• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Politics
  • Health
  • Travel
  • Gay Pride
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Men
  • Space
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Monkeypox
  • Film/TV

Gay Families Should Cancel Their Trips to New Orleans

Ari Ezra Waldman October 12, 2011

BY ARI EZRA WALDMAN

The Supreme Court just denied certiorari, or refused to hear, a case involving a state's power to refuse to amend a birth certificate for a child who was legally adopted out of state by a same-sex couple. By declining to hear the case, the Court lets stand an en banc decision from the Fifth Circuit that said that Louisiana could deny one of its children a birth certificate that lists both his parents simply because those parents both happen to be male. The case asks an important question of constitutional law — what is the reach of the command of the Full Faith and Credit Clause, which requires one state to respect the "public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of every other state"? — but also has implications on Main Street — without an accurate birth certificate for their children, gay couples are at risk whenever they enter a new state that has different adoption and marriage laws.

LouisianaThe Supreme Court declined to comment on its denial of cert, so we have to look to the Fifth Circuit's majority for the governing law. And, when we peel back that majority's seemingly reasonable outer layer, we're left with mind-numbing inanity. The Fifth Circuit has carved out a strange exception to a state's responsibility to recognize out-of-state adoption judgments and it has done so without justification.

The case involves Oren Adar and Mickey Smith. Mssrs. Adar and Smith are a gay couple who adopted their Louisiana-born son in 2006 in New York, where a judge issued an adoption decree. The couple then tried to get a new birth certificate for their child, in part so the child could be added to his parents' health insurance, but the registrar's office told him that Louisiana does not recognize adoption by unmarried parents and would not issue it with both adopted parents' names. A Louisiana district court ordered the registrar to change course, as did a unanimous three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit. But, a sharply divided Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, said Louisiana did not have to change the child's birth certificate.

And, yet, if the couple were straight, they wouldn't be in this mess. I discuss the Fifth Circuit's tortured reasoning AFTER THE JUMP…

The Fifth Circuit seemed to think it was okay for Louisiana to refuse to issue a new birth certificate even though it had to recognize the validity of the New York adoption decree, though the reality of the latter seems illusory without the former. If the court's rule sounds confusing, don't expect the following quote from the majority to help:

Louisiana can be described as the "sole mistress" of revised birth certificates that are part of its vital statistics records. Louisiana has every right to channel and direct the rights created by foreign judgments. Obtaining a birth certificate falls in the heartland of enforcement, and therefore outside the full faith and credit obligation of recognition.

Adar v. Smith, slip op. at 21 (citation omitted). It is as if the Fifth Circuit was looking at a different case: No one doubts that states have the sole power to issue birth certificates. But, the court, in distinguishing between "enforcement" and "recognition," clearly suggests that the Full Faith and Credit Clause amounts only to a mandate on state courts and not on any other arm of the state. The Clause's plain language says nothing of the kind. Article IV, Section 1 of the U.S. Constitution states that "Full Faith and Credit shall be given in each State to the public Acts, Records, and judicial Proceedings of every other State." Nothing in that clause's plain language or in more than 100 years of precedent interpreting it has ever suggested any reason to distinguish between recognition and enforcement. Not four years ago, the Tenth Circuit found that this Clause meant that an Oklahoma state official had to issue a correct birth certificate noting the adopted child's gay parents. And, yet, today, Louisiana law is uniquely and odiously discriminatory.

If the federal requirement that one state must give full faith and credit to another state's judgments can be so neutered as to simply include a mandate on a court rather than the enforcement arms of the state, there would be no point to a Full Faith and Credit Clause. Court judgments mean nothing without a government to enforce them.

***

Ari Ezra Waldman is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. After practicing in New York for five years and clerking at a federal appellate court in Washington, D.C., Ari is now on the faculty at California Western School of Law in San Diego, California. His research focuses on gay rights and the First Amendment. Ari will be writing weekly posts on law and various LGBT issues.

Follow Ari on Twitter at @ariezrawaldman.

Topics: News, Supreme Court More Posts About: Ari Ezra Waldman, discrimination, gay adoption, Law - Gay, LGBT, Louisiana, Louisiana, News

Related Posts
  • Russia Blocks Facebook, Accusing it of Restricting Access to Russian Media;
  • BK 99’s Stephanie Beatriz Says Even Her Favorite Shows Spread Bisexual Myths That It’s A Hyper-Promiscuous , Manipulative Phase
  • Duran Duran Has New Music And You Are About To Enjoy it. It’s 2021. Seriously.
  • Ellen DeGeneres ends pioneering talk show under cloud

    Ellen DeGeneres ends pioneering talk show under cloud

    Published by AFP Los Angeles (AFP) – For nearly two decades, “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” and its openly lesbian host have beamed into homes across America, busting stereotypes and charming daytime TV audiences with a feel-good …Read More »
  • New York City removes last public phone booth

    New York City removes last public phone booth

    Published by DPA A phone booth, redesigned by the artist Glenn Ligon, on a Manhattan street. The New York city administration began dismantling telephone booths in January 2021, and has been setting up free wi-fi kiosks …Read More »
  • Johnson takes responsibility but won’t quit over lockdown parties

    Johnson takes responsibility but won’t quit over lockdown parties

    Published by Reuters By Elizabeth Piper and Muvija M LONDON (Reuters) -A “humbled” Boris Johnson said he took full responsibility but would not quit after a damning official report on Wednesday detailed a series of illegal …Read More »
  • Exclusive: Biden moves to fill key appellate seat vacated by U.S. Supreme Court’s Jackson

    Exclusive: Biden moves to fill key appellate seat vacated by U.S. Supreme Court’s Jackson

    Published by Reuters By Nate Raymond (Reuters) – President Joe Biden on Wednesday nominated three women to serve as appellate judges including Florence Pan, who would succeed U.S. Supreme Court-designate Ketanji Brown Jackson on the influential …Read More »
Previous Post: « Glenn Beck Says His New Teabagger Clothing Line Will Rebuild America: VIDEO
Next Post: Florida School District Cuts Ties with Boy Scouts Education Program Over Anti-Gay Discrimination »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Georgia rebukes Trump over US voter fraud ‘Big Lie’

    Georgia rebukes Trump over US voter fraud ‘Big Lie’

  • Nike halts sales to retailers in Russia

    Nike halts sales to retailers in Russia

  • Shunned! Caitlyn Jenner Denied Invite To Kardashian-Barker Wedding In Italy

    Shunned! Caitlyn Jenner Denied Invite To Kardashian-Barker Wedding In Italy

  • Paranoid Putin! Russian Leader Promotes Bodyguard To Minister Following Predecessor’s Sudden & Mysterious Death

    Paranoid Putin! Russian Leader Promotes Bodyguard To Minister Following Predecessor’s Sudden & Mysterious Death

Break

  • Dyson set to preview new robots to help with tasks at home

    Dyson set to preview new robots to help with tasks at home

  • Elvis fever set to shake Cannes

    Elvis fever set to shake Cannes

  • Battle Of The Billionaires! Elon Musk SLAMS Bill Gates After Article Claims Microsoft Mogul Is Funding Musk’s Critics

    Battle Of The Billionaires! Elon Musk SLAMS Bill Gates After Article Claims Microsoft Mogul Is Funding Musk’s Critics

  • Paula Abdul planning ‘spectacular’ 60th birthday bash

    Paula Abdul planning ‘spectacular’ 60th birthday bash

RSS Partner Links

  • Morning Wood
  • Ricky Martin at first Cannes Film Festival!
  • Thomas Markle hospitalized just days before he was supposed to fly to the UK
  • “Steven Tyler recently relapsed & voluntarily checked into rehab” links
  • Shakira, Ricky Martin, & More Stars Arrive in Style for 'Elvis' Premiere at Cannes 2022
  • Every 'Survivor' Winner, Ranked in Popularity From Lowest to Highest
  • Kate Middleton Steals The Show In A Pretty Floral Fancy Hat at Buckingham Palace Garden Party
  • Chicago Fire's Stellaride Wedding Happens Tonight!
  • Beto O'Rourke Does What Needs To Be Done

Most Recent

  • ‘What is the purpose?’ NC bill on teaching LGBTQ issues likely to be blocked by governor

    ‘What is the purpose?’ NC bill on teaching LGBTQ issues likely to be blocked by governor

  • Ellen DeGeneres ends pioneering talk show under cloud

    Ellen DeGeneres ends pioneering talk show under cloud

  • New York City removes last public phone booth

    New York City removes last public phone booth

  • Johnson takes responsibility but won’t quit over lockdown parties

    Johnson takes responsibility but won’t quit over lockdown parties

  • Exclusive: Biden moves to fill key appellate seat vacated by U.S. Supreme Court’s Jackson

    Exclusive: Biden moves to fill key appellate seat vacated by U.S. Supreme Court’s Jackson

  • Monkeypox vaccine producer says enough supplies are available

    Monkeypox vaccine producer says enough supplies are available

  • LGBTQ Community Urges Viewers To Boycott Controversial Comic Ricky Gervais After ‘Anti-Trans’ Jokes

    LGBTQ Community Urges Viewers To Boycott Controversial Comic Ricky Gervais After ‘Anti-Trans’ Jokes

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 · Log in