• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer
  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!
  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

Two Marriage Equality Cases in Virginia: What’s Going On?

Ari Ezra Waldman October 31, 2013

Virginia

By ARI EZRA WALDMAN

There are two federal marriage equality cases going on in Virginia. They look a lot alike: Both revolve around same-sex Virginia couples who want to marry; both challenge Virginia's explicit constitutional ban on such unions; both address the lack of recognition of valid out-of-state marriages of same-sex couples; both want to reach the Supreme Court and hope to decide, once and for all, that bans on marriage freedom are unconstitutional.

The cases differ in two critical aspects: Different courts and different lawyers.

Olson_boiesIn one case, the American Foundation of Equal Rights (AFER) and Ted Olson and David Boies have taken the lead even though it was originally filed by a local law firm. In the other case, Lambda Legal and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) have picked up the baton of marriage equality.    

Some say it's a race. Who can craft the best case. Who can win first. Who can get to the Supreme Court first. There has been some chatter among the LGBT press in this vein.

I do not dive so quickly toward paranoia. No one can deny that there's a certain competitive storm swirling around these neighboring lawsuits. After all, AFER got to the Supreme Court first, in Perry v. Brown, but the ACLU actually won an important victory in Windsor, the DOMA case. Meanwhile, Lambda was filing and winning marriage equality cases throughout the country and, of course, won us the right to be who we are ten years ago in Lawrence v. Texas. 

But there is nothing inherently wrong with a multipronged attack on marriage discrimination. In fact, we should see this as a good sign! We are, ultimately, giving the federal courts multiple ways to eradicate an odious law. Let's just make sure these multiple ways forward do not devolve into multiple battles backward.

CONTINUED, AFTER THE JUMP…

BosticFirst, here is some background on how these cases came about. Virginia is divided into two federal court districts. In the eastern part of the state, a local law firm brought a case on behalf of Timothy Bostic and Tony London. The two long-time partners would like to marry, so they and their lawyers argue that Virginia's ban on same-sex marriage violates the Equal Protection Clause and the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

Recall that we've heard those precise arguments before: In the case that ended up at the Supreme Court several months ago, Perry v. Brown. Perry was the cause celebre of the AFER and its legal team of Ted Olson and David Boies. So, it should come as no surprise that AFER, Olson, and Boies joined the Bostic case, taking the lead in the litigation.

Aclu_virginiaShortly after the original Bostic case was filed, but before AFER decided to join in the game, Lambda Legal, the country's oldest and most successful LGBT legal advocacy organization, joined with the ACLU to bring a marriage equality case in the western part of the state. That case focuses on two couples – Joanne Harris and Jessica Duff and Christy Berghoff and Victoria Kidd — whom, together, brought a comprehensive case seeking marriage rights in Virginia and the recognition of valid out-of-state marriages in Virginia, as well. 

They also want their case certified as a class action. That refers to a case where one or a few plaintiffs want to represent thousands. You can't have thousands of people show up and sit at the plaintiffs table; nor does the system want thousands of separate, yet identical cases arguing the same things. But that is exactly the scenario here: all gay couples in Virginia have precisely the same problem and precisely the same arguments against that state's marriage discrimination provision. So, a class action would bring their interests into one case and automatically apply the decision to every one of those gay Virginia couples.

That's important because normally, a trial court decision only applies to the particular plaintiffs and defendants. But, as a class action, the decision applies to all members of the class regardless of their plaintiff status.

Lambda and the ACLU are doing this to avoid any problems with the ultimate decision and to prevent any future judge or conservative interest group who might want to limit the effect of a pro-equality decision to the particular plaintiffs in the case.

And yet, as we know, there are still two cases.

It is easy to see this as a competition between lawyers for credit. Undoubtedly, being the lawyer or the organization that ends up being responsible for bringing about marriage equality nationwide is going to be a big deal. It will lead to fame, accolades, and money.

But more prongs of attack could lead to a more swift victory. Two cases in neighboring jurisdictions has the feel of overwhelming force. And overwhelming force is exactly what we need to create a 5+ majority on the Supreme Court. I am consistently reminded of now-retired Justice Sandra Day O'Connor's truism — "Rare indeed is the legal victory that is not a careful byproduct of an emerging social consensus" — and what better way to show that a consensus has emerged than case after case after case, from all over the country, finding that state bans on same-sex marriage are unconstitutional. To that end, we should want Lambda, the ACLU, and AFER to be filing so-called "competing" law suits elsewhere, not just in Virginia.

Our community has great potential if our leaders work together. We also have the potential to bury ourselves under fear, discontent, and paranoia. Our lawyers are, in fact, working together to achieve the same goal. Our media should not be so quick to condemn them as selfish competitors.

***

Follow me on Twitter: @ariezrawaldman

Ari Ezra Waldman is the Associate Director of the Institute for Information Law and Policy and a professor at New York Law School and is concurrently getting his PhD at Columbia University in New York City. He is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. Ari writes weekly posts on law and various LGBT issues.

Topics: News, Supreme Court More Posts About: Ari Ezra Waldman, Ari Ezra Waldman, david boies, David Boies, Gay Marriage, gay marriage, Law - Gay, LGBT, Law - Gay, LGBT, News, ted olson, Ted Olson, Virginia, Virginia

Related Posts
  • Former Roommate Indicted For Murder Of Florida LGBTQ Activist Jorge Diaz-Johnston, One of the Public Faces In State Fight For Marriage Equality
  • Russia Blocks Facebook, Accusing it of Restricting Access to Russian Media;
  • Survivor Benefits Payments For Same-Sex Partners Are Being Paid Under Biden, But Many Don’t Even Know They Qualify
  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Mel B will “always be open” when it comes to her sexuality. The Spice Girls singer, 48, who reunited with her bandmates including the group's ex-singer Victoria Beckham for the fashion …Read More »
  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Megan Thee Stallion is being sued for allegedly creating a hostile work environment and forcing her cameraman to watch her having lesbian sex. The 29-year-old ‘Savage' rapper faces the salacious claims …Read More »
  • Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Jonathan Bennett's life was “changed forever” by his role in ‘Mean Girls'. The 42-year-old actor starred as heartthrob Aaron Samuels in the 2004 cult classic – which followed Lindsay Lohan, Rachel …Read More »
  • Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass a gift basket after he came out as gay. The 44-year-old NSYNC star revealed the legendary singer showed his support when Lance decided to reveal …Read More »
Previous Post: « Tom of Finland’s L.A. Studio Revealed by His Muse and Mentor: VIDEO PREMIERE
Next Post: Terry McAuliffe Calls Out Ken Cuccinelli’s Rabid Homophobia in Last Days of Virginia Governor Race »

Primary Sidebar

Most Recent

  • Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer

    Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer

  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

  • Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

  • Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

  • Relationship status influences heterosexual women’s sexual prejudice towards lesbians

    Relationship status influences heterosexual women’s sexual prejudice towards lesbians

  • JoJo Siwa had a challenge transitioning to new grown-up image

    JoJo Siwa had a challenge transitioning to new grown-up image

  • Liz Hurley defends lesbian sex scene in new movie that was directed by her son

    Liz Hurley defends lesbian sex scene in new movie that was directed by her son

Partner Links

  • Immorality And More
    Open thread below... read more
  • Randy Rainbow visits with Kelly Clarkson
    “She wanted to raise the gayest kid on Long Island!” Comedian […]
  • Song of the Day: 'Only Love Can Break Your Heart' by Saint Etienne
    Today marks exactly 35 years since the release of Saint Etienne's […]
  • Baldwin Isn't Fire, But She'll Keep A Simmering Heat On RFK Jr.
    Earlier this month, Wisconsin Sen. Tammy Baldwin confronted RFK, Jr, about […]
  • Remains of the Day (05/28)
    Out: Benito Skinner teases "Overcompensating" season 2 storylinesCBS News: Infant fatally […]

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

About

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Ptown Hacks 2018

Read

  • Travel
  • Film
  • Law – LGBT Rights
  • Columns
  • Specials

About

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 · Log in

×
×