• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Politics
  • Health
  • Travel
  • Gay Pride
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Men
  • Space
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Monkeypox
  • Film/TV

Justice Dept. and Obama Forced into Opposition Over ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’ in Log Cabin Case

Andy Towle April 14, 2010

Sotu  

Statements that President Obama made at a gay rights reception at the White House in June 2009 and at the State of the Union Address, that 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' "weakens our national security," put him at odds with his own Justice Dept. this week as the DOJ was compelled to deny, on the record (PDF), their accuracy in a case against the military gay ban brought by the Log Cabin Republicans.

The SF Chronicle reports:Dadt  

Monday's filing in U.S. District Court in Riverside was the latest twist in the current round of litigation over anti-gay measures that Obama politically opposes but is defending in court.

The suit by the Log Cabin Republicans, a gay and lesbian group, is scheduled to go to trial in June. The group argues that the 1993 law prohibiting military service by homosexuals who reveal their sexual orientation was an irrational measure that served no legitimate military or government purpose.

Government lawyers preparing for trial are often asked by their opponents to confirm or deny officials' statements that might help the plaintiffs' case. When confronted with Obama's June 2009 speech at a White House reception, Justice Department lawyers objected that the question was both misleading and irrelevant.

The president was discussing only the advisability of the policy, not its legal status, and his comments should not be used to suggest that the law is "somehow legally invalid or unconstitutional," government lawyers said in a brief last month. Words and phrases like "national security" and "weakens" are vague and subjective, they argued, and add nothing to the legal debate.

A federal magistrate was unswayed and ordered the Justice Department to tell the plaintiffs whether it supported or rejected Obama's statement.

Still protesting that the question was too complex for a one-word answer, department lawyers replied this week that – duty-bound to defend all federal laws – they had "no choice but to deny, for purposes of this litigation," the accuracy of the president's words.

Here is some additional analysis from Timothy Kincaid at Box Turtle Bulletin. 

Writes Kincaid: "[The DOJ tries] to quibble that the Executive and Legislative Branches are in disagreement. They state that they are compelled to defend the law even if the Executive wishes it repealed.

And that may be correct. But they are not compelled to take specific factual conclusions that are contradictory to those espoused by the Executive Branch and yet that is exactly what they are doing."

Topics: Military, News More Posts About: Barack Obama, Barack Obama, Don't Ask Don't tell, Military, News

Related Posts
  • Biden loses potent aide with departure of press secretary Psaki
  • Psaki Passes WH Position to Karine Jean-Pierre, Who Ran Kamala Harris’ Campaign; Is First Out Gay, Black Press Secretary
  • Samuel Alito Has Been Staunch Conservative on U.S. Supreme Court
  • Activists Rally, Make Case For Thailand Marriage Equality; Present Rewritten Version of  Constitutional Court’s Ruling On Marriage Law

    Activists Rally, Make Case For Thailand Marriage Equality; Present Rewritten Version of Constitutional Court’s Ruling On Marriage Law

    On May 17, the International Day Against Homophobia, Transphobia, and Biphobia(IDAHOT), activists held a rally for LGBTQ+ rights and called for marriage equality by rewriting the Constitutional Court’s ruling on the Thai marriage law. On November 17, …Read More »
  • New House map sets stage for Brooklyn slugfest headlined by Bill de Blasio, Mondaire Jones

    New House map sets stage for Brooklyn slugfest headlined by Bill de Blasio, Mondaire Jones

    Published by New York Daily News NEW YORK — The ink has barely dried on New York’s much-revised House map, but a radically transformed 10th Congressional District has set the stage for an unruly political scramble …Read More »
  • Kate McKinnon Leaving SNL; What? Also Aidy Bryant, Pete Davidson  and Kyle Mooney Set to Depart After This Season.  Season Finale TONIGHT

    Kate McKinnon Leaving SNL; What? Also Aidy Bryant, Pete Davidson and Kyle Mooney Set to Depart After This Season. Season Finale TONIGHT

      Published by InsideHook   By Tobias Carroll The current season of Saturday Night Live featured the show’s largest cast ever, with 21 different comedians appearing on screen at various points during the year. Based on …Read More »
  • Explicit Photos To Blame? ‘Speechless’ Madonna Is Outraged After Being BLOCKED From Instagram Live

    Explicit Photos To Blame? ‘Speechless’ Madonna Is Outraged After Being BLOCKED From Instagram Live

    Published by Radar Online KCS Presse / MEGA Madonna was in utter shock to discover that Instagram had blocked her from going live, sharing a video of the awkward moment she found out on Friday. “What …Read More »
Previous Post: « Watch: Sue Sylvester Does ‘Vogue’
Next Post: Read: Grindr’s New Terms of Service (for Puritans) »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Harris, White House Spox Rip Oklahoma For Passing Near-Total Abortion Ban Weeks After Leaked Supreme Court Opinion

    Harris, White House Spox Rip Oklahoma For Passing Near-Total Abortion Ban Weeks After Leaked Supreme Court Opinion

  • Trump pays $110,000 fine for blocking New York state tax probe

    Trump pays $110,000 fine for blocking New York state tax probe

  • Erdogan demands concessions to back Swedish, Finnish NATO membership

    Erdogan demands concessions to back Swedish, Finnish NATO membership

  • Zelensky says Ukraine has ‘broken the backbone’ of the Russian army

    Zelensky says Ukraine has ‘broken the backbone’ of the Russian army

Break

  • Evan Spiegel & Miranda Kerr Pay Off $10 Million In Loans Of Otis College’s Graduating Class

    Evan Spiegel & Miranda Kerr Pay Off $10 Million In Loans Of Otis College’s Graduating Class

  • Vladimir Putin’s Daughter SECRETLY Living In Germany With Man Named Igor Zelensky

    Vladimir Putin’s Daughter SECRETLY Living In Germany With Man Named Igor Zelensky

  • Tucker Carlson: Voice of white America’s outrage and fears

    Tucker Carlson: Voice of white America’s outrage and fears

  • Viola Davis was called by director’s maid’s name

    Viola Davis was called by director’s maid’s name

RSS Partner Links

  • Will Prince Charles & the Queen deal with the ‘counsellors of state’ issue soon?
  • Mayor Sadiq Khan invited the Sussexes to LA & they invited him to Montecito
  • Kim & Khloe Kardashian Go Gothic Glam for Kourtney Kardashian & Travis Barker's Wedding - See All the Photos!
  • Machine Gun Kelly Wears Blue Leopard-Print Suit to Travis Barker & Kourtney Kardashian's Wedding with Megan Fox
  • You're Welcome: The Might Casey Swings Out
  • Amanda Bynes Reveals The One Show She'd Return To Acting For
  • Michelle Yeoh & Mindy Kaling Honored at Gold House's 2022 Gold Gala
  • Mick Jagger Responds To The Harry Styles Comparisons, Says That Harry Is A “Superficial Resemblance” Of His Younger Self
  • John Mulaney Fans Say They Felt Ambushed By Him Bringing Dave Chappelle Out For His Show

Most Recent

  • Hayley Kiyoko Comes Out About Dating ‘Bachelor’ Star Becca Tilley In Video For Her Catchy New “For the Girls” A Parody of Lesbian Dates, Reality Tropes: WATCH

    Hayley Kiyoko Comes Out About Dating ‘Bachelor’ Star Becca Tilley In Video For Her Catchy New “For the Girls” A Parody of Lesbian Dates, Reality Tropes: WATCH

  • Activists Rally, Make Case For Thailand Marriage Equality; Present Rewritten Version of  Constitutional Court’s Ruling On Marriage Law

    Activists Rally, Make Case For Thailand Marriage Equality; Present Rewritten Version of Constitutional Court’s Ruling On Marriage Law

  • New House map sets stage for Brooklyn slugfest headlined by Bill de Blasio, Mondaire Jones

    New House map sets stage for Brooklyn slugfest headlined by Bill de Blasio, Mondaire Jones

  • Kate McKinnon Leaving SNL; What? Also Aidy Bryant, Pete Davidson  and Kyle Mooney Set to Depart After This Season.  Season Finale TONIGHT

    Kate McKinnon Leaving SNL; What? Also Aidy Bryant, Pete Davidson and Kyle Mooney Set to Depart After This Season. Season Finale TONIGHT

  • Explicit Photos To Blame? ‘Speechless’ Madonna Is Outraged After Being BLOCKED From Instagram Live

    Explicit Photos To Blame? ‘Speechless’ Madonna Is Outraged After Being BLOCKED From Instagram Live

  • US archbishop bans Pelosi from communion over abortion rights support

    US archbishop bans Pelosi from communion over abortion rights support

  • Giuliani meets with U.S. House Jan. 6 panel, CNN reports

    Giuliani meets with U.S. House Jan. 6 panel, CNN reports

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 · Log in