Federal Judge Orders Ohio to Recognize Gay Marriages from Other States

As promised on April 4, Judge Timothy Black has issued a 45-page ruling ordering the state of Ohio to recognize same-sex marriage performed elsewhere. Black announced his ruling ahead of time to give the state to prepare an instant appeal.

T_blackThe case was brought by four gay Ohio couples suing to have their marriages recognized on birth certificates:

The couples, all of whom were legally married in other states but have ties to Ohio through their children, or soon-to-be-born children, filed a lawsuit against the state to have their marriages recognized on birth certificates. They stated that being forced to list only one parent is a violation of their rights according to the U.S. Constitution.

Black previously issued a ruling applying only to death certificates.

The Washington Blade adds:

Now that Black has handed down the decision, state officials in Ohio — Gov. John Kasich and Attorney General Mike DeWine — are expected to appeal the decision to the U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals. The officials may also independently seek a stay of the order requiring the state to recognize out-of-state same-sex marriages.

That would be consistent with actions from other state officials in Kentucky and Tennessee when faced with orders requiring those states to recognize out-of-state same-sex marriages. The Sixth Circuit already had the distinction of being the only federal appeals court where each of the four states within the circuit — Michigan, Ohio, Tennessee and Kentucky — has a marriage equality case on appeal.

Read the full ruling below:

1:14-cv-00129 #28 by Equality Case Files


  1. Ready says

    I love that the ruling is not wishy washy in any way. “…staggeringly devoid of any legitimate justification for the States ongoing arbitrary discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and therefore, Ohio’s recognition bans are facially unconstitutional and unenforceable under any circumstances”

  2. simon says

    How is the impeachment process going? The House Repugs have more reasons now to lynch this guy.

  3. TKinSC says

    “Happy Adoption Day”?? Seriously??

    But oh no, this judge called it straight down the middle. No bias on his part. Nope. None at all.

    He makes way too much use of footnotes, though.

  4. says

    That’s right, @TKINSC, better get your Happy Adoption Day cards addressed–too bad the Harvey Milk stamps aren’t out yet.

    And the court victory streak continues, to NOM’s chagrin …

  5. Randy says

    I am reading the bold-underline parts in Judge Judy’s voice. It’s very satisfying.