I’ve written so much about this movie I thought it might be good to utilize the resources I’ve collected and put them all in one place.
Please feel free to add your own reviews and thoughts about the movie in the comments. Off-topic and offensive comments will be deleted.
Brokeback Mountain [Official Site]
[Buy the Story on Amazon]
or iTunes.
REVIEWS
The Towleroad review of Brokeback Mountain.
Report on the Venice Film festival with Variety and Hollywood Reporter excerpts.
“Brokeback Mountain” takes great pains to be a compassionate love story; but the filmmaking itself, self-consciously restrained and desiccated, is inert and inexpressive.”
“If that’s true and it’s just a love story between two men, then gay people are halfway there. If two men f*cking in a tent and french kissing in Wyoming isn’t gay, then same-sex unions should pose no threat. Some women aren’t feeling it. I suspect that’s because women are not internal creatures.”
“The film is not exploitation, and it is definitely not what people would expect. I expect there will be a lot of nervous, juvenile giggling by audiences who are uncomfortable watching a love story between two men. It’s their loss, as they’re missing out on a great story of love that can be applied to everyone, regardless of sexual preference.”
“One, we just loved seeing the boys rustle up some cowbooty and swap spit, and two, we hated feeling that they were justified in hiding their love. We had to step back and realize that yes, indeed this was a period piece – sadly with some present day equivalents, but still and all not indicative of a modern gay lifestyle. Rural Wyoming was probably not a safe haven for the gays in the mid 1960s. And ultimately, this film isn’t about the right to self expression, it’s about the inability for some men to express themselves at all.”
“The largely gay audience I was with at first seemed to expect (or hope) that Brokeback Mountain would parody the rugged machismo of the Western genre by exposing the buried homoeroticism underneath. (It was as if some patrons saw Brokeback as a means to get revenge on that most manly — and straight — of genres.) But Lee doesn’t see his homosexual lovers as revolutionaries or gay-right liberators or anything so grandiose, and he isn’t here to reinvent genre clichés. In truth, Brokeback Mountain returns to the same thematic terrain as The Ice Storm — the complete and utter unhappiness that is the modern world.”
“In Brokeback Mountain, everyone suffers because of manly western myths, and no one suffers more acutely than Ennis. Yes, antihero Jack does meet one of the time-honored antihero ends at the hands of the vile side of civilization that simply cannot abide his “natural” identity. But our hero Ennis, our upstanding frontier man who stays close to the land but resists nature’s temptations, and who wants—but mostly fails—to do right by his adoring daughters has an arguably more painful fate (and Ledger makes you feel that pain).