• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Politics
  • Health
  • Travel
  • Gay Pride
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Men
  • Space
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Monkeypox
  • Film/TV

Trump’s Cruel and Irrational Travel Ban Guidance: A Legal Analysis

Ari Ezra Waldman June 30, 2017 Leave a Comment

signing trump

On Monday, the United States Supreme Court allowed a severely limited Muslim travel ban to go into effect. On Thursday, the Trump Administration was ready with its guidance for implementing that decision. To no one’s surprise, the guidance makes absolutely no sense. And, as such, it probably violates the Court’s order.

Despite his protestations to the contrary, Donald Trump campaigned on banning Muslims from coming into this country. He keeps calling it a “travel ban.” He even took the opportunity to radically misunderstand an tragedy in London to call for the immediate implementation of his ban. But the law is getting in his way.

Within hours of Trump announcing his first travel ban, protests erupted at almost every major city. Lawyers challenged the ban’s constitutionality in various district courts, challenges that culminated in nationwide injunctions preventing the order from going into effect. Several of those decisions held that the travel ban discriminated on the basis of religion. A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit, which was hastily assembled for a teleconference to hear the Administration’s appeal of the injunction, slapped the Administration down, as well. The Ninth Circuit’s reasoning was a little narrower: The Administration exceeded its statutory authority in issuing the ban.

The ban, for the most part, never went into effect. The injunction held. The travel ban was revised, but the injunctions remained. Then, on Monday, a divided Supreme Court held that some version of the travel ban could go into effect.

But the Court put a significant restriction in place. The injunction would remain for “foreign nationals who have a credible claim of a bona fide relationship with a person or entity in the United States,” meaning Trump could not stop them from coming in. But the Administration could keep out those persons who did not, thus suspending some immigration and the refugee program for “foreign nationals abroad who have no connection to the United States at all.”

We can debate the validity of that decision, but set that aside for the moment.

The Administration translated “bona fide relationship” into “close family.” These are the family relationships Trump thinks are “bona fide” or “close”: “parent (including parent-in-law), spouse, child, adult son or daughter, son-in-law, daughter-in-law, sibling, whether whole or half. This includes step relationships.”

Who is not included? “‘Close family’ does not include grandparents, grandchildren, aunts, uncles, nieces, nephews, cousins, and any other ‘extended’ family members.”

When I read the Court’s decision, I thought the problem would be agents on the ground trying to implement an ambiguous standard. Instead, the Administration issued a cruel, rigid, and dishonest interpretation of the Court’s order.

First, it gets the Court’s decision wrong. The Court said that the only people to whom the Administration could apply the travel ban were those “foreign nationals abroad who have no connection to the United States at all” and “a foreign national who lacks any connection to this country.” Under no circumstances do grandparents and grandkids have no connection to each other. The Supreme Court’s restriction was meant to make the ban extremely narrow. Trump basically ignored the limitation.

Second, it’s too rigid. “Bona fide” relationships often exist between grandparents and grandchildren and between aunts and uncles and nieces and nephews. Not every family looks like every other family. Sometimes, grandparents raise their children’s kids. Sometimes, extended family members live with each other. Sometimes, nuclear family members are estranged. And, as the LGBTQ community knows well, sometimes two men and two women who cannot marry are the closest families around.

Third, and worst of all, this “bona fide relationship” or “close family” rule is being applied to refugees from a war zone. Syria has been destroyed by war for nearly 7 years. Some estimates put the death toll at 400,000 Syrians. It’s not unreasonable to think that the very refugees who are desperately trying to escape death have lost family members, many of whom couldn’t make it anywhere, let alone the United States. To suggest that every refugee needs not only a relationship but an artificially close relationship will basically make it impossible for all but a very lucky few.

The implementing guidance needs to be challenged. The travel ban needs to go. So does Trump.

Topics: Supreme Court, towleroad More Posts About: Ari Ezra Waldman, Donald Trump, immigration, Law - Gay, LGBT, Muslim travel ban, Refugee, Syria

Related Posts
  • Georgia rebukes Trump over US voter fraud ‘Big Lie’
  • U.S. commission recommends renaming nine Army bases to strip Confederate legacy
  • Factbox: Seven races to watch in Georgia, Alabama midterm primaries, Texas run-offs
  • Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60

    Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60. The keyboardist and founding member – who was born in Nottingham and moved to Basildon in the 70s – of the 80s band …Read More »
  • TV board dismisses Senator’s request to allow parents to shield kids from LGBTQ characters; Cites 95% Parent Satisfaction With Ratings

    TV board dismisses Senator’s request to allow parents to shield kids from LGBTQ characters; Cites 95% Parent Satisfaction With Ratings

      Published by The Kansas City Star   The TV Parental Guidelines Monitoring Board dismissed a request from Sen. Roger Marshall, a Republican from Kansas, asking them to update their ratings system so parents could shield …Read More »
  • Apple unveils new Pride Apple Watch bands and watch face

    Apple unveils new Pride Apple Watch bands and watch face

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Apple has unveiled new Pride bands and a watch face for the Apple Watch to mark Pride Month. The tech giant is releasing a Pride Edition Sport Loop and the Pride …Read More »
  • Lithuanian parliament agrees to consider same-sex partnership bill

    Lithuanian parliament agrees to consider same-sex partnership bill

    Published by Reuters UK By Andrius Sytas VILNIUS (Reuters) – Lithuania’s parliament on Thursday voted to accept a draft bill legalizing same-sex civil partnerships for further debate, after voting down a similar bill in May 2021. …Read More »
Previous Post: « Georgia Teen Is the 14th – and Youngest – Transgender Murder Victim This Year
Next Post: Sandy Rios: ‘Sordid’ Gay Men Denied Dignity By Pro-LGBT Christians – LISTEN »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Trump must testify in New York probe, appeals court rules

    Trump must testify in New York probe, appeals court rules

  • Guns are now the leading cause of death for American children

    Guns are now the leading cause of death for American children

  • The staggering toll of gun violence in the United States

    The staggering toll of gun violence in the United States

  • Georgia rebukes Trump over US voter fraud ‘Big Lie’

    Georgia rebukes Trump over US voter fraud ‘Big Lie’

Break

  • Dyson set to preview new robots to help with tasks at home

    Dyson set to preview new robots to help with tasks at home

  • Elvis fever set to shake Cannes

    Elvis fever set to shake Cannes

  • Battle Of The Billionaires! Elon Musk SLAMS Bill Gates After Article Claims Microsoft Mogul Is Funding Musk’s Critics

    Battle Of The Billionaires! Elon Musk SLAMS Bill Gates After Article Claims Microsoft Mogul Is Funding Musk’s Critics

  • Paula Abdul planning ‘spectacular’ 60th birthday bash

    Paula Abdul planning ‘spectacular’ 60th birthday bash

RSS Partner Links

  • OMG, Will Poulter is all grown up and lookin’ like a shirtless snack while in Ibiza with Florence Pugh
  • Kevin Spacey HAD A Secret
  • OMG Playlist: May 2022
  • WATCH: Ellen DeGeneres shares how she almost gave her writer the Medal of Freedom by accident
  • Birthday Sluts
  • Page 1 Roundup (05/26)
  • A Look 'Beyond the Law'
  • Wrestle Wednesday
  • Morning Wood

Most Recent

  • Actor Kevin Spacey facing sexual assault charges in UK

    Actor Kevin Spacey facing sexual assault charges in UK

  • Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60

    Depeche Mode’s Andy Fletcher has died aged 60

  • TV board dismisses Senator’s request to allow parents to shield kids from LGBTQ characters; Cites 95% Parent Satisfaction With Ratings

    TV board dismisses Senator’s request to allow parents to shield kids from LGBTQ characters; Cites 95% Parent Satisfaction With Ratings

  • Apple unveils new Pride Apple Watch bands and watch face

    Apple unveils new Pride Apple Watch bands and watch face

  • Lithuanian parliament agrees to consider same-sex partnership bill

    Lithuanian parliament agrees to consider same-sex partnership bill

  • German minister warns against homophobia amid monkeypox outbreak

    German minister warns against homophobia amid monkeypox outbreak

  • Todd Chrisley’s ‘Ex Lover’ and Business Partner Confirms Gay Affair, Blackmail While Testifying On Helping ‘Chrisley Knows Best’ Star, Wife Julie  Commit Fraud

    Todd Chrisley’s ‘Ex Lover’ and Business Partner Confirms Gay Affair, Blackmail While Testifying On Helping ‘Chrisley Knows Best’ Star, Wife Julie Commit Fraud

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 · Log in