• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Politics
  • Health
  • Travel
  • Gay Pride
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Men
  • Space
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Monkeypox
  • Film/TV

Marriage Equality Comes to Oregon and Pennsylvania: An Analysis, Part II

Ari Ezra Waldman May 21, 2014

First, let's briefly review the opinion. There were three elements to Judge Jones's opinion, all of which you will remember from previous columns.

1. Baker v. Nelson no longer applies. Aclu

Baker v. Nelson was a summary dismissal of an appeal from a Minnesota Supreme Court decision that said that Minnesota law did not allow gay couples to marry and that such a law did not violate the Federal Constitution. When the Supreme Court shoots down a "summary dismissal," it is almost like ignoring it, or saying that the case does not raise any issue for a federal court to address. Judge Jones said Baker is no longer good law. Significant doctrinal developments since Baker, which was decided in 1971, have changed the landscape of minority and gay rights, in general, and marriage rights, in particular. There was no such thing as intermediate scrutiny in 1971. Antigay discrimination did not even need a rational basis until 1996 (Romer v. Evans). And, until Lawrence v. Texas in 2003, gays were still presumptive criminals. Most importantly, Windsor proved that gays marrying raises substantial federal questions. 

2. Due Process guarantees an individual the right to marry.

Judge Jones noted that the Supreme Court had found that the right to marry was fundamental many times and that the right that the "courageous" plaintiffs were seeking was not a new right, but the same right as anyone else who wants to marry the person he or she loves.

The fundamental due process right to marry is not based in the heterosexual person; it is based in the individual, whatever his or her sexual orientation. And just because tradition and custom has restricted marriage to between one man and one man, that is no reason to continue discrimination. If it had been a valid reason, marriage rights would have never evolved to include those who wanted to marry persons of a different race.

Judge Jones went on to find that there are actually two due process rights here: the right to marry and the right to remain married after crossing state lines. The marriage right would mean nothing if it could be taken away by a work trip or a vacation or a trip to grandma's house. As a result, Pennsylvania's statutes banning gays from marrying and refusing to recognize out-of-state marriages were unconstitutional.

Pennsylvania3. Antigay discrimination merits heightened scrutiny and the ban on gays marrying violates Equal Protection under that, or any, standard.

The opinion includes a rather comprehensive consideration of the applicability of heightened scrutiny. Judge Jones first notes that even though the Third Circuit in which he sits has never explicitly articulated a scrutiny level of antigay discrimination, several other district and circuit courts (including the Ninth Circuit in Abbott Labs) have required heightened scrutiny. He then noted that the Supreme Court's gay rights opinions have, at a minimum, used a scrutiny level higher than simple rational basis. Then he went through the requirements of heightened scrutiny and ultimately found that gays do merit heightened scrutiny.

None of the purported justifications for this ban — optimal parenting and promoting procreation — met this standard. But there can be no connection between the ban and these ostensibly important objectives. Judge Jones joins the 14 federal or state judges who have struck down bans on same-sex marriage, all of whom have found no legitimate connection between the law and the supposed purposes.

Judge Jones is also one in a long line of conservative and Republican-appointed judges who have struck down bans on same-sex marriage. Marriage equality not only resonates with conservatives, it also is so obviously contrary to our constitutional tradition that both liberals and conservatives can agree that the bans must go.

But his conservatism did shine through toward the end of his opinion.

To Judge Jones, and to the justices in the conservative majority that eviscerated the Civil Rights Act and allowed Michigan to ban considerations of race in admissions, our country's wretched history of discrimination is over. In a way, they're right. We no longer have laws that designated "white only" restrooms and we no longer have laws that explicitly say "women cannot vote." But we do gerrymander our districts to dilute minority votes. Conservatives make it exceedingly difficult for immigrants to vote. We still allow employers to fire someone simply for being gay. We employ many tools to make our ultimate motive — discrimination — hidden from view. We delude ourselves when we say discrimination is a thing of the past. It's not. It's just more insidious, more sneaky, more hidden today.

Judge Jones's toss away line may be of little moment. It is entirely possible that he simply meant that the days of the law approving of "separate but equal" as true equality are over. But it does suggest a greater lesson: Our string of marriage equality victories should never obscure the fact that LGBT Americans are still the victims of hate, homophobia, and institutional discrimination in many ways. Just being able to get married is not the end of the fight; it is the beginning of a long journey.

***

Follow me on Twitter and on Facebook.

Ari Ezra Waldman is a professor of law and the Director of the Institute for Information Law and Policy at New York Law School and is concurrently getting his PhD at Columbia University in New York City. He is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. Ari writes weekly posts on law and various LGBT issues.

Topics: News, Supreme Court More Posts About: Ari Ezra Waldman, Ari Ezra Waldman, gay marriage, Gay Marriage, Law - Gay, LGBT, Law - Gay, LGBT, News, Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania

Related Posts
  • Philadelphia Enquirer: Malcolm Kenyatta is the Democrats’ future, so why can’t he be their present?
  • Former Roommate Indicted For Murder Of Florida LGBTQ Activist Jorge Diaz-Johnston, One of the Public Faces In State Fight For Marriage Equality
  • Russia Blocks Facebook, Accusing it of Restricting Access to Russian Media;
  • Actor Kevin Spacey facing sexual assault charges in UK

    Actor Kevin Spacey facing sexual assault charges in UK

    Published by AFP The two-time Oscar winner was artistic director of the Old Vic London (AFP) – Hollywood actor Kevin Spacey is facing sexual assault charges in the UK, police and prosecutors said on Thursday, after …Read More »
  • Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60

    Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60. The keyboardist and founding member – who was born in Nottingham and moved to Basildon in the 70s – of the 80s band …Read More »
  • TV board dismisses Senator’s request to allow parents to shield kids from LGBTQ characters; Cites 95% Parent Satisfaction With Ratings

    TV board dismisses Senator’s request to allow parents to shield kids from LGBTQ characters; Cites 95% Parent Satisfaction With Ratings

      Published by The Kansas City Star   The TV Parental Guidelines Monitoring Board dismissed a request from Sen. Roger Marshall, a Republican from Kansas, asking them to update their ratings system so parents could shield …Read More »
  • Apple unveils new Pride Apple Watch bands and watch face

    Apple unveils new Pride Apple Watch bands and watch face

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Apple has unveiled new Pride bands and a watch face for the Apple Watch to mark Pride Month. The tech giant is releasing a Pride Edition Sport Loop and the Pride …Read More »
Previous Post: « Georgia GOP Candidate Says Gays Plot to Sodomize Children: VIDEO
Next Post: United Kingdom Deporting Lesbian Mom To Face Possible Beatings, Imprisonment, Death In Uganda »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Don McLean, Larry Gatlin Pull Out Of NRA Convention Concert In Texas

    Don McLean, Larry Gatlin Pull Out Of NRA Convention Concert In Texas

  • Trump must testify in New York probe, appeals court rules

    Trump must testify in New York probe, appeals court rules

  • Guns are now the leading cause of death for American children

    Guns are now the leading cause of death for American children

  • The staggering toll of gun violence in the United States

    The staggering toll of gun violence in the United States

Break

  • Justin Timberlake has sold his song catalogue in a deal reportedly worth 100 million dollars

    Justin Timberlake has sold his song catalogue in a deal reportedly worth 100 million dollars

  • Dyson set to preview new robots to help with tasks at home

    Dyson set to preview new robots to help with tasks at home

  • Elvis fever set to shake Cannes

    Elvis fever set to shake Cannes

  • Battle Of The Billionaires! Elon Musk SLAMS Bill Gates After Article Claims Microsoft Mogul Is Funding Musk’s Critics

    Battle Of The Billionaires! Elon Musk SLAMS Bill Gates After Article Claims Microsoft Mogul Is Funding Musk’s Critics

RSS Partner Links

  • OMG, his butt: Actor Devon Sawa in HACKS Season 2
  • OMG, LISTEN TO THIS: Dua Lipa and Young Thug team with Calvin Harris for ‘Potion’ video
  • Jacinda Ardern Delivers Harvard Commencement Speech: DEMOCRACY CAN BE FRAGILE
  • Morning Round-Up: James Scully; Jodie Foster; Jake Borelli; Andy Cohen; Ellen DeGeneres
  • eBay Is Homophobic (Literally) & Full Of Shit
  • Birthday Sluts
  • Caption Me
  • Song of the Day: 'Blasphemous Rumours' by Depeche Mode
  • Page 1 Roundup (05/27)

Most Recent

  • ‘The Reckoning Is Going To Happen’: Kevin Spacey’s Brother Slams Actor Hours After Sexual Assault Charges

    ‘The Reckoning Is Going To Happen’: Kevin Spacey’s Brother Slams Actor Hours After Sexual Assault Charges

  • Actor Kevin Spacey facing sexual assault charges in UK

    Actor Kevin Spacey facing sexual assault charges in UK

  • Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60

    Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60

  • TV board dismisses Senator’s request to allow parents to shield kids from LGBTQ characters; Cites 95% Parent Satisfaction With Ratings

    TV board dismisses Senator’s request to allow parents to shield kids from LGBTQ characters; Cites 95% Parent Satisfaction With Ratings

  • Apple unveils new Pride Apple Watch bands and watch face

    Apple unveils new Pride Apple Watch bands and watch face

  • Lithuanian parliament agrees to consider same-sex partnership bill

    Lithuanian parliament agrees to consider same-sex partnership bill

  • German minister warns against homophobia amid monkeypox outbreak

    German minister warns against homophobia amid monkeypox outbreak

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 · Log in