• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Fun With The Familia! Madonna Lets Loose In Italy To Celebrate Her & Son Rocco’s Birthdays
  • Viola Davis joins ‘Hunger Games’ prequel in ‘cruel,’ ‘fearsome’ role
  • NFL World Reacts To The Carl Nassib Signing News

Stewart vs. Santorum: “Not Bad Dudes”?

Andy Towle July 26, 2005

Santorumstewart1_1

Last night The Daily Show with Jon Stewart hosted homophobe U.S. Senator Rick Santorum as he made the rounds publicizing his new book It Takes a Family: Conservatism and the Common Good.

Stewart seemed stymied by Santorum’s family values talking points. I don’t think I’ve ever seen Stewart having such difficulty coming up with rebuttals. By the end of their interview it seemed to be turning into a virtual lovefest, with the two of them agreeing to disagree. Here’s a partial transcript of the first half of the show which dealt with homosexuality and same-sex families:

Stewart: Can you confuse virtue with heterosexuality? Because I live in New York City. I’m literally – we’re in a sea of homosexuality here. (Santorum giggles) It is – and also evangelism and Jewish and Muslim — it’s New York. There’s 8 million people. You’ve got more of everything. My experience has been virtue is unrelated to sexuality. APPLAUSE. And by the way on the other side of that…unrelated to religion. I think that’s why the argument and concern in that vein is so confusing.

Santorum: I would say that certainly people who are homosexuals can be virtuous and very often are. The problem is that when you talk about he institution of marriage as the foundation and building block of society which I say the family is, and the marriage is the glue that holds the family together. We need to do things to make sure that that institution stays stable for the benefit of children.

Stewart: Children are best raised in male/female is what you’re…

Santorum: Yeah, one man one woman.

Stewart: One man, one woman, good job…

Santorum: Absolutely…I mean I talked about all those aspects of society…

Stewart: But if you don’t have the ideal? Cause you know they say you go to war with the army that you have…

Santorum: But government should be for the ideal [note: This is straight out of Bush’s rhetoric – remember this interview?] — that doesn’t mean that a single mom can’t and in most cases will raise great children. That [doesn’t] mean that other forms can’t and won’t raise good children. What government should be for is what’s best because a lot’s at stake – the future of our country. And so we should have a system that builds around what’s best, and that’s the traditional, what I call natural family. It’s not to say that other people are bad.

Stewart: Isn’t even the natural family evolving? All the way up until the 60’s and 70’s there were those head of household laws that a family could decide to move but it was basically the man who had final say, you know, and before that marriage was more a property arrangement. You know, love marriage only came in the 1700’s and moved on from there. Is it possible that, through an examination or as we go along, or is this just a basic difference of opinion about what the nature of sexuality is and what the nature of virtue is?

Santorum: No I think it’s the nature of what’s best for society. From four thousand years of history we’ve decided and determined that marriage awas so important, having a mother and father who had children who were together for the purpose of children. Remember, the reason societies elevate marriage to a special status is not because they want to affirm the relationship between two adults. That’s important. A love relationship is important.

Stewart: But isn’t that more a religious paradigm than..

Santorum: No, no. Again, what’s society’s purpose in marriage? Society’s purpose – the reasons civilizations have held up marriage is because they want to establish and support and secure the relationship that is in the best interest of the future of the society, which is, a man and a woman having children and providing the stability for those children to be raised in the future.

Stewart: Wouldn’t you say though and with that same thing and I completely agree, although I always thought the purpose of marriage was a bachelor party but that’s beside the point. (laughter) But wouldn’t you say that society has an interest in understanding that the homosexual community also wants to form those same bonds and raise children and wouldn’t a monogamous, good-hearted, virtuous homosexual couple be in society’s best interest raising a child rather than a heterosexual couple with adultery, with alcohol issues, with other things, and by the way, I don’t even need to make that sound as though a gay couple can only raise a child given failures in other couples.

Santorum: You’re matching up best case vs worst case.

Stewart: I’m talking best case because…

Santorum: If it’s best case best case, the best case everywhere is one man, one woman, their child, raising that child.

Stewart: Can you legislate an ideal? [next words inaudible]

Santorum: We have to. We owe it to children. Children need a mom and a dad. There are differences between mothers and fathers. And young girls and young boys need both.

Stewart: I would, okay. (pause – laughter)

Stewart: Ultimately you get to this point where it’s this crazy stopping point where literally we can’t get any further. I don’t think you’re a bad dude. I don’t think I’m a bad dude. But I don’t think I can convince you of the idea that I think it’s doing society a disservice to dismiss the potential of all these really…

Santorum: I don’t think it’s dismissing the potential. I think we should honor every person in America – that every person has worth and dignity. There’s a difference though, when it comes to changing the laws of the country, that could harm children.

[end of partial transcript]

I was hoping for a few more fireworks from this match-up. I did, however, like the cutaway to the gay wedding when the show went to break.

Video at Crooks and Liars.

Santorumstewart2_1

Topics: Film/TV/Stream, History, Religion, towleroad More Posts About: Current Affairs

Related Posts
  • Notes from Our Leader
  • Dick and Mary Cheney on Homosexuality
  • Larry Miller Meets with Gay and Lesbian Students
  • Viola Davis joins ‘Hunger Games’ prequel in ‘cruel,’ ‘fearsome’ role

    Viola Davis joins ‘Hunger Games’ prequel in ‘cruel,’ ‘fearsome’ role

    Published by New York Daily News We’re always hungering for more Viola Davis. The Oscar winner, 57, is joining the “Hunger Games” prequel as the villainous head game-maker Dr. Volumnia Gaul in “The Ballad of Songbirds …Read More »
  • NFL World Reacts To The Carl Nassib Signing News

    NFL World Reacts To The Carl Nassib Signing News

    Published by The Spun By Daniel Bates After spending the first two years of his career in Cleveland, Carl Nassib made his name as a member of the Bucs before signing on with the Las Vegas …Read More »
  • Haunted, self-possessed or just spirited: 2022’s Emmy-nominated songs

    Haunted, self-possessed or just spirited: 2022’s Emmy-nominated songs

    Published by DPA Rachel Brosnahan in "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel". The show's season 4 song "Maybe Monica" is among this year's Emmy-nominated songs. -/Amazon Prime/dpa The songs nominated for the 2022 Emmy for original music and lyrics …Read More »
  • Kenya Barris to direct Wizard of Oz remake

    Kenya Barris to direct Wizard of Oz remake

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Kenya Barris is to direct a ‘Wizard of Oz’ remake. The ‘Black-ish’ creator has been tapped to write and helm the Warner Bros. reimagining of L. Frank Baum’s book ‘The Wonderful …Read More »
Previous Post: « Previous Post
Next Post: Next Post »

Primary Sidebar

Adjacent News

  • Biden signs $430 billion climate, healthcare and tax bill

    Biden signs $430 billion climate, healthcare and tax bill

  • Judge schedules Thursday hearing on motion to unseal Trump search warrant materials

    Judge schedules Thursday hearing on motion to unseal Trump search warrant materials

  • Dr. Oz Loses $5 Million Of GOP Campaign Funding In Pennsylvania As His Poll Numbers Continue To Plummet

    Dr. Oz Loses $5 Million Of GOP Campaign Funding In Pennsylvania As His Poll Numbers Continue To Plummet

Good Trash: Going to Read It Somewhere, Y’know

  • Ellen Has Not Contacted Ex-Lover Anne Heche Following Fiery Crash Into LA Home

    Ellen Has Not Contacted Ex-Lover Anne Heche Following Fiery Crash Into LA Home

  • Pete Davidson Proposed to Kim Kardashian Before Their Breakup

    Pete Davidson Proposed to Kim Kardashian Before Their Breakup

  • New bombshell book on Trump reveals he wanted to be treated like Hitler: ‘Totally loyal’

    New bombshell book on Trump reveals he wanted to be treated like Hitler: ‘Totally loyal’

RSS Partner Links

  • OMG, have you heard? J.Lo & Ben Affleck plan to have a 3-day wedding party this weekend
  • OMG, this FB group shares the internet’s most-disgusting vintage recipes
  • OMG, he’s naked: Actor Artur Abe goes full-frontal and rear in the Brazilian short ‘Trato de Levante’
  • Hot Sluts Of The Day!
  • Michelle Branch Filed For Divorce From Patrick Carney
  • Meme Spirited
  • Florence Pugh Confirms That She And Zach Braff Have Broken Up

Most Recent

  • Fun With The Familia! Madonna Lets Loose In Italy To Celebrate Her & Son Rocco’s Birthdays

    Fun With The Familia! Madonna Lets Loose In Italy To Celebrate Her & Son Rocco’s Birthdays

  • Viola Davis joins ‘Hunger Games’ prequel in ‘cruel,’ ‘fearsome’ role

    Viola Davis joins ‘Hunger Games’ prequel in ‘cruel,’ ‘fearsome’ role

  • NFL World Reacts To The Carl Nassib Signing News

    NFL World Reacts To The Carl Nassib Signing News

  • Haunted, self-possessed or just spirited: 2022’s Emmy-nominated songs

    Haunted, self-possessed or just spirited: 2022’s Emmy-nominated songs

  • Kenya Barris to direct Wizard of Oz remake

    Kenya Barris to direct Wizard of Oz remake

  • Analysis-Ben & Jerry’s Unilever fight shows risks of ceding control

    Analysis-Ben & Jerry’s Unilever fight shows risks of ceding control

  • Doja Cat says people who don’t like her buzzcut can ‘go f***” themselves’

    Doja Cat says people who don’t like her buzzcut can ‘go f***” themselves’

  • Anne Heche wanted Miley Cyrus to play her in movie about her life

    Anne Heche wanted Miley Cyrus to play her in movie about her life

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in

×