• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Andy Cohen Thanks Former Governor Andrew Cuomo for Having Daughter Lucy be ‘One of the First’ Gestational Surrogacies in New York
  • Honor the past and celebrate the present with PRIDE | Opinion
  • Sex and the City author Candace Bushnell ‘did not get enough in royalties’

The Marriage Equality Ruling in Idaho: A Legal Summary and Analysis

Ari Ezra Waldman May 14, 2014

Idaho's marriage laws are pretty restrictive. They neither allow gays to marry in-state nor do they recognize out of state gay marriages. Idaho nullifies legal marriages performed elsewhere, turning husbands into legal strangers.

Judge Dale takes this state of affairs and follows a path of legal reasoning well-worn over the last several years.

First up was Baker v. Nelson, a 1971 Supreme Court order that said that antigay state marriage laws do not raise federal questions applicable for a federal court. That case is no longer applicable because, as Judge Dale stated, much has changed. Since 1971, gays went from presumptive criminals (Bowers v. Hardwick) to a protected minority with constitutional rights (Romer and Lawrence) to citizens qith equal dignity (Windsor). Whereas in 1971, gays had no federal rights to speak of, that is certainly not the case now.

Flag_idahoNext up was due process.

Judge Dale takes us through a wonderfully comprehensive summary and review of the many times — 14, in fact — that the Supreme Court has called the right to marry fundamental. But she went further. The right to marry is not just fundamental; it also transcends the limiting boundaries embodied in Idaho's ban on same-sex marriages. The Court has said that the fundamental right to marry extends not just to one man and one woman, but it is blind to race, to prison confinement, money, or ability to procreate. Lawrence and Windsor ensure that the right is extended to gay persons. Therefore, Idaho's ban infringes this fundamental right.

Finally, Judge Dale address equal protection.

Here we see how equality under the law has radically changed for gays in the last couple of years. The ban on same-sex marriage is a form of antigay discrimination, or discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. In the Ninth Circuit, where Idaho sits, that kind of discrimination now gets heightened scrutiny because of the appellate court's decision in GlaxoSmithKline v. Abbott Labs. I wrote about that case here, but, in short, the court found that Windsor mandated a heightened level of scrutiny when the state discriminates against gays. In that case, a party to a patent case involving HIV drugs wanted to exclude a juror simply because he is gay. In Latta, the discrimination is against gays marrying, but the scrutiny level still applies.

For Judge Dale, this ends the story. There is no conceivable way for any state to meet the high burden of heightened scrutiny. She even notes that the state could not even meet the lowest form of review because the ban is blatantly irrational. It neither encourages heterosexuals to marry nor creates "optimal" child rearing contexts. Children are not better off in heterosexual households. It cannot stand on morality or tradition alone. As so many judge before her have stated, these ostensible justifications are not even rationally connected to banning gays from marrying, let alone closely connected to the law.

Judge Dale ordered Idaho to stop discriminating against gay couples wishing to marry. Her order goes into effect in two days. This morning she denied the state's request for a stay of the ruling. Stay tuned to Towleroad for the latest developments.

***

Follow me on Twitter and on Facebook.

Ari Ezra Waldman is a professor of law and the Director of the Institute for Information Law and Policy at New York Law School and is concurrently getting his PhD at Columbia University in New York City. He is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. Ari writes weekly posts on law and various LGBT issues.

Topics: Uncategorized More Posts About: Ari Ezra Waldman, Ari Ezra Waldman, DOMA, DOMA, gay marriage, Gay Marriage, IDAHO, Idaho, Law - Gay, LGBT, Law - Gay, LGBT

Related Posts
  • White House blasts ‘radical’ Republican abortion bans
  • New Documents On Foiled Patriot Front Attack Of Idaho LGBTQ Pride Event Show FBI Monitored Multiple Hate Groups A Year Prior
  • Former Roommate Indicted For Murder Of Florida LGBTQ Activist Jorge Diaz-Johnston, One of the Public Faces In State Fight For Marriage Equality
  • Honor the past and celebrate the present with PRIDE | Opinion

    Honor the past and celebrate the present with PRIDE | Opinion

    Published by NJ.com Some 20,000 people turned out Sunday to see the floats, decorated vehicles and marching bands at New Jersey’s Asbury Park Pride celebration. The annual event, the largest and oldest of its kind in …Read More »
  • Sex and the City author Candace Bushnell ‘did not get enough in royalties’

    Sex and the City author Candace Bushnell ‘did not get enough in royalties’

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Candace Bushnell “did not get the royalties she deserved” for ‘Sex and the City’. The 64-year-old author wrote a column for The New York Observer that was adapted into the bestselling …Read More »
  • Tom Cruise ‘Would Love to Meet Someone Special’ After 3 Divorces: ‘He Believes the Right Girl Is Out There’

    Tom Cruise ‘Would Love to Meet Someone Special’ After 3 Divorces: ‘He Believes the Right Girl Is Out There’

    Published by OK Magazine mega Tom Cruise is back on the prowl! The three-time divorced movie star has reportedly been in search of a new woman after being single for about a year. mega “Tom would …Read More »
  • Scores detained in Hong Kong on Tiananmen crackdown anniversary

    Scores detained in Hong Kong on Tiananmen crackdown anniversary

    Published by Reuters By Jessie Pang and Ben Blanchard HONG KONG/TAIPEI (Reuters) -Hong Kong police searched and detained scores of people on Sunday, including four arrested for “seditious” intent, as authorities tightened security for the 34th …Read More »
Previous Post: « Incredible Cat Saves Child from Attack by Vicious Dog: VIDEO
Next Post: Facebook ‘Kiss-In’ Launched in Response to Negative Reactions to Michael Sam Kiss »

Primary Sidebar

Adjacent News

  • Tennessee pride celebrations showcase queer joy amid neo-Nazi threats, legal attacks

    Tennessee pride celebrations showcase queer joy amid neo-Nazi threats, legal attacks

  • ‘It’s about self-care’: Lady Gaga thinks make-up can benefit mental health

    ‘It’s about self-care’: Lady Gaga thinks make-up can benefit mental health

  • Pregnant transgender man featured on cover of Glamour magazine

    Pregnant transgender man featured on cover of Glamour magazine

Good Trash: Going to Read It Somewhere, Y'know

  • Kelly Ripa Savagely Exposes Andy Cohen After He Sent Her a ‘Completely Erect’ NSFW Photo From Potential Suitor

    Kelly Ripa Savagely Exposes Andy Cohen After He Sent Her a ‘Completely Erect’ NSFW Photo From Potential Suitor

  • Elliot Page reveals he was told by A-list actor: ‘I’m going to f*** you to make you realise you aren’t gay’

    Elliot Page reveals he was told by A-list actor: ‘I’m going to f*** you to make you realise you aren’t gay’

  • Andy Cohen Admits Further Plastic Surgery Discussions Were Cut From ‘KUWTK’ Reunion Special: ‘People Would Be Really Surprised’

    Andy Cohen Admits Further Plastic Surgery Discussions Were Cut From ‘KUWTK’ Reunion Special: ‘People Would Be Really Surprised’

Partner Links

  • Prince Harry skipped the first day of the Mirror trial, he only flew in late last night
  • King Charles is giving up Llwynywermod, his 192-acre estate in Wales
  • Morning Round-Up: Elliot Page; Robert Garcia; David Burtka; Jake Shears; WeHo Pride; Julio Rodriguez & more!
  • We Have The Same Paws!
  • Putin Puppet Calls For 'Final Solution' In Ukraine

Most Recent

  • Andy Cohen Thanks Former Governor Andrew Cuomo for Having Daughter Lucy be ‘One of the First’ Gestational Surrogacies in New York

    Andy Cohen Thanks Former Governor Andrew Cuomo for Having Daughter Lucy be ‘One of the First’ Gestational Surrogacies in New York

  • Honor the past and celebrate the present with PRIDE | Opinion

    Honor the past and celebrate the present with PRIDE | Opinion

  • Sex and the City author Candace Bushnell ‘did not get enough in royalties’

    Sex and the City author Candace Bushnell ‘did not get enough in royalties’

  • Tom Cruise ‘Would Love to Meet Someone Special’ After 3 Divorces: ‘He Believes the Right Girl Is Out There’

    Tom Cruise ‘Would Love to Meet Someone Special’ After 3 Divorces: ‘He Believes the Right Girl Is Out There’

  • Scores detained in Hong Kong on Tiananmen crackdown anniversary

    Scores detained in Hong Kong on Tiananmen crackdown anniversary

  • Kim Cattrall’s ‘Stipulations’ for ‘And Just Like That’ Cameo Revealed: ‘Refused to Film With Her Former Costars’ Including Sarah Jessica Parker

    Kim Cattrall’s ‘Stipulations’ for ‘And Just Like That’ Cameo Revealed: ‘Refused to Film With Her Former Costars’ Including Sarah Jessica Parker

  • Thai PM frontrunner attends Pride parade, promising same-sex marriage, gender identity rights

    Thai PM frontrunner attends Pride parade, promising same-sex marriage, gender identity rights

  • Kim Cattrall has ‘moved on’ from Sex and the City

    Kim Cattrall has ‘moved on’ from Sex and the City

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

Footer

Copyright © 2023 · Log in

×