• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Is Trump kissing Fauci? With apparently fake photos, DeSantis raises AI ante
  • US Supreme Court backs Alabama Black voters, bolsters civil rights law
  • Pat Robertson, who made Christian right a political force, dead at 93

Utah, Indiana, Heightened Scrutiny and Next Steps: Is Marriage Heading to the Supreme Court?

Ari Ezra Waldman June 25, 2014

TenthcircuitThe most pressing question is what happens now that the Tenth Circuit has affirmed that Utah's ban on same-sex marriage is unconstitutional?

First, gay couples cannot marry just yet. A stay, which was already put in place after a great number of couples had already married, is attached to the appellate court's decision. The stay explicitly mentions that the ruling should be stayed pending Supreme Court review.

Second, there are several possible steps forward. The ultra-conservative leaders of Utah are unlikely to concede the justice of marriage equality and accept gay marriage in the state (as the embattled Republican governor did in Pennsylvania). Assuming they want to pursue the case, the state could ask for the Tenth Circuit to rehear the case en banc. That means that instead of just 3 judges deciding the issue for Utah and the Tenth Circuit, the same questions would go to the entire Tenth Circuit. If the Circuit grants a rehearing, which is not that likely, they could ask for additional briefing or decide the case on the current briefs. That process could take several months and, at least, into next fall. Or, the state defendants could appeal directly to the Supreme Court. Because we are almost at the end of the current Supreme Court term and because the Court does not meet to discuss certiorari petitions over the summer, we would not hear anything about whether the Court accepts the case and when the hearing gets scheduled until early next fall. 

SupremesThis brings up the related question: Does the Supreme Court have to take this case?

No. The Court knows what's happening in the lower courts. The justices know that various cases are winding their way through the lower courts from all corners of the country and even if state defendants do decide to appeal up to the Supreme Court, the Court may elect to do nothing and wait to see what happens with all the other cases. The Court has in the past waited for several cases to come up for review, taken one or several, and decided all issues under one umbrella. This is sort of what happened when the Court granted a hearing in the Windsor case rather than any of the various other DOMA cases.

It is not even an absolute certainty that the Supreme Court will ever take a marriage equality case. Granted, it is highly likely that marriage equality is heading back to the Supreme Court, whether it is from the Tenth, the Fourth, or whatever other circuit. However, it is not certain. The Tenth Circuit has affirmed the unconstitutionality of Utah's ban. The Fourth Circuit may follow suit in short order. Michigan's ban is up for review, as is Texas's. Cases are lower down in the system elsewhere. But, eventually, every appellate court could have a marriage equality case before it. If every appellate court strikes down the gay marriage bans, and given our post-Windsor streak, that seems possible, there would be no legal question demanding the Supreme Court's answer.

Of course the Supreme Court may take a marriage case anyway. But for all our talk of needing the Supreme Court to give us a nationwide right to marry, our post-Windsor winning streak may make the Supreme Court unnecessary. 

Over the next few days and weeks, I will return to these decisions and discuss the details. Stay tuned!

***

Follow me on Twitter and on Facebook.

Ari Ezra Waldman is a professor of law and the Director of the Institute for Information Law and Policy at New York Law School and is concurrently getting his PhD at Columbia University in New York City. He is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. Ari writes weekly posts on law and various LGBT issues.

Topics: News, Supreme Court More Posts About: Ari Ezra Waldman, Ari Ezra Waldman, DOMA, DOMA, Gay Marriage, gay marriage, Law - Gay, LGBT, Law - Gay, LGBT, News, Utah, Utah

Related Posts
  • Republicans have filed dozens of bills to disrupt transgender youth health care
  • No deal to end gun violence, U.S. Republican lawmaker says
  • Former Roommate Indicted For Murder Of Florida LGBTQ Activist Jorge Diaz-Johnston, One of the Public Faces In State Fight For Marriage Equality
  • US Supreme Court backs Alabama Black voters, bolsters civil rights law

    US Supreme Court backs Alabama Black voters, bolsters civil rights law

    Published by Reuters By John Kruzel WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday handed a major victory to Black voters who challenged a Republican-drawn electoral map in Alabama, finding the state violated a landmark law …Read More »
  • Pat Robertson, who made Christian right a political force, dead at 93

    Pat Robertson, who made Christian right a political force, dead at 93

    Published by AFP Pat Robertson, founder of the Christian Broadcasting Network, has died at the age of 93 Washington (AFP) – Pat Robertson, the soft-spoken televangelist who helped make America’s Christians a powerful political force while …Read More »
  • Uganda enacts repressive law putting LGBTQ+ communities at serious risk

    Uganda enacts repressive law putting LGBTQ+ communities at serious risk

    Published by Global Voices Image of LGBTQ community protest in Uganda, on the Africanews YouTube Channel. May 2023 was a watershed period for Uganda’s lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ+) community. On May 2, the …Read More »
  • Biden names coordinator to work on book bans issue

    Biden names coordinator to work on book bans issue

    Published by AFP The graphic novel Washington (AFP) – US President Joe Biden has named a government coordinator to handle the thorny issue of book bans in schools — one of a series of initiatives announced …Read More »
Previous Post: « Hatemonger Linda Harvey Claims Gay Parents Will Molest Their Children: AUDIO
Next Post: British Grocers Fortnum & Mason Celebrate Pride With Subtle Grammatical Joke »

Primary Sidebar

Adjacent News

  • 2 groups cancel Orlando conventions as worries over political climate grow

    2 groups cancel Orlando conventions as worries over political climate grow

  • Danny Westneat: We’re going back in time on LGBTQ+ equality

    Danny Westneat: We’re going back in time on LGBTQ+ equality

  • South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem Says America ‘Can't Shop at Target Anymore' Because the Store is 'Fundamentally Tearing Down This Country' After 'Tuck-friendly' Swimwear Debacle

    South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem Says America ‘Can't Shop at Target Anymore' Because the Store is 'Fundamentally Tearing Down This Country' After 'Tuck-friendly' Swimwear Debacle

Good Trash: Going to Read It Somewhere, Y'know

  • Justin Bieber’s Dad Faces Backlash Over Anti-Pride Post After Telling LGBTQ Community to ‘Thank a Straight Person’ for Their ‘Existence’

    Justin Bieber’s Dad Faces Backlash Over Anti-Pride Post After Telling LGBTQ Community to ‘Thank a Straight Person’ for Their ‘Existence’

  • Former CNN anchor Don Lemon lands new hosting gig – but not on TV

    Former CNN anchor Don Lemon lands new hosting gig – but not on TV

  • Elliot Page Shockingly Admits He had Secret Relationship With Kate Mara While She was Dating Max Minghelia

    Elliot Page Shockingly Admits He had Secret Relationship With Kate Mara While She was Dating Max Minghelia

Partner Links

  • Morning Round-Up: Rock Hudson; Sam Smith and Madonna; Janelle Monae; Elliot Page & more!
  • Lorna Luft, Kevin Spirtas & Jojo Siwa honored at opening of “Real to Reel: Portrayals & Perceptions of LGBTQ+ in Hollywood”
  • 54 Candles
  • The Magic A.I. Genie
  • Rosie reacts to second Trump indictment

Most Recent

  • Is Trump kissing Fauci? With apparently fake photos, DeSantis raises AI ante

    Is Trump kissing Fauci? With apparently fake photos, DeSantis raises AI ante

  • US Supreme Court backs Alabama Black voters, bolsters civil rights law

    US Supreme Court backs Alabama Black voters, bolsters civil rights law

  • Pat Robertson, who made Christian right a political force, dead at 93

    Pat Robertson, who made Christian right a political force, dead at 93

  • Uganda enacts repressive law putting LGBTQ+ communities at serious risk

    Uganda enacts repressive law putting LGBTQ+ communities at serious risk

  • Biden names coordinator to work on book bans issue

    Biden names coordinator to work on book bans issue

  • Biden rails against ‘prejudiced,’ ‘unjustified’ attacks on LGTBQ+ Americans

    Biden rails against ‘prejudiced,’ ‘unjustified’ attacks on LGTBQ+ Americans

  • 40 Moments From the Original ‘Sex and the City’ Series That Live Rent-Free in Our Heads

    40 Moments From the Original ‘Sex and the City’ Series That Live Rent-Free in Our Heads

  • Janelle Monae admits she’s always craved her mum’s approval: ‘It’s everything!’

    Janelle Monae admits she’s always craved her mum’s approval: ‘It’s everything!’

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

Footer

Copyright © 2023 · Log in

×