• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Body
  • Daily Resist
  • POLITICS
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Film
  • TV
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Men
  • Marriage Equality
  • Space
  • Trans Rights
  • Books
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • TowleREAD

DOMA Challenge Heard at Federal Appeals Court in New York

September 28, 2012 by Andy Towle

Chris Geidner has an excellent report on the arguments heard yesterday in Edie Windsor's case challenging DOMA that went before the U.S. Court of Appeals in New York, which concludes with this explanation of how Paul Clement, the attorney for House Republicans defending the law, used an 1885 Mormon polygamy case to argue its constitutionality:

ClementIn his closing rebuttal, Clement told the court that Congress has overridden states’ determinations about marriage. He gave two examples: fraud statutes and conditions placed on statehood aimed at stopping polygamy.

More than 30 years before the U.S. Constitution would be amended to prohibit voting discrimination based on sex, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of a law that required those in the Utah territory to take an oath that included a statement that the male was violating bigamy or polygamy prohibitions.

The case, which cited the infamous Dred Scott Supreme Court decision declaring that slaves were not citizens under the U.S. Constitution as evidence of governmental powers in the territories, was mentioned by Clement. It’s the case, he told Judge Chester Straub, a Clinton appointee to the bench, where the Supreme Court referenced the "traditional understanding" of marriage.

The 1885 case takes a hard line on the role of marriage in the post-Civil War nation, in reference to the practice of polygamy in the Utah territory.

The court wrote that "no legislation can be supposed more wholesome and necessary in the founding of a free, self-governing commonwealth … than that which seeks to establish it on the basis of the idea of the family [is] consisting in and springing from the union for life of one man and one woman in the holy estate of matrimony."

That definition of marriage, the court wrote in 1885, is "the sure foundation of all that is stable and noble in our civilization; the best guaranty of that reverent morality which is the source of all beneficent progress in social and political improvement."

Read Geidner's full report here.

WindsorChris Johnson has more at the Washington Blade:

Paul Clement, a former U.S. solicitor general under the Bush administration, claimed before a federal appeals court that Edith Windsor doesn’t have a case because she married in Canada and her spouse, Thea Spyer, died in 2009 — two years before New York legalized same-sex marriage.

“The critical question isn’t 2012, the critical question is 2009,” Clement said.

Clement added that the issue of whether the marriage is sufficient for a challenge against DOMA should be brought to certification before the New York Court of Appeals, the highest state court in New York.

James Esseks, director of the ACLU’s Lesbian Gay Bisexual and Transgender Project, told the Blade after the oral arguments that Clement was “grasping at straws” when making these claims.

Filed Under: DOMA, Edie Windsor, New York, News Tagged With: DOMA, Edie Windsor, New York, News

Recent Posts

  • Jerome Adams, Wonka, Nats Getty, Drain the Swamp, Vogue, Patriot Party, Cher, The Lady and The Dale: HOT LINKS

    Jerome Adams, Wonka, Nats Getty, Drain the Swamp, Vogue, Patriot Party, Cher, The Lady and The Dale: HOT LINKS

    14 hours ago
  • Inauguration of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris: LIVE VIDEO

    Inauguration of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris: LIVE VIDEO

    18 hours ago
  • World #3 Golfer Justin Thomas Says He’ll Undergo ‘Better Person’ Training Program After Using Homophobic Slur

    World #3 Golfer Justin Thomas Says He’ll Undergo ‘Better Person’ Training Program After Using Homophobic Slur

    18 hours ago
  • John Bolton: Trump ‘Did Incite the Riot’ with the Intention to ‘Prevent Congress from Certifying the Vote’ — WATCH

    John Bolton: Trump ‘Did Incite the Riot’ with the Intention to ‘Prevent Congress from Certifying the Vote’ — WATCH

    18 hours ago
Previous Post: « Zac Efron on Sesame Street: VIDEO
Next Post: Honey Boo Boo’s Pro-Gay Message Gets Autotuned: VIDEO »

Primary Sidebar

  • Jerome Adams, Wonka, Nats Getty, Drain the Swamp, Vogue, Patriot Party, Cher, The Lady and The Dale: HOT LINKS

  • Inauguration of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris: LIVE VIDEO

  • World #3 Golfer Justin Thomas Says He’ll Undergo ‘Better Person’ Training Program After Using Homophobic Slur

Recent Posts

  • Jerome Adams, Wonka, Nats Getty, Drain the Swamp, Vogue, Patriot Party, Cher, The Lady and The Dale: HOT LINKS

    Jerome Adams, Wonka, Nats Getty, Drain the Swamp, Vogue, Patriot Party, Cher, The Lady and The Dale: HOT LINKS

    14 hours ago
  • Inauguration of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris: LIVE VIDEO

    Inauguration of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris: LIVE VIDEO

    18 hours ago
  • World #3 Golfer Justin Thomas Says He’ll Undergo ‘Better Person’ Training Program After Using Homophobic Slur

    World #3 Golfer Justin Thomas Says He’ll Undergo ‘Better Person’ Training Program After Using Homophobic Slur

    18 hours ago
  • John Bolton: Trump ‘Did Incite the Riot’ with the Intention to ‘Prevent Congress from Certifying the Vote’ — WATCH

    John Bolton: Trump ‘Did Incite the Riot’ with the Intention to ‘Prevent Congress from Certifying the Vote’ — WATCH

    18 hours ago
  • Disgraced Trump Leaves White House for Last Time, Holds Sendoff for Himself: WATCH

    Disgraced Trump Leaves White House for Last Time, Holds Sendoff for Himself: WATCH

    18 hours ago
  • Claudia Conway Alleges Physical and Verbal Abuse by Kellyanne Conway in Disturbing TikTok Videos: ‘Ungrateful B*tch!’ — WATCH

    Claudia Conway Alleges Physical and Verbal Abuse by Kellyanne Conway in Disturbing TikTok Videos: ‘Ungrateful B*tch!’ — WATCH

    19 hours ago
  • Democrats Urged to Reject ‘Desperate’ McConnell Effort to Preserve Filibuster and Kneecap Biden’s Agenda

    Democrats Urged to Reject ‘Desperate’ McConnell Effort to Preserve Filibuster and Kneecap Biden’s Agenda

    20 hours ago
  • Pelosi: Trump’s Role in US Capitol Insurrection Makes Him an Accessory to Murder: WATCH

    Pelosi: Trump’s Role in US Capitol Insurrection Makes Him an Accessory to Murder: WATCH

    21 hours ago
  • Trump Issues 143 Pardons and Commutations including Steve Bannon, Lil Wayne, Kwame Kilpatrick

    Trump Issues 143 Pardons and Commutations including Steve Bannon, Lil Wayne, Kwame Kilpatrick

    22 hours ago
  • Amanda Gorman, Tokyo Olympics, Putin’s Secret Estate, Dwyane Wade, Lady Gaga, Chris Evans, Hungary: HOT LINKS

    Amanda Gorman, Tokyo Olympics, Putin’s Secret Estate, Dwyane Wade, Lady Gaga, Chris Evans, Hungary: HOT LINKS

    2 days ago

Most Commented

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Footer

Copyright © 2021 · Log in