• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox

Tenth Circuit to Hear Challenge to Utah’s Gay Marriage Ban Tomorrow: A Preview of the Players

Lisa Keen, Keen News Service April 9, 2014

BY LISA KEEN / Keen News Service

The Tenth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals this week will become the second federal appeals court to tackle the question of whether statewide laws banning same-sex couples from marrying violate the U.S. Constitution.
The Denver-based court will hear oral arguments Thursday, April 10, at 10 a.m. MDT in the Utah same-sex marriage case Herbert v. Kitchen.

ShelbyBy order of the court, there will be no audio or video recording, broadcasting, photography, blogging, tweeting, emailing or any other broadcast mechanism or wireless communication anywhere in the courthouse during oral arguments.

In that crowded courtroom, a three-judge panel will scrutinize the decision last December of U.S. District Court Judge Robert Shelby (pictured, an Obama appointee). Shelby ruled that the state constitution’s definition of marriage as being only between “a man and a woman” is not permissible under the U.S. Constitution. He said the law’s prohibition of same-sex couples marrying violates the due process and equal protection guarantees of the U.S. Constitution. He said the ban denies gay and lesbian citizens their “fundamental right to marry and, in doing so, demean[s] the dignity of these same-sex couples for no rational reason.”

While this case is the first to reach a federal appeals court since the Ninth Circuit heard Brown v. Perry in 2012, it is just one of almost a dozen that have reached the federal appeals level. They are spread across five circuits. The Utah Kitchen case is a pacesetter at the moment. And here’s a look at the players in Thursday’s hearing:

TenthcircuitThe judges: The three-judge panel tasked with hearing the appeal includes two Republican and one Democratic appointee.

Judge Paul Kelly (an appointee of President George H.W. Bush) is considered conservative.

Judge Carlos Lucero (a Clinton appointee) is considered liberal. But both judges voted with the majority at the Tenth Circuit in the Hobby Lobby v. Sebelius case. They said the owners of the retail store were allowed, under the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act and the First Amendment free exercise clause, to cite their religious beliefs in order to deny contraceptive services in their health plans under the Affordable Care Act.

Judge Jerome Holmes (a George W. Bush appointee) is the wild card. He was recused from the Hobby Lobby case. He was one of two judges in the Tenth Circuit to deny an emergency request from the state of Utah to stay a district court decision pending appeal. They said a stay was “not warranted.”

The attorneys: Attorneys for the two parties in the case – the state of Utah and the plaintiff couples—have 30 minutes each to present their arguments.

TomsicPeggy Tomsic, a lawyer at the private Salt Lake City firm of Magleby & Greenwood, will be presenting arguments for the plaintiff couples. According to the Salt Lake City Tribune, Tomsic asked her life partner Cindy Bateman to marry her shortly after Shelby issued his decision. She and her law firm partner Jim Magleby (straight and married) are known for taking on large, complicated cases. Most recently, they won a $134 million award against PacificCorp, one of the leading utility companies on the west coast.

SchaerrGene Schaerr, who was hired by the state attorney general’s in January specifically to lead Utah’s defense of the marriage ban, will argue for the state and Governor Gary Herbert. Schaerr resigned his partnership at a private law firm to become Special Assistant Attorney General for Utah. In a memo to his firm upon his departure, Schaerr said he was leaving to “fulfill what I have come to see as a religious and family duty: defending the constitutionality of traditional marriage in the state where my church is headquartered and where most of my family resides.” Schaerr has been a sometimes contributor to the Mormon magazine Meridian, including an article urging opposition to a marriage equality ballot measure in Maryland in 2012.

KitchenThe plaintiffs:

The three plaintiff couples are Derek Kitchen and Moudi Sbeity (pictured), who have not yet married; Laurie Wood and Kody Partridge, who married in Utah during the brief window of opportunity this year; and Kate Call and Karen Archer, who obtained a marriage certificate in Iowa.

The organizer behind the lawsuit is Mark Lawrence, director of Restore Our Humanity, a group established specifically to mount this lawsuit. According to a profile in the Salt Lake City Tribune, Lawrence, an information technology specialist who lives with his parents to care for his father who has Alzheimer’s, was inspired by the Proposition 8 lawsuit to tackle something similar here.

After Thursday’s hearing, the 10th Circuit has also scheduled oral arguments in another marriage equality case: Bishop v. Smith out of Oklahoma. That will be on April 17.

On May 12, the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals will hear oral argument in Bostic v. Schaeffer, a case led by Ted Olson and David Boies for the American Foundation for Equal Rights and a team of attorneys against Virginia’s ban.

The Sixth Circuit has four marriage equality appeals pending before it, and one of those, Michigan, just asked the court to skip over the three-judge panel phase and go directly to a full “en banc” review. If the Sixth Circuit agreed, that could enable the Michigan case to reach the U.S. Supreme Court before Utah. But getting to the high court first does not guarantee the justices will choose that case to decide the issue at stake in all these cases: whether states can deny same-sex couples the right to marry.

© 2014 Keen News Service. All rights reserved.

More on this case soon from our legal editor Ari Ezra Waldman…

Topics: News More Posts About: gay marriage, Gay Marriage, Law - Gay, LGBT, Law - Gay, LGBT, News, Utah, Utah

Related Posts
  • No deal to end gun violence, U.S. Republican lawmaker says
  • Former Roommate Indicted For Murder Of Florida LGBTQ Activist Jorge Diaz-Johnston, One of the Public Faces In State Fight For Marriage Equality
  • Utah lawmakers vote to override veto on anti-trans sports ban
  • Chris Pratt Called Out! Actor’s ‘Not Religious’ Claim Debunked After Spilling About Church & Faith For Years

    Chris Pratt Called Out! Actor’s ‘Not Religious’ Claim Debunked After Spilling About Church & Faith For Years

    Published by Radar Online Mega Chris Prattshocked the world when he came out and denied going to Hillsong church or being religious altogether after catching flak for going to an anti-LGBTQ establishment — but now, after …Read More »
  • Baz Luhrmann is turning Australia into new series Faraway Downs

    Baz Luhrmann is turning Australia into new series Faraway Downs

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Baz Luhrmann is turning ‘Australia’ into a six-part series. The 59-year-old filmmaker has officially revealed his 2008 epic adventure film – which starred Nicole Kidman and Hugh Jackman – will be …Read More »
  • WHO warns ‘sustained transmission’ of monkeypox risks vulnerable groups

    WHO warns ‘sustained transmission’ of monkeypox risks vulnerable groups

    Published by Reuters LONDON (Reuters) – The World Health Organization said “sustained transmission” of monkeypox worldwide could see the virus begin to move into high-risk groups, like pregnant women, immunocompromised people and children. WHO said on …Read More »
  • U.S. Supreme Court expands state power over tribes in win for Oklahoma

    U.S. Supreme Court expands state power over tribes in win for Oklahoma

    Published by Reuters By Lawrence Hurley WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday widened the power of states over Native American tribes and undercut its own 2020 ruling that had expanded Native American tribal authority …Read More »
Previous Post: « Beards are So Hot Right Now That People are Paying $15,000 for Beard Implants: VIDEO
Next Post: No, Gay Rapper Fly Young Red Didn’t Just Join Lil’ Wayne’s Music Label »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • California beachfront property to return to Black family

    California beachfront property to return to Black family

  • Four takeaways from the sixth day of Jan. 6 U.S. Capitol riot hearings

    Four takeaways from the sixth day of Jan. 6 U.S. Capitol riot hearings

  • Trump wanted to join Jan. 6 Capitol riot, tried to grab limo steering wheel

    Trump wanted to join Jan. 6 Capitol riot, tried to grab limo steering wheel

RSS Partner Links

  • Travis Barker's Stepdaughter Atiana De La Hoya Speaks Out Amid His Hospitalization
  • Naomie Harris Goes Sightseeing With Davor Tomic After Attending His Sister's Wedding in Italy
  • “Anna Kendrick & Bill Hader were dating, but now they’ve split?” links
  • Cassidy Hutchinson: Donald Trump assaulted Secret Service chief on Jan. 6th
  • Tom Brady & Gisele Bundchen Enjoy Some Alone Time During Family Vacation to Italy
  • OPEN Your Heart
  • Hugh Grant To Lead Netflix's Dark Green Mythology Series 'Kaos' - Meet The Full Cast Here!

Most Recent

  • Biden Administration Outlines Monkeypox Strategy, Including Increased Testing, Vaccination And Community Education

    Biden Administration Outlines Monkeypox Strategy, Including Increased Testing, Vaccination And Community Education

  • Chris Pratt Called Out! Actor’s ‘Not Religious’ Claim Debunked After Spilling About Church & Faith For Years

    Chris Pratt Called Out! Actor’s ‘Not Religious’ Claim Debunked After Spilling About Church & Faith For Years

  • Baz Luhrmann is turning Australia into new series Faraway Downs

    Baz Luhrmann is turning Australia into new series Faraway Downs

  • WHO warns ‘sustained transmission’ of monkeypox risks vulnerable groups

    WHO warns ‘sustained transmission’ of monkeypox risks vulnerable groups

  • U.S. Supreme Court expands state power over tribes in win for Oklahoma

    U.S. Supreme Court expands state power over tribes in win for Oklahoma

  • Ginni Thomas’ lawyer wants to know what Jan. 6 probe wants from his client

    Ginni Thomas’ lawyer wants to know what Jan. 6 probe wants from his client

  • U.S. steps up fight against monkeypox, allocates more vaccines to states

    U.S. steps up fight against monkeypox, allocates more vaccines to states

  • Ethan Hawke and Pedro Pascal cast in Strange Way of Life

    Ethan Hawke and Pedro Pascal cast in Strange Way of Life

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in