• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Unearthed: Late Lisa Marie Presley Blames Scientology For Michael Jackson Divorce — ‘They Made Sure That I Left Him’
  • Lawsuit to take aim at Utah law banning transition care for minors
  • U.S. court rejects J&J bankruptcy strategy for tens of thousands of talc lawsuits

Hearing on Prop 8 Federal Challenge Today; NYT Profiles Ted Olson

Andy Towle August 19, 2009

Tedolson

Attorney Ted Olson is profiled in today's NYT, explaining how he came about taking on the case against Proposition 8:

"Given the traditional battle lines on the issue, Mr. Olson’sdecision to file a lawsuit challenging California’s recent ban onsame-sex marriage has stirred up stereotype-rattled suspicion on bothsides. 'For conservatives who don’t like what I’m doing, it’s,‘If he just had someone in his family we’d forgive him,’' Mr. Olsonsaid. 'For liberals it’s such a freakish thing that it’s, ‘He must havesomeone in his family, otherwise a conservative couldn’t possibly havethese views.’ It’s frustrating that people won’t take it on face value.'"”

Ted Olson's "Supreme Court Adventure" is also taken up by Eugene Volokh, U.C.L.A. Law School, Kenji Yoshino, N.Y.U. School of Law, Amy Wax, University of Pennsylvania Law School, and Evan Wolfson, Freedom to Marry, in the paper's Room for Debate column.

Olson_boies At 10 am this morning, a hearing regarding the challenge to Prop 8 brought by Olson, Boies, and the American Foundation for Equal Rights will be held in San Francisco, according to a media advisory:

In documents filed with the court in advance of the hearing, defenders of Proposition 8 cited slain San Francisco Supervisor Harvey Milk as evidence that LGBT political power is “substantial” enough to undermine plaintiffs’ constitutional challenges to Prop. 8. They also question the quality of LGBT families and say Proposition 8 is appropriate because discrimination against the LGBT community is “increasingly rare.”

At the hearing, attorneys Olson and Boies – on behalf of plaintiffs Kris Perry & Sandy Stier, and Paul Katami & Jeff Zarrillo — will argue for a proceeding that demonstrates that Proposition 8 is unconstitutional “under any standard of review,” and that any facts that cannot be resolved in plaintiffs’ favor as a matter of law be decided through a full and public trial. Defenders of Proposition 8 say “a trial is not necessary , ” even as to hotly disputed facts.

"Granting the right to marry would not damage, inhibit, or impair any rights of individuals who wish to marry persons of the opposite sex or otherwise impair any legitimate state interest. Prop. 8 is therefore unconstitutional under any standard of review," Olson and Boies wrote in court filings.

Despite their call for a 'paper' trial, defendants are asking that the judge not hear oral arguments until July 2010 at the earliest, while Olson and Boies, citing the ongoing violation of constitutional rights caused by Proposition 8, are requesting a trial starting in December 2009.

The Defenders of Prop. 8 “urge the Court not to follow the steps through which trial courts traditionally build factual records and decide cases— discovery, followed by motions for summary judgment, followed by trial,” according to papers filed with the court by Olson and Boies. A paper trial of disputed facts is “neither just nor efficient. It would deprive Plaintiffs of the opportunity to build a complete factual record, to present their case through live witness testimony, and to cross-examine in open court those who seek to defend and justify the denial of their constitutional rights. It would similarly deprive the Court of the opportunity to question fact and expert witnesses and to assess their credibility in Court.”

This is the second hearing in the case since it was filed in late May. In an order issued just prior to the July 2 hearing, Judge Vaughn R. Walker of the U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, said: "Given that serious questions are raised in these proceedings … the court is inclined to proceed directly and expeditiously to the merits of plaintiffs' claims. … The just, speedy and inexpensive determination of these issues would appear to call for proceeding promptly to trial.”

Perry, Stier, Katami and Zarrillo comprise two same-sex couples who wish to be married but, because of Proposition 8, have been denied marriage licenses.

“This unequal treatment of gays and lesbians denies them the basic liberties and equal protection under the law that are guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution,” their suit states.

According to the suit, Proposition 8: Violates the Due Process Clause by impinging on fundamental liberties; Violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment; Singles out gays and lesbians for a disfavored legal status, thereby creating a category of “second-class citizens.”; Discriminates on the basis of gender; Discriminates on the basis of sexual orientation.

More details on the case (regarding attys Olson and Boies, and the plaintiffs), as described by the advisory, AFTER THE JUMP…

ADVISORY, CONT….

Olson is a former U.S. Solicitor General who represented George W. Bush in 2000’s Bush v. Gore, which decided the presidential election. Boies represented Al Gore in that case. Olson, widely regarded as one of the nation’s preeminent constitutional lawyers, has argued 55 cases in the U.S. Supreme Court. Boies ranks as one of the leading trial lawyers of his generation, having secured landmark victories for clients in numerous areas of the law. This is the first time they have served alongside each other as co-counsel.

“More than 30 years ago, the United States Supreme Court recognized that marriage is one of the basic rights of man,” the suit states, referring to the Court’s decision in Loving v. Virginia, which struck down bans on interracial marriage.

Kris Perry and Sandy Stier have been together for 9 years and are the parents of four boys. Perry is Executive Director of First 5 California, a state agency that promotes education and health for children under five. She holds a BA from UC Santa Cruz and an MSW from San Francisco State University. Stier is Information Technology Director for the Alameda County Behavioral Health Care Services Agency. She is originally from Iowa and is a graduate of the University of Iowa.

Perry and Stier first tried to marry in 2004, after the City of San Francisco began issuing licenses. They live in Berkeley, CA. Paul Katami and Jeff Zarrillo have been together for 8 years. Katami is a fitness expert and business owner who graduated from Santa Clara University before receiving his graduate degree from UCLA. Zarrillo is the General Manager of a theater exhibition company. A native of New Jersey, Zarrillo graduated from Montclair State University. Having wanted to marry each other for more than two years, they considered options including traveling to other states for a “civil union,” but felt any alternative fell short of marriage. They live in Burbank, CA.

They have issued the following joint statement: “We and our relationships should be treated equally under the law. Our goal is to advance the cause of equality for all Americans, which is the promise that makes this nation so great.”

Topics: Business, News, Travel More Posts About: California, California, david boies, gay marriage, News, proposition 8, ted olson

Related Posts
  • Former Roommate Indicted For Murder Of Florida LGBTQ Activist Jorge Diaz-Johnston, One of the Public Faces In State Fight For Marriage Equality
  • Disney Walkout: Employees, Allies Protest CEO’s Response To Florida’s ‘Don’t Say Gay’ Bill; “Had They Said Something It Wouldn’t Have Passed.”
  • Russia Blocks Facebook, Accusing it of Restricting Access to Russian Media;
  • Lawsuit to take aim at Utah law banning transition care for minors

    Lawsuit to take aim at Utah law banning transition care for minors

    Published by Reuters By Brad Brooks (Reuters) – The legal director of a leading LGBTQ advocacy group on Monday said he is preparing a lawsuit to ask courts to block a new Utah law that prohibits …Read More »
  • U.S. court rejects J&J bankruptcy strategy for tens of thousands of talc lawsuits

    U.S. court rejects J&J bankruptcy strategy for tens of thousands of talc lawsuits

    Published by Reuters By Tom Hals, Mike Spector and Dan Levine (Reuters) -A U.S. appeals court upended Johnson & Johnson’s attempt to offload into bankruptcy tens of thousands of lawsuits over its talc products, ruling the …Read More »
  • Michael Jackson’s Son Prince ‘Couldn’t Be Happier’ His Cousin Is Playing The Famed Singer In Upcoming Biopic

    Michael Jackson’s Son Prince ‘Couldn’t Be Happier’ His Cousin Is Playing The Famed Singer In Upcoming Biopic

    Published by OK Magazine @jaafarjackson/instagram-jourdynn Jackson;mega Jaafar Jackson will represent his uncle’s honor in the upcoming biopic, Michael. The thrilling film — directed by Antoine Fuqua and produced by Oscar winner Graham Kingwill — will portray …Read More »
  • Judge blocks New Jersey ban on guns at beaches, casinos

    Judge blocks New Jersey ban on guns at beaches, casinos

    Published by Reuters By Brendan Pierson (Reuters) – A federal judge on Monday blocked New Jersey’s recently enacted bans on carrying guns at beaches or casinos, though she left in place other restrictions passed by the …Read More »
Previous Post: « Richard Hatch Arrested Again After Matt Lauer Interview
Next Post: White House Considers ‘Nuclear Option’ Go-It-Alone on Health Care? »

Primary Sidebar

Adjacent News

  • Principal orders librarian to take down Holocaust survivor’s famous quote

    Principal orders librarian to take down Holocaust survivor’s famous quote

  • Former FBI official warns of right-wing violence akin to ‘violent Islamic jihad’

    Former FBI official warns of right-wing violence akin to ‘violent Islamic jihad’

  • Editorial: The right’s meltdown over M&Ms reveals more than just a chocolatey center

    Editorial: The right’s meltdown over M&Ms reveals more than just a chocolatey center

Good Trash: Going to Read It Somewhere, Y'know

  • Stormy Daniels takes victory lap after Trump pens tirade about her on Truth Social

    Stormy Daniels takes victory lap after Trump pens tirade about her on Truth Social

  • ‘He Was Consumed With Sadness’: Lisa Marie Presley ‘Destroyed’ Ex-Husband Michael Jackson With Shock Divorce Filing

    ‘He Was Consumed With Sadness’: Lisa Marie Presley ‘Destroyed’ Ex-Husband Michael Jackson With Shock Divorce Filing

  • Jane Fonda ‘worried’ about Barbarella remake

    Jane Fonda ‘worried’ about Barbarella remake

RSS Partner Links

  • Rhiannon Ally and DeMarco Morgan May Replace Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes On “GMA3” And It’s Causing Drama
  • Every Superman Movie & TV Show, Ranked
  • Nia Long Tells Drew Barrymore That She Wasn’t Selected For The “Charlie’s Angels” Movie Because She Looked “Too Old” And “Too Sophisticated”
  • Morning Man Classic: James Franciscus!
  • Hot Killers + Rugby Vet: I'M GAY + Santos Quits Committees — What's Next? + NeNe's Son Teases Homosexuality, Homosexuals + Reminder That Paris Hilton Sucks + MORE! — 12-PACK
  • OMG send it back: Alan Cumming returns Order of the British Empire
  • Marvel's 'Agatha: Coven of Chaos' TV Series - 12 Big Stars Joining & Returning to Cast!

Most Recent

  • Unearthed: Late Lisa Marie Presley Blames Scientology For Michael Jackson Divorce — ‘They Made Sure That I Left Him’

    Unearthed: Late Lisa Marie Presley Blames Scientology For Michael Jackson Divorce — ‘They Made Sure That I Left Him’

  • Lawsuit to take aim at Utah law banning transition care for minors

    Lawsuit to take aim at Utah law banning transition care for minors

  • U.S. court rejects J&J bankruptcy strategy for tens of thousands of talc lawsuits

    U.S. court rejects J&J bankruptcy strategy for tens of thousands of talc lawsuits

  • Michael Jackson’s Son Prince ‘Couldn’t Be Happier’ His Cousin Is Playing The Famed Singer In Upcoming Biopic

    Michael Jackson’s Son Prince ‘Couldn’t Be Happier’ His Cousin Is Playing The Famed Singer In Upcoming Biopic

  • Judge blocks New Jersey ban on guns at beaches, casinos

    Judge blocks New Jersey ban on guns at beaches, casinos

  • Florida pastor clashes with DeSantis over Black history courses and vows to host them in his church

    Florida pastor clashes with DeSantis over Black history courses and vows to host them in his church

  • ‘What’s The Big Deal?’: Ex-‘RHOA’ Star NeNe Leakes Says Son Brent Told Her He’s Not Gay After Viral TikTok Challenge

    ‘What’s The Big Deal?’: Ex-‘RHOA’ Star NeNe Leakes Says Son Brent Told Her He’s Not Gay After Viral TikTok Challenge

  • Rock Hudson’s Double Life: Arranged Marriage & Secret Male Lovers — How His Inner Circle Attempted To Keep His Gay Scandal Buried

    Rock Hudson’s Double Life: Arranged Marriage & Secret Male Lovers — How His Inner Circle Attempted To Keep His Gay Scandal Buried

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

Footer

Copyright © 2023 · Log in

×