• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Carole Baskin’s Missing Husband’s Signature On Will Declared A Forgery By Experts As ‘Tiger King’ Star Claims Ex Was Found Alive In Costa Rica: Source
  • World ‘dangerously unprepared’ for next crisis: Red Cross
  • Brendan Fraser needed spinal surgery and knee replacement after years of stunts

California Supreme Court Overturns Ban on Same-Sex Marriage

Andy Towle May 15, 2008

Justices

Opinion (PDF)

The California Supreme Court has overturned the state’s ban on same-sex marriage in a 4-3 decision. The opinion is lengthy, and I’m just getting through it, but here’s an excerpt:

“Furthermore, in contrast to earlier times, our state now recognizes that an individual’s capacity to establish a loving and long-term committed relationship with another person and responsibly to care for and raise children does not depend upon the individual’s sexual orientation, and, more generally, that an individual’s sexual orientation — like a person’s race or gender — does not constitute a legitimate basis upon which to deny or withhold legal rights. We therefore conclude that in view of the substance and significance of the fundamental constitutional right to form a family relationship, the California Constitution properly must be interpreted to guarantee this basic civil right to all Californians, whether gay or heterosexual, and to same-sex couples as well as to opposite-sex couples.”

NewsomThe SF Chronicle reports: “The ruling set off a celebration at San Francisco City Hall. As the decision came down, out-of-breath staff members ran into the mayor’s office where Gavin Newsom read the decision. Outside the city clerk’s office, three opposite-sex couples were waiting at 10 a.m. for marriage certificates. City officials had prepared for a possible rush on certificates by same-sex couples, but hadn’t yet changed the forms that ask couples to fill out the name of the ‘bride’ and ‘groom.’ Kenton Owayang, the office supervisor for the city clerk’s office, said he’s waiting for word from the state registrar’s office about marriage forms and working on getting extra staff members in today in case the city is able to give out the certificates to same-sex couples.”

Photos from the Courthouse steps…

Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger reacted to the ruling: “…as I have said in the past, I will not support an amendment to the constitution that would overturn this state Supreme Court ruling.”

Ruling may reverberate in presidential race in favor of McCain…

Equality California to hold celebration rallies across the state…

And the portion of the opinion where they talk about why anything aside from the term “marriage” is unsatisfactory, AFTER THE JUMP…

“Under the strict scrutiny standard, unlike the rational basis standard, in order to demonstrate the constitutional validity of a challenged statutory classification the state must establish (1) that the state interest intended to be served by the differential treatment not only is a constitutionally legitimate interest, but is a compelling state interest, and (2) that the differential treatment not only is reasonably related to but is necessary to serve that compelling state interest. Applying this standard to the statutory classification here at issue, we conclude that the purpose underlying differential treatment of opposite-sex and same-sex couples embodied in California’s current marriage statutes — the interest in retaining the traditional and well-established definition of marriage — cannot properly be viewed as a compelling state interest for purposes of the equal protection clause, or as necessary to serve such an interest.

“A number of factors lead us to this conclusion. First, the exclusion of same-sex couples from the designation of marriage clearly is not necessary in order to afford full protection to all of the rights and benefits that currently are enjoyed by married opposite-sex couples; permitting same-sex couples access to the designation of marriage will not deprive opposite-sex couples of any rights and will not alter the legal framework of the institution of marriage, because same-sex couples who choose to marry will be subject to the same obligations and duties that currently are imposed on married opposite-sex couples. Second, retaining the traditional definition of marriage and affording same-sex couples only a separate and differently named family relationship will, as a realistic matter, impose appreciable harm on same-sex couples and their children, because denying such couples access to the familiar and highly favored designation of marriage is likely to cast doubt on whether the official family relationship of same-sex couples enjoys dignity equal to that of opposite-sex couples. Third, because of the widespread disparagement that gay individuals historically have faced, it is all the more probable that excluding same-sex couples from the legal institution of marriage is likely to be viewed as reflecting an official view that their committed relationships are of lesser stature than the comparable relationships of opposite-sex couples. Finally, retaining the designation of marriage exclusively for opposite-sex couples and providing only a separate and distinct designation for same-sex couples may well have the effect of perpetuating a more general premise — now emphatically rejected by this state — that gay individuals and same-sex couples are in some respects “second-class citizens” who may, under the law, be treated differently from, and less favorably than, heterosexual individuals or opposite-sex couples. Under these circumstances, we cannot find that retention of the traditional definition of marriage constitutes a compelling state interest. Accordingly, we conclude that to the extent the current California statutory provisions limit marriage to opposite-sex couples, these statutes are unconstitutional.”

Topics: Actor, News, Supreme Court More Posts About: California, California, gay marriage, News

Related Posts
  • Former Roommate Indicted For Murder Of Florida LGBTQ Activist Jorge Diaz-Johnston, One of the Public Faces In State Fight For Marriage Equality
  • Disney Walkout: Employees, Allies Protest CEO’s Response To Florida’s ‘Don’t Say Gay’ Bill; “Had They Said Something It Wouldn’t Have Passed.”
  • Russia Blocks Facebook, Accusing it of Restricting Access to Russian Media;
  • World ‘dangerously unprepared’ for next crisis: Red Cross

    World ‘dangerously unprepared’ for next crisis: Red Cross

    Published by AFP A health worker prepares a Covid booster jab for an airport worker in Bali Geneva (AFP) – All countries remain “dangerously unprepared” for the next pandemic, the Red Cross warned on Monday, saying …Read More »
  • Brendan Fraser needed spinal surgery and knee replacement after years of stunts

    Brendan Fraser needed spinal surgery and knee replacement after years of stunts

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Brendan Fraser needed spinal surgery and a partial knee replacement after spending years getting “banged up” while doing his own stunts. ‘The Mummy’ star, 54, has revealed he suffered numerous injuries …Read More »
  • New Details: Brandi Glanville Booted From ‘Real Housewives: Ultimate Girls Trip’ After ‘Unwanted Kisses’ With Caroline Manzo

    New Details: Brandi Glanville Booted From ‘Real Housewives: Ultimate Girls Trip’ After ‘Unwanted Kisses’ With Caroline Manzo

    Published by OK Magazine mega New details have emerged as to what went down between Brandi Glanville and Caroline Manzo in Morocco. Both of the former Bravo stars stopped filming for Season 4 of Real Housewives: …Read More »
  • Sixth Memphis police officer dismissed in Tyre Nichols case, local media reports

    Sixth Memphis police officer dismissed in Tyre Nichols case, local media reports

    Published by Reuters (Reuters) – A sixth Memphis police officer has been dismissed from the force for his involvement in the fatal beating of Tyre Nichols, local media reported on Monday, days after video footage of …Read More »
Previous Post: « Has Jodie Foster Split from ‘Her Beautiful Cydney’ of 14 Years?
Next Post: Oops: CNN Announces Same-Sex Marriage Ban is Upheld »

Primary Sidebar

Adjacent News

  • Secrets about Catholic priest’s 1966 murder unearthed by reporters in Buffalo

    Secrets about Catholic priest’s 1966 murder unearthed by reporters in Buffalo

  • Booker says he’ll keep trying to pass weed legislation even with House Republicans in charge

    Booker says he’ll keep trying to pass weed legislation even with House Republicans in charge

  • Madison Square Garden’s facial recognition blacklisting sparks outcry

    Madison Square Garden’s facial recognition blacklisting sparks outcry

Good Trash: Going to Read It Somewhere, Y'know

  • Jane Fonda ‘worried’ about Barbarella remake

    Jane Fonda ‘worried’ about Barbarella remake

  • Photographer insists Prince Andrew and Virginia Giuffre photo isn’t fake

    Photographer insists Prince Andrew and Virginia Giuffre photo isn’t fake

  • John Easterling pays tribute to ‘magic’ late wife Dame Olivia Newton-John

    John Easterling pays tribute to ‘magic’ late wife Dame Olivia Newton-John

RSS Partner Links

  • Adam Levine & Behati Prinsloo Welcome Third Child
  • Kanye West Is The Subject Of A Battery Investigation After Snatching A Photog’s Phone, And Kim Kardashian Scolded A Pap Who Asked Her About It In Front Of Her Kids
  • Madonna’s Biopic Reportedly Cost Universal Pictures More Than $10 Million Before They Shelved It
  • Stefanik Can't Name One Program She'd Cut Except 'Woke Agenda'
  • OMG, have you heard? Troye Sivan used to post sexy photos on Instagram
  • Austin Butler & Baz Luhrmann Attend 'Elvis' Screening in Hollywood
  • Fleshback: James Franciscus — The Naked Ape

Most Recent

  • Carole Baskin’s Missing Husband’s Signature On Will Declared A Forgery By Experts As ‘Tiger King’ Star Claims Ex Was Found Alive In Costa Rica: Source

    Carole Baskin’s Missing Husband’s Signature On Will Declared A Forgery By Experts As ‘Tiger King’ Star Claims Ex Was Found Alive In Costa Rica: Source

  • World ‘dangerously unprepared’ for next crisis: Red Cross

    World ‘dangerously unprepared’ for next crisis: Red Cross

  • Brendan Fraser needed spinal surgery and knee replacement after years of stunts

    Brendan Fraser needed spinal surgery and knee replacement after years of stunts

  • New Details: Brandi Glanville Booted From ‘Real Housewives: Ultimate Girls Trip’ After ‘Unwanted Kisses’ With Caroline Manzo

    New Details: Brandi Glanville Booted From ‘Real Housewives: Ultimate Girls Trip’ After ‘Unwanted Kisses’ With Caroline Manzo

  • Sixth Memphis police officer dismissed in Tyre Nichols case, local media reports

    Sixth Memphis police officer dismissed in Tyre Nichols case, local media reports

  • Alan Cumming admits returning CBE was a ‘complicated’ decision

    Alan Cumming admits returning CBE was a ‘complicated’ decision

  • LGBTQ people face being ‘erased’ in Michigan schools thanks to right-wing group’s legal loophole

    LGBTQ people face being ‘erased’ in Michigan schools thanks to right-wing group’s legal loophole

  • Modern Family’s Julie Bowen Crushing On Harry Styles; Reveals She Was Once In Love With A Gay Woman, “but she didn’t love me back”

    Modern Family’s Julie Bowen Crushing On Harry Styles; Reveals She Was Once In Love With A Gay Woman, “but she didn’t love me back”

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

Footer

Copyright © 2023 · Log in

×