
  • Shakira Is Considering Moving Miami To Leave Behind Her Tax And Relationship Woes In Spain
  • Paulina Porizkova Responds to Plastic Surgeon Telling Her How She Should 'Fix' Her Face
  • Leslie Jordan show us his new condo!

Most Recent

  • Jennifer Lopez tells Britney Spears to ‘stay strong’

    Jennifer Lopez tells Britney Spears to ‘stay strong’

  • Meta will hold the first ever drag show in the metaverse

    Meta will hold the first ever drag show in the metaverse

  • Billy Eichner needed Bros to be ‘authentic’

    Billy Eichner needed Bros to be ‘authentic’

  • Michelle Visage shocked by ‘introverted’ RuPaul

    Michelle Visage shocked by ‘introverted’ RuPaul

  • U.S. House gives Biden a win with massive bill on climate change, drug prices

    U.S. House gives Biden a win with massive bill on climate change, drug prices

  • Robert De Niro pays tribute to ‘wonderful’ Anne Heche

    Robert De Niro pays tribute to ‘wonderful’ Anne Heche

  • Trump lawyer in June said classified material had been returned -NY Times

    Trump lawyer in June said classified material had been returned -NY Times

  • I want to spread positivity, says Billy Porter

    I want to spread positivity, says Billy Porter

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in

×