• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox

Tobias Wolff: ‘Hobby Lobby Decision Supports The Enforceability Of Anti-Discrimination Laws’

Sean Mandell July 3, 2014

Friends and Colleagues —

In the wake of the Hobby Lobby decision, opponents of LGBT equality are trying to reverse the progress we have made on workplace protections. As Chris Geidner reports, a group of advocates including Rick Warren have published a letter seeking to pressure the White House to insert a broad and unprecedented religious exemption in the forthcoming Executive Order on federal contractors, and they point to Hobby Lobby as one principal justification.

It is important to understand that Hobby Lobby in fact rejects the argument that religious exercise can be an excuse for invidious discrimination. The following is the key passage of the decision, which the Court inserted specifically to respond to the suggestion that its ruling could authorize discrimination in the workplace:

"The principal dissent raises the possibility that discrimination in hiring, for example on the basis of race, might be cloaked as religious practice to escape legal sanction. See post, at 32-33. Our decision today provides no such shield. The Government has a compelling interest in providing an equal opportunity to participate in the workforce without regard to race, and prohibitions on racial discrimination are precisely tailored to achieve that critical goal."

Allow me to break down the significance of this passage — what it says, and what it means in a larger context — so that we can respond appropriately to these attempts to use Hobby Lobby to justify discrimination.

– The Supreme Court says unequivocally in this passage that private workplace discrimination is a harm so severe that government has a "compelling interest" in eradicating that discrimination.

– The Court uses the example of race discrimination to make this point, but it does not limit itself to race discrimination. 

– Discrimination based upon other suspect characteristics — those that provoked either "heightened scrutiny" or "strict scrutiny" when government uses them to discriminate — are controlled by the same principle. The Supreme Court has already issued a holding to that effect regarding private acts of sex discrimination in the context of the First Amendment, in a case called Roberts v. U.S. Jaycees. Thus, the government "has a compelling interest in providing an equal opportunity to participate in the workforce without regard to" sex and gender, as well.

– Antigay discrimination by government is a suspect form of discrimination that provokes heightened scrutiny. That proposition has been strongly affirmed by the President and the Attorney General in their refusal to enforce DOMA and by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in their decision in Windsor, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in the SmithKline Beecham case, the California Supreme Court, the Connecticut Supreme Court and the New Mexico Supreme Court in their marriage equality rulings, and other courts as well. Therefore, government has a compelling interest in eradicating private antigay discrimination from the workplace. 

– Antitrans discrimination is discrimination based upon sex and gender and hence subject to heightened scrutiny. That proposition has been strongly affirmed by the Obama Administration, for example in the Macy v. Holder ruling and in the recent clarification issued by the Labor Department, and by the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in Glenn v. Brumby and other courts around the country. Therefore, government has a compelling interest in eradicating private antitrans discrimination from the workplace.

– In this passage from Hobby Lobby, the Court also makes clear that laws and policies that prohibit discrimination in the workplace are "precisely tailored to achieve that critical goal". In other words, it is the act of discriminating itself — which deprives the individual worker of "an equal opportunity to participate in the workforce" — that inflicts the harm that the government has a compelling interest to eradicate. This passage strongly repudiates the argument that opponents sometimes make that there is no compelling interest in enforcing anti-discrimination laws if a person could find another job or patronize another business. Every act of private discrimination works a serious harm that the government has a compelling interest in eradicating.

In the days ahead, it is important that advocates and leaders strongly push out the message that the Hobby Lobby decision strongly supports the enforceability of anti-discrimination laws, even in the face of religious exemption arguments. Hobby Lobby represents a vindication of the principle that anti-discrimination protections should trump religious objections in the workplace.

 

Tobias Barrington Wolff

Professor of Law

University of Pennsylvania Law School

http://www.law.upenn.edu/cf/faculty/twolff/

Topics: Actor, Business, News, Supreme Court More Posts About: discrimination, Discrimination, Gay Rights, gay rights, Law - Gay, LGBT, Law - Gay, LGBT, News, Tobias Wolff, Tobias Wolff

Related Posts
  • Russia Blocks Facebook, Accusing it of Restricting Access to Russian Media;
  • BK 99’s Stephanie Beatriz Says Even Her Favorite Shows Spread Bisexual Myths That It’s A Hyper-Promiscuous , Manipulative Phase
  • Duran Duran Has New Music And You Are About To Enjoy it. It’s 2021. Seriously.
  • Christian extremists destroy LGBT monument in east Beirut

    Christian extremists destroy LGBT monument in east Beirut

    Published by Al-Araby Christian extremists have torn down a flower monument depicting the rainbow flag in east Beirut, as Lebanon experiences a wave of homophobic and transphobic incidents. In a video published by “Soldiers of God” …Read More »
  • Ryan Resch Becomes First Openly Gay NBA Basketball Ops Person

    Ryan Resch Becomes First Openly Gay NBA Basketball Ops Person

    Published by Sports Illustrated By Daniel Chavkin The 29-year-old publicly came out on Saturday. View the original article to see embedded media. Suns vice president of strategy and evaluation Ryan Resch publicly came out as gay, …Read More »
  • U.S. tech industry frets about handing data to states prosecuting abortion

    U.S. tech industry frets about handing data to states prosecuting abortion

    Published by Reuters By Jeffrey Dastin PALO ALTO, Calif. (Reuters) – The technology industry is bracing for the uncomfortable possibility of having to hand over pregnancy-related data to law enforcement, in the wake of the U.S. …Read More »
  • ‘Guns have more rights than women’: Kim Kardashian hits out at US abortion law ruling

    ‘Guns have more rights than women’: Kim Kardashian hits out at US abortion law ruling

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Kim Kardashian has condemned the Supreme Court’s decision to terminate the constitutional right to abortion in the US. Lawmakers in the US caused uproar across the globe after the landmark Roe …Read More »
Previous Post: « YouTube Complaints 2014 – VIDEO
Next Post: The OXD Mirror: New Dance tracks by Kiesza, Anna Lunoe, Duke Dumont and more »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Billie Eilish tells Glastonbury fans to scream away anxieties at history making headline slot

    Billie Eilish tells Glastonbury fans to scream away anxieties at history making headline slot

  • Landmark gun-safety bill heads to U.S. House after Senate passage

    Landmark gun-safety bill heads to U.S. House after Senate passage

  • Prosecutors seek 25-year prison sentence for Chauvin over breach of Floyd’s rights

    Prosecutors seek 25-year prison sentence for Chauvin over breach of Floyd’s rights

RSS Partner Links

  • Sunday Comics
  • Speedo Sunday
  • Chris Diamantopoulos Goes Shirtless for Afternoon Walk with His Dog
  • Rita Moreno Reflects on Botched Abortion Years Before Roe V. Wade
  • Colin Farrell on Tom Cruise’s stunt work: ‘that’s mental illness, that’s not bravery’
  • Prince William didn’t get the People cover, but did get an embiggening profile
  • 'Bachelor in Paradise' Star Cam Ayala Undergoes Leg Amputation Amid Battle with Lymphedema

Most Recent

  • ‘F*ck BET:’ Lil Nas X BET Conflict Gets New Volley With Release Of New Single And Video ‘Late To Da Party’

    ‘F*ck BET:’ Lil Nas X BET Conflict Gets New Volley With Release Of New Single And Video ‘Late To Da Party’

  • Christian extremists destroy LGBT monument in east Beirut

    Christian extremists destroy LGBT monument in east Beirut

  • Ryan Resch Becomes First Openly Gay NBA Basketball Ops Person

    Ryan Resch Becomes First Openly Gay NBA Basketball Ops Person

  • U.S. tech industry frets about handing data to states prosecuting abortion

    U.S. tech industry frets about handing data to states prosecuting abortion

  • ‘Guns have more rights than women’: Kim Kardashian hits out at US abortion law ruling

    ‘Guns have more rights than women’: Kim Kardashian hits out at US abortion law ruling

  • Lizzo donates $500k to Planned Parenthood and Abortion Rights

    Lizzo donates $500k to Planned Parenthood and Abortion Rights

  • Biden administration signals fight over medication abortion

    Biden administration signals fight over medication abortion

  • Horror on Oslo Pride day as gunman goes on deadly rampage at gay bar

    Horror on Oslo Pride day as gunman goes on deadly rampage at gay bar

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in