• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox

The Westboro Baptist Church, Democracy and Death: Persistent, Omnipresent Questions Surround Supreme Court Case

Andrew Belonsky October 6, 2010

"In our nation, as in nearly every culture and religious tradition, proper burials play a crucial role in helping the bereaved mourn the dead," declare 42 politically opposed Senators, like Harry Reid, Mitch McConnell and Al Franken. "The disruption of a funeral interferes with the necessary emotional process of grieving, and thus can inflict severe psychological and even physical distress on the bereaved. In recognition of the vulnerability of mourners, American courts have long recognized a 'right' to a decent burial."

As proof of this legal note, the Senators point out that Congress, as well as 42 states, have already enacted laws denoting which times and places people can demonstrate outside of funerals. These laws are not, they insist, contradictory to the principle of free speech.

So here we have two complex concepts: the First Amendment and the "necessary emotional process" that comes with death. The former concept is distinctly Democratic, while the latter more collective in nature, and far more inevitable.

Everyone, regardless of their ideologies and voting record, will die, and we will all mourn someone who has died. Which concept, then, is more worthy of being protected: the right to say outrageous things or the "right" to mourn someone in private? Does death, ever-worthy of respect, warrant a "no free speech zone," however temporary? Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg today wondered aloud whether the First Amendment would tolerate the Church "exploiting this bereaved family."

Though the Westboro case, like Stephen Colbert's Congressional testimony, should be cheered as an example of democracy and civic discourse in action, the essential, elementary question cannot be ignored: Are laws created to sustain man or to constrain him? Are they a civilizing force, or an organic outgrowth of the general will? Do we have laws because we're naturally social creatures or because man's naturally ill-tempered and violent?

A recent study suggests that early man was indeed kindhearted. Does that mean our society, with its scores of fundamentalists and wing-nuts, went wrong somewhere?

 

Dead-soldiers-33439451

The Westboro Baptist Church's appearance before the Supreme Court today truly embodies this nation's democratic ideals: opposing sides, with extremely different, vocal opinions, are given a chance to present their case before the highest court in the land, thus proving that little people have a place in government, too.

Of course, dig a little deeper and more fundamental debates begin to rear their head, one that's unique to the democratic challenge and one that's a bit more universal. It turns out these two elements come to blows, presenting Americans with perennial questions about free speech, death and the meaning of laws.

Much of the debate surrounding the Westboro Baptist Church has revolved around free speech. Was the Westboro Baptist Church entitled to bring signs reading "Thank God for Dead Soldiers" and "Fags Burn" to fallen soldier Matthew Snyder's funeral?

A jury originally answered in the negative, and awarded Snyder's family nearly $11 million in damages for the Church's actions. The WBC appealed, of course, eventually sending the case to the Justices.

The ACLU, 21 media outlets, including representatives from the New York Times and the Associated Press, and Free Speech scholars all issued briefs on behalf of the WBC's First Amendment rights. Most reasonable people would consider the funeral protests conducted by members of the Westboro Baptist Church to be inexplicable and hateful," reads the brief submitted by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.

Without a doubt, the church’s message of intolerance is deeply offensive to many, and especially so to gay Americans, Catholics, veterans, and the families of those who sacrificed their lives defending the United States. But to silence a fringe messenger because of the distastefulness of the message is antithetical to the First Amendment’s most basic precepts.

Yes, their brief addresses the case's "repugnant" details, a dead soldier's funeral, the signatories are quite clear in spelling out their Constitutional concern: "The particular facts of this case should not be used to fashion a First Amendment exemption for offensive speech." Over three dozen U.S. Senators see the matter through a more apolitical lens.

Topics: News, Supreme Court More Posts About: Albert Snyder, Albert Snyder Supreme Court, News, westboro baptist church, Westboro Baptist Church Supreme Court

Related Posts
  • Russia Blocks Facebook, Accusing it of Restricting Access to Russian Media;
  • Duran Duran Has New Music And You Are About To Enjoy it. It’s 2021. Seriously.
  • ‘Mayor Pete’ Trailer; Papa Pete Pwns Tucker; 4-Stars for Dr. Rachel Levine; JoJo Siwa’s Perfect 10s; Lynda Carter’s 8 Wonder-full Words: GOOD NEWS
  • Black gun owners to gain from Supreme Court overturning of New York license to carry weapons law

    Black gun owners to gain from Supreme Court overturning of New York license to carry weapons law

    Published by New York Daily News NEW YORK — Black people are more likely to be jailed for weapons possession than other New Yorkers — giving public defenders and civil rights advocates reason to support last …Read More »
  • Leaders at G7 mock bare-chested horseback rider Putin

    Leaders at G7 mock bare-chested horseback rider Putin

    Published by Reuters SCHLOSS ELMAU, Germany (Reuters) – Leaders of the Group of Seven wealthy nations mocked the macho image of their absent adversary Vladimir Putin on Sunday, at a meeting in Germany dominated by the …Read More »
  • Turkey police break up Istanbul Pride march, detain dozens: AFP

    Turkey police break up Istanbul Pride march, detain dozens: AFP

    Published by Al-Araby Turkish police on Sunday forcibly intervened in a Pride march in Istanbul, detaining dozens of demonstrators and an AFP photographer, AFP journalists on the ground said. The governor’s office had banned the march …Read More »
  • Raiders‘ Carl Nassib Salutes Pride Month With Charity Effort

    Raiders‘ Carl Nassib Salutes Pride Month With Charity Effort

    Published by Sports Illustrated By Thomas Neumann Nassib commemorated Pride Month by revealing a charitable donation on Instagram. View the original article to see embedded media. Carl Nassib is a leader on and off the field …Read More »
Previous Post: « ‘Jewish Standard’ Publisher: ‘We May Have Acted Too Quickly’ With Gay Announcement Ban, Will Reconsider
Next Post: News: Stonewall Defenses, Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s Loss And Stereotypical Injustice »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Billie Eilish tells Glastonbury fans to scream away anxieties at history making headline slot

    Billie Eilish tells Glastonbury fans to scream away anxieties at history making headline slot

  • Landmark gun-safety bill heads to U.S. House after Senate passage

    Landmark gun-safety bill heads to U.S. House after Senate passage

  • Prosecutors seek 25-year prison sentence for Chauvin over breach of Floyd’s rights

    Prosecutors seek 25-year prison sentence for Chauvin over breach of Floyd’s rights

RSS Partner Links

  • Pink Has A Biting Message For Fans Who Support Supreme Court Abortion Ruling
  • Rudy Guiliani Was Slapped By Supermarket Worker on Staten Island
  • President Biden: The Dobbs decision ‘must not be the final word. This is not over.’
  • AG Garland: DOJ will protect & ensure access to abortion medication
  • Sutton Foster Has COVID-19; Will Miss Performances of 'The Music Man'
  • Lizzo & Billy Porter Made Fashionable & Dramatic Entrances To BET Awards 2022
  • Open Post: Hosted By The Dog Who Tried To Compete In A Soccer Game

Most Recent

  • Turn UP VOLUME  To Feel A Bit Better: Olivia Rodrigo And Lily Allen Dedicate F*** You Song to 6 Justices Of The Supreme Court At Glastonbury  Festival

    Turn UP VOLUME To Feel A Bit Better: Olivia Rodrigo And Lily Allen Dedicate F*** You Song to 6 Justices Of The Supreme Court At Glastonbury Festival

  • Black gun owners to gain from Supreme Court overturning of New York license to carry weapons law

    Black gun owners to gain from Supreme Court overturning of New York license to carry weapons law

  • Leaders at G7 mock bare-chested horseback rider Putin

    Leaders at G7 mock bare-chested horseback rider Putin

  • Turkey police break up Istanbul Pride march, detain dozens: AFP

    Turkey police break up Istanbul Pride march, detain dozens: AFP

  • Raiders‘ Carl Nassib Salutes Pride Month With Charity Effort

    Raiders‘ Carl Nassib Salutes Pride Month With Charity Effort

  • At Pride parades, revelry turns to resistance after Roe v. Wade reversal

    At Pride parades, revelry turns to resistance after Roe v. Wade reversal

  • Half Of LGBT People Have Symptoms Of Anxiety: Census

    Half Of LGBT People Have Symptoms Of Anxiety: Census

  • Anderson Cooper: Shirtless Richard Gere made me realise I was gay

    Anderson Cooper: Shirtless Richard Gere made me realise I was gay

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in