• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Body
  • Daily Resist
  • POLITICS
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Film
  • TV
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Men
  • Marriage Equality
  • Space
  • Trans Rights
  • Books
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • TowleREAD

Federal Judge Denies South Dakota’s Motion to Dismiss Challenge to State Gay Marriage Ban

November 15, 2014 by Kyler Geoffroy

The lawsuit challenging South Dakota's marriage equality ban has received the green light from U.S. Judge Karen Schreier after she rejected the state's motion for the case to be dismissed on Friday. 

Via press release:

South dakotaIn a 28-page opinion, issued Friday afternoon, Judge Schreier agreed with the plaintiffs, writing, “Given the subsequent developments recognized almost uniformly by federal courts following the Supreme Court’s decision in Windsor, Baker is no longer binding authority. Although Bruning explained that sexual orientation is not a suspect class, it did not address whether marriage is a fundamental right. Thus, those cases do not foreclose relief on plaintiffs’ due process and equal protection claims.”

The Court will now consider the legitimacy of the marriage bans. Judge Schreier ordered state officials to respond to the plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment within ten days. The State must explain why its refusal to wed same-sex couples and its refusal to recognize out-of-state marriages of same-sex couples do not violate U.S. Constitution guarantees of due process, equal protection, and the right to travel.

Here's the current marriage map via Freedom to Marry:

Marriage map

Here's the order via Equality Case Files:

Filed Under: News Tagged With: gay marriage, News, South Dakota

Recent Posts

  • Michael Alig Dead, Nashville, L.A. COVID, Lindsey Graham, 737 Max, The Queen, Roger Stone, Joe Exotic: WEEKEND HOT LINKS

    Michael Alig Dead, Nashville, L.A. COVID, Lindsey Graham, 737 Max, The Queen, Roger Stone, Joe Exotic: WEEKEND HOT LINKS

    6 hours ago
  • Ben Sasse, Stella Tennant, Gautam Raghavan, Andrew Yang, Kirk COVIDiot Cameron, Emma Corrin: HOT LINKS

    Ben Sasse, Stella Tennant, Gautam Raghavan, Andrew Yang, Kirk COVIDiot Cameron, Emma Corrin: HOT LINKS

    2 days ago
  • Trump Appoints Anti-Gay Conversion Therapy Practitioner and Christian Extremist Marcus Bachmann (Husband of Michelle) to Advisory Panel

    Trump Appoints Anti-Gay Conversion Therapy Practitioner and Christian Extremist Marcus Bachmann (Husband of Michelle) to Advisory Panel

    2 days ago
  • Paul Manafort Issues Bootlicking Tweets, His First in 4 Years, After Trump Pardons Him Along with 25 Others

    Paul Manafort Issues Bootlicking Tweets, His First in 4 Years, After Trump Pardons Him Along with 25 Others

    2 days ago
Previous Post: « NCLR Asks Supreme Court to Review 6th Circuit Ruling Upholding Tennessee’s Gay Marriage Ban
Next Post: Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi Appeals Gay Marriage Ruling to Eleventh Circuit Court »

Primary Sidebar

  • Michael Alig Dead, Nashville, L.A. COVID, Lindsey Graham, 737 Max, The Queen, Roger Stone, Joe Exotic: WEEKEND HOT LINKS

  • Ben Sasse, Stella Tennant, Gautam Raghavan, Andrew Yang, Kirk COVIDiot Cameron, Emma Corrin: HOT LINKS

  • Trump Appoints Anti-Gay Conversion Therapy Practitioner and Christian Extremist Marcus Bachmann (Husband of Michelle) to Advisory Panel

Recent Posts

  • Michael Alig Dead, Nashville, L.A. COVID, Lindsey Graham, 737 Max, The Queen, Roger Stone, Joe Exotic: WEEKEND HOT LINKS

    Michael Alig Dead, Nashville, L.A. COVID, Lindsey Graham, 737 Max, The Queen, Roger Stone, Joe Exotic: WEEKEND HOT LINKS

    6 hours ago
  • Ben Sasse, Stella Tennant, Gautam Raghavan, Andrew Yang, Kirk COVIDiot Cameron, Emma Corrin: HOT LINKS

    Ben Sasse, Stella Tennant, Gautam Raghavan, Andrew Yang, Kirk COVIDiot Cameron, Emma Corrin: HOT LINKS

    2 days ago
  • Trump Appoints Anti-Gay Conversion Therapy Practitioner and Christian Extremist Marcus Bachmann (Husband of Michelle) to Advisory Panel

    Trump Appoints Anti-Gay Conversion Therapy Practitioner and Christian Extremist Marcus Bachmann (Husband of Michelle) to Advisory Panel

    2 days ago
  • Paul Manafort Issues Bootlicking Tweets, His First in 4 Years, After Trump Pardons Him Along with 25 Others

    Paul Manafort Issues Bootlicking Tweets, His First in 4 Years, After Trump Pardons Him Along with 25 Others

    2 days ago
  • ‘Sex and the City’ Reboot, Miley Cyrus, Nicholas Cage Swearing, Dr. Birx, Ellen’s Mask, John Thune, Jerry Falwell Jr: HOT LINKS

    ‘Sex and the City’ Reboot, Miley Cyrus, Nicholas Cage Swearing, Dr. Birx, Ellen’s Mask, John Thune, Jerry Falwell Jr: HOT LINKS

    3 days ago
  • How Many Christmas Movie Parodies Can You Count in Edmund Bagnell’s Holiday Classic? — WATCH

    How Many Christmas Movie Parodies Can You Count in Edmund Bagnell’s Holiday Classic? — WATCH

    3 days ago
  • Palm Springs Gay Clothing-Optional Resort INNdulge is Up for Sale

    Palm Springs Gay Clothing-Optional Resort INNdulge is Up for Sale

    3 days ago
  • Buffalo Gay Bar Open Since 1974 Facing Closure After Being Rejected for  COVID Relief Grant and Owner Wonders if LGBTQ Businesses Were Excluded: WATCH

    Buffalo Gay Bar Open Since 1974 Facing Closure After Being Rejected for COVID Relief Grant and Owner Wonders if LGBTQ Businesses Were Excluded: WATCH

    3 days ago
  • North Carolina Wedding Venue Tells Gay Couple to Find Somewhere Else to Get Married: WATCH

    North Carolina Wedding Venue Tells Gay Couple to Find Somewhere Else to Get Married: WATCH

    3 days ago
  • Amy Klobuchar Rips Trump Over Pardons for Criminal Cronies, Meddling in COVID Stimulus Relief: ‘This is an Attack on Every American’ — WATCH

    Amy Klobuchar Rips Trump Over Pardons for Criminal Cronies, Meddling in COVID Stimulus Relief: ‘This is an Attack on Every American’ — WATCH

    3 days ago

Most Commented

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Footer

Copyright © 2020 · Log in