• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Strippers bid to unionize in Los Angeles
  • Giuliani testifies in Georgia criminal probe into 2020 U.S. election
  • U.S. prosecutors subpoena files given to Capitol attack committee -NYT

Film Review: ‘The Case Against 8’

Joseph Ehrman-Dupre June 3, 2014

Emotions run understandably high. The law firm’s offices are a revolving door of teary testimony and raucous laughter. White and Cotner pair scenes of Perry’s raw speech on the aggression she faces each day (and why she is stronger for it) with a drawn-out, serious cross examination of Stier that ends with a solemn-faced-turned-hilarious recitation of her inconsequential “About Me” section on Facebook (as though it should mean something when she takes the stand). In each instance, the plaintiffs are met with warm support from their attorneys; Olson in particular seems to love long hugs. Lawyers and the profession they practice so often seem cold, but Cotner and White are invested in seeking out the tenderness behind this case.

8KrisSandyThe depictions of the trials themselves vary based on whether cameras were allowed into the courtroom. The first trial, to which the film devotes the most time, consists of the plaintiffs and attorneys reading transcripts from that day, a narrative device which quite evocatively showcases their eloquence in the face of oppression. The directors had footage from the appeals trial with which to work, and audio of the Supreme Court justices from the final trial; still, they consistently refer back to the plaintiffs and attorneys directly, utilizing the tension that those involved felt in order to build the audience’s anticipation.

That anticipation leads to the sweetest moments, of course: the victories. One after the other, Boies, Olson, and the plaintiffs win the trials, fueling scenes of cathartic release. No moment reveals the happy break from tension so much as the the plaintiffs’ dual marriages. One panelist at the talkback described how the film’s “story is told by the expressions on people’s faces.” One look at Zarrillo and Katami’s tear-stricken cheeks says more about the fear and pain of a long-fought battle, finally released in a moment of pure joy, than words could describe. 

8LawOfficeThe Case Against 8 is not a perfect film. There are a few too many comic bits involving Boies and Olson, and we do not spend enough time at the Supreme Court. And though the filmmakers do an excellent job at crafting dramatic tension from a subject whose ending is a foregone conclusion, one cannot help but feel that the tone, so insistently hopeful about (and focused only on) marriage equality as “the gay issue,” is slightly passe. The film’s Prop 8 focus is momentous but cannot match the exhilarating speed with which states are deciding on gay marriage bans, or the importance of ENDA, LGBT homelessness, and health-based issues (often ignored in mainstream gay media). It makes it all the more clear that White and Cotner’s filmmaking, like the legal process, was constantly shifting, moving toward an unknowable outcome glimmering in the future. 

This uncertainty, while difficult, also makes for that ultimately cathartic ending, and what Ryan White described as a “bittersweet” postscript, in which the number of states still seeking marriage equality is revealed. This statement, like the outcome of The Case Against 8, does not shock or add to on-going discussions surrounding the gay rights movement. The film surrounding it, however, proves to be an undeniably worthwhile and intriguing look inside the case that revved that movement up. 

The Case Against 8 will premiere on HBO on June 23rd.

For now, check out the trailer and the film's website to find screenings near you.

Topics: Film/TV/Stream, Health, News, Supreme Court More Posts About: California, California, David Boies, david boies, Gay Marriage, gay marriage, Gay Media, Gay Media, gay rights, Gay Rights, News, Proposition 8, proposition 8, Review, Review, Ted Olson, ted olson

Related Posts
  • Newsom’s attack ad on DeSantis could be 2024 presidential preview
  • Former Roommate Indicted For Murder Of Florida LGBTQ Activist Jorge Diaz-Johnston, One of the Public Faces In State Fight For Marriage Equality
  • Disney Walkout: Employees, Allies Protest CEO’s Response To Florida’s ‘Don’t Say Gay’ Bill; “Had They Said Something It Wouldn’t Have Passed.”
  • Giuliani testifies in Georgia criminal probe into 2020 U.S. election

    Giuliani testifies in Georgia criminal probe into 2020 U.S. election

    Published by Reuters By Maria Alejandra Cardona ATLANTA (Reuters) -Rudy Giuliani, Donald Trump’s onetime personal lawyer, testified before a special grand jury in Atlanta on Wednesday in a Georgia criminal probe examining attempts by the former …Read More »
  • U.S. prosecutors subpoena files given to Capitol attack committee -NYT

    U.S. prosecutors subpoena files given to Capitol attack committee -NYT

    Published by Reuters (Reuters) – Federal prosecutors examining the role of former President Donald Trump and allies in events ahead of the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol have subpoenaed National Archives documents provided …Read More »
  • Florida prosecutor suspended by DeSantis over abortion stance sues to regain job

    Florida prosecutor suspended by DeSantis over abortion stance sues to regain job

    Published by Reuters By David Thomas (Reuters) – A Florida state attorney on Wednesday sued Governor Ron DeSantis after he was suspended earlier this month for saying he would not prosecute anyone who sought or provided …Read More »
  • Once hated by the left, FBI is now US conservatives’ evil demon

    Once hated by the left, FBI is now US conservatives’ evil demon

    Published by AFP The Federal Bureau of Investigation seal at the bureau's headquarters, the J. Edgar Hoover FBI building, in Washington Washington (AFP) – Agents of the US Federal Bureau of Investigation are used to criticism, …Read More »
Previous Post: « Jonah Hill on Anti-Gay Slur: ‘What I Said in That Moment Was Disgusting’ — VIDEO
Next Post: Adore Delano Discovers She’s Not Alone in the Relationship in ‘I Adore U’: VIDEO »

Primary Sidebar

Adjacent News

  • Biden signs $430 billion climate, healthcare and tax bill

    Biden signs $430 billion climate, healthcare and tax bill

  • Judge schedules Thursday hearing on motion to unseal Trump search warrant materials

    Judge schedules Thursday hearing on motion to unseal Trump search warrant materials

  • Dr. Oz Loses $5 Million Of GOP Campaign Funding In Pennsylvania As His Poll Numbers Continue To Plummet

    Dr. Oz Loses $5 Million Of GOP Campaign Funding In Pennsylvania As His Poll Numbers Continue To Plummet

Good Trash: Going to Read It Somewhere, Y’know

  • ‘It’s Good To Be Loved!’ Ellen DeGeneres Celebrates Anniversary With Portia de Rossi After It’s Revealed She Won’t Be Invited To Ex Anne Heche’s Funeral

    ‘It’s Good To Be Loved!’ Ellen DeGeneres Celebrates Anniversary With Portia de Rossi After It’s Revealed She Won’t Be Invited To Ex Anne Heche’s Funeral

  • New Handwritten Notes & Letter Reveal Princess Diana Predicted She May Be Killed In A ‘Staged Car Accident’

    New Handwritten Notes & Letter Reveal Princess Diana Predicted She May Be Killed In A ‘Staged Car Accident’

  • ‘I Want To Release These Voice Recordings So Bad’: NeNe Leakes Tears Into Andy Cohen As Discrimination Lawsuit Turns Nasty

    ‘I Want To Release These Voice Recordings So Bad’: NeNe Leakes Tears Into Andy Cohen As Discrimination Lawsuit Turns Nasty

RSS Partner Links

  • GALECA: The Society of LGBTQ Entertainment Critics announces winners of its 14th Dorian TV Awards
  • See Luke Evans’ beach workout!
  • Coldplay's 'Humankind' Music Video Was Filmed at Their Mexico City Concerts - Watch!
  • “Rep. Liz Cheney lost her primary to a Donald Trump fanatic” links
  • People: The Cambridges still haven’t moved into Adelaide Cottage
  • Eiza Gonzalez Didn't Let a Foot Injury Stop Her From Attending the Day of Indulgence Party!
  • Jonah Hill Reveals He Will Not Promote His Films Anymore - Here's Why

Most Recent

  • Strippers bid to unionize in Los Angeles

    Strippers bid to unionize in Los Angeles

  • Giuliani testifies in Georgia criminal probe into 2020 U.S. election

    Giuliani testifies in Georgia criminal probe into 2020 U.S. election

  • U.S. prosecutors subpoena files given to Capitol attack committee -NYT

    U.S. prosecutors subpoena files given to Capitol attack committee -NYT

  • Florida prosecutor suspended by DeSantis over abortion stance sues to regain job

    Florida prosecutor suspended by DeSantis over abortion stance sues to regain job

  • Once hated by the left, FBI is now US conservatives’ evil demon

    Once hated by the left, FBI is now US conservatives’ evil demon

  • Proud Boy files to run for a Sacramento-area school board. The GOP isn’t supporting him

    Proud Boy files to run for a Sacramento-area school board. The GOP isn’t supporting him

  • Stanford monkeypox case not sex-related, raising questions about transmission

    Stanford monkeypox case not sex-related, raising questions about transmission

  • Chicago police investigating whether racist and anti-gay posts on 4chan came from real officer

    Chicago police investigating whether racist and anti-gay posts on 4chan came from real officer

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in

×