• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Body
  • Daily Resist
  • POLITICS
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Film
  • TV
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Men
  • Marriage Equality
  • Space
  • Trans Rights
  • Books
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • TowleREAD

Challenging Marriage Equality: The Case of Conservatives v. Albany

November 30, 2011 by Ari Ezra Waldman

An anti-group, misleadingly named "New Yorkers for Constitutional Freedoms," sued to invalidate the Marriage Equality Law in New York because in passing and signing the law, the state legislature and the governor violated state law. The group has two arguments:

CuomoFirst, Article III, Section 14 of the state constitution requires that all bills under consideration be held for three days before any vote. The only exception is when the governor certifies specific facts that require the legislature to act immediately. In the case of the Marriage Equality Act, Governor Cuomo did certify such facts, but the judge called that certification plainly "disingenuous." The plaintiffs argued that the the Governor's reasons — that continued discrimination against gay couples mandates immediate action — is illogical, especially given that gays have been excluded from the institution of marriage for hundreds of years already.

Second, Article III, Section 10 of the state constitution requires that legislative sessions be kept open to the public unless deliberations require secrecy for the benefit of the public welfare. The lawsuit argues that secret negotiations with Republicans, a closed chamber, and other secret meetings aimed at getting the law passed violated this open meeting requirement.

The arguments' merits were not discussed in this decision. In fact, the judge belied his occasional sarcastic and sharp distaste for Albany's shenanigans by suggesting that his hands are tied to accept the Governor's supposedly "disingenuous" certification and by dismissing Attorney General Eric Schneiderman from the case entirely. At issue at this stage was the State's motion to dismiss, in which the State argued that the Governor's certification of immediacy and the fact that the full legislative chamber was indeed open to the public mean that there are neither issues of fact or law to be discussed further. The judge disagreed. He said he did not have enough information to decide the case in either party's favor, so he allowed the case to continue to the discovery phase.

Letting this lawsuit proceed is not a step back, but a slight detour. It is — and should be — hard to win a motion to dismiss. For a court to dismiss a lawsuit at this early stage is to declare that there is absolutely no issue to discuss. A judge has to take the facts alleged in the plaintiff's complaint as true, even if they are complete and utter lies, and decide if there is even a small issue to discuss further.

NyBut regardless of discovery and any further arguments, it is hard to imagine this lawsuit going anywhere. State law is explicitly clear that the Governor's certification of immediacy must list facts that require tossing the three day waiting period, but there are no restrictions on that certification. Courts have interpreted a specificity requirement and a good faith requirement, but the judge's view that continued anti-gay discrimination could not be sufficient is a simple disagreement of policy, not a basis on which to challenge the Governor's good faith. The essence of judging is to not replace legislative policy preferences with your own, so the judge will be hamstrung to do anything but accept the Governor's call for waiving the three day delay. As for the second argument, some meetings were indeed private. But, the open meetings law does not explicitly require that every meeting of more than one person be open to every Joe, Tim, and Sally who's interested. Nor is it meant to uproot the entire legislative process. To invalidate one law on the grounds that some people conducted some closed door meetings would set a dangerous precedent that could invalidate nearly every law Albany passes, including every budget since the 1950s, the law that sent computer money to certain public schools, and the law that named a state building after the Rev. Diaz.

Attacking Albany is a favorite New York political ploy. Albany is "broken," "deadlocked," "dominated by elitists," "corrupt," "hopeless," and so on. Before the highly effective and moderate Governor Cuomo, Albany was a bastion of smoke-filled rooms and partisan bickering. So, attacking gay equality through the Albany lens is a good tactic. And, yet, it is a desperate one. The plaintiffs in this case are barely hiding their anti-gay rhetoric behind passionate sanctimony about the importance of public access to the legislative process, and they marshall arguments that have no hope of succeeding lest we overturn every New York State law since Andrew Cuomo was a baby. That is not going to happen.

***

Ari Ezra Waldman is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. After practicing in New York for five years and clerking at a federal appellate court in Washington, D.C., Ari is now on the faculty at California Western School of Law in San Diego, California. His research focuses on gay rights and the First Amendment. Ari will be writing weekly posts on law and various LGBT issues.

Follow Ari on Twitter at @ariezrawaldman.

Filed Under: Andrew Cuomo, New York, News Tagged With: Andrew Cuomo, gay marriage, New York, News

Recent Posts

  • Pete Buttigieg Bothered to Be in Trump’s Dreams: ‘I Want Absolutely Nothing to Do With Them’ — WATCH

    Pete Buttigieg Bothered to Be in Trump’s Dreams: ‘I Want Absolutely Nothing to Do With Them’ — WATCH

    7 hours ago
  • Impeachment Vote, Dua Lipa, Human Rainbow, Annette Bening, Danny Aiello, Baseball, Elizabeth Warren: HOT LINKS

    Impeachment Vote, Dua Lipa, Human Rainbow, Annette Bening, Danny Aiello, Baseball, Elizabeth Warren: HOT LINKS

    9 hours ago
  • Fishermen Save Bald Eagle Caught in the Grip of a Giant Octopus: WATCH

    Fishermen Save Bald Eagle Caught in the Grip of a Giant Octopus: WATCH

    11 hours ago
  • Gabon Bans Gay Sex, Penalizes it with 6 Month Prison Term

    Gabon Bans Gay Sex, Penalizes it with 6 Month Prison Term

    12 hours ago
Previous Post: « We’re Gonna Need a Bigger Boat: VIDEO
Next Post: ‘Ex-Gay’ Organization ‘Exodus International’ on Verge of Collapse? »

Reader Interactions

Primary Sidebar

Ptown Hacks 2019

download ptown Hacks

Recent Posts

  • Pete Buttigieg Bothered to Be in Trump’s Dreams: ‘I Want Absolutely Nothing to Do With Them’ — WATCH

    Pete Buttigieg Bothered to Be in Trump’s Dreams: ‘I Want Absolutely Nothing to Do With Them’ — WATCH

    7 hours ago
  • Impeachment Vote, Dua Lipa, Human Rainbow, Annette Bening, Danny Aiello, Baseball, Elizabeth Warren: HOT LINKS

    Impeachment Vote, Dua Lipa, Human Rainbow, Annette Bening, Danny Aiello, Baseball, Elizabeth Warren: HOT LINKS

    9 hours ago
  • Fishermen Save Bald Eagle Caught in the Grip of a Giant Octopus: WATCH

    Fishermen Save Bald Eagle Caught in the Grip of a Giant Octopus: WATCH

    11 hours ago
  • Gabon Bans Gay Sex, Penalizes it with 6 Month Prison Term

    Gabon Bans Gay Sex, Penalizes it with 6 Month Prison Term

    12 hours ago
  • Ridiculous Michael Bloomberg Campaign Dance Goes Viral: WATCH

    Ridiculous Michael Bloomberg Campaign Dance Goes Viral: WATCH

    12 hours ago
  • New Argentine President’s Drag Queen Son Rocked a Rainbow Flag Pocket Square at the Inauguration This Week: WATCH

    New Argentine President’s Drag Queen Son Rocked a Rainbow Flag Pocket Square at the Inauguration This Week: WATCH

    13 hours ago
  • Mitch McConnell to Hannity: ‘We All Know How it’s Going to End … No Chance the President’s Gonna Be Removed from Office’ — WATCH

    Mitch McConnell to Hannity: ‘We All Know How it’s Going to End … No Chance the President’s Gonna Be Removed from Office’ — WATCH

    13 hours ago
  • House to Approve Articles of Impeachment Against Donald J. Trump: WATCH LIVE

    House to Approve Articles of Impeachment Against Donald J. Trump: WATCH LIVE

    14 hours ago
  • Larry Kramer, Trans Model Search, Eric Holder, Lachlan Murdoch, ‘In The Heights’ Movie, Pete Buttigieg, Vassar: HOT LINKS

    Larry Kramer, Trans Model Search, Eric Holder, Lachlan Murdoch, ‘In The Heights’ Movie, Pete Buttigieg, Vassar: HOT LINKS

    1 day ago
  • GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz Called Out for DUI After Ripping Hunter Biden for Substance Abuse in Impeachment Hearing: WATCH

    GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz Called Out for DUI After Ripping Hunter Biden for Substance Abuse in Impeachment Hearing: WATCH

    1 day ago
  • Trump Supporters Warn of Civil War, Violence if He is Removed from Office: WATCH

    Trump Supporters Warn of Civil War, Violence if He is Removed from Office: WATCH

    2 days ago
  • Trump Lauds Confirmation of Anti-LGBTQ Extremist Lawrence VanDyke to 9th Circuit

    Trump Lauds Confirmation of Anti-LGBTQ Extremist Lawrence VanDyke to 9th Circuit

    2 days ago
  • Supermassive Black Hole at the Center of our Galaxy May Have a Friend

    Supermassive Black Hole at the Center of our Galaxy May Have a Friend

    2 days ago
  • Greta Thunberg Responds After Trump Tells Her to Work on Her ‘Anger Management’

    Greta Thunberg Responds After Trump Tells Her to Work on Her ‘Anger Management’

    2 days ago
  • Mike Pence Refuses to Declassify Call with Ukrainian President

    Mike Pence Refuses to Declassify Call with Ukrainian President

    2 days ago

Ptown Hacks 2019. Download Now!

Follow @PtownHacks on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter and sign up for the Ptown Hacks email list.

Most Commented

Footer

Read

  • Politics
  • Travel
  • Film
  • Theatre
  • Television
  • Science
  • Law – LGBT Rights
  • Columns
  • Specials

About

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2019 · News Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in