• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox

The False and Insulting Argument About Hitler, Guns, and the Jews

Ari Ezra Waldman October 3, 2017 Leave a Comment

Yesterday, I responded to conservatives’ legal argument that the Second Amendment, which the Supreme Court has read to sort of create a right for individuals to own some firearms for the sole purpose of self-defense in the home, would make reasonable gun safety legislation–background checks, assault weapons bans, registration, buy backs, etc.–unconstitutional. Today, I would like to respond to the oft-repeated, yet profoundly offensive argument that because Hitler used gun control to oppress, persecute, and ultimately destroy Europe’s Jews, legislative steps toward gun safety are attempts by the State to pacify the populace and take away all our rights.

Hitler never said this meme. He lessoned gun controls by the previous leaders. He allowed more guns, to Nazis but denied them to jews/blacks pic.twitter.com/wEgsDZ5T3r

— Michelle Hairston (@hairmich42) October 3, 2017

Never mind that this argument was first peddled by Holocaust deniers decades ago. Never mind that it pops up after every gun massacre in this country on right-wing, fake news, incendiary websites. As a family friend once told me, just because someone denies the Holocaust doesn’t mean that they’re wrong about everything. (Let that statement sink in, by the way.). But, in this case, this argument is misleading and an insult to history, Jews, and all the Nazis’ victims.

Here’s the argument: The best way to take total control of a population is to monopolize power, force, and weaponry. So, to ensure that the Jews couldn’t fight back, Hitler took away their guns. In his 1994 book, the mouthpiece of the National Rifle Association (NRA), Wayne LaPierre, talked about this story quite a bit, writing: “In Germany, Jewish extermination began with the Nazi Weapon Law of 1938, signed by Adolf Hitler.” FOX News commentators, Joe “The Plumber”, and even an organization called  Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership (“America’s most aggressive defender of firearms ownership”) spread the Hitler-guns-Jews story.

Except it’s all a lie.

In the aftermath of World War I, the Weimar Republic passed a law in 1919 that basically banned all private gun ownership, which makes Weimar tougher on guns among the population than Hitler ever was. Hitler’s 1938 law, far from being a gun control measure, almost completely deregulated the use, possession, and sale of firearms, including ammunition. And anyone who was a member of the Nazi Party could buy, sell, use, possess, tinker with, and whatever else they could think of doing with guns. The one thing conservatives get right is that the 1938 law, as part of Hitler’s campaign to institutionalize discrimination and persecution of Jews, did prohibit Jews from owning guns. But far from using gun confiscation as a means of oppressing the populace, Hitler used mass gun ownership among the privileged — Aryans — to oppress minorities — Jews, gypsies, and gays. Hitler’s Aryan population used the guns Hitler let it have to trash Jewish-owned businesses, to rough up Jewish people on the street, and to engage in what were called pogroms in Russia.

This rings true today. In America, guns are often a tool that white, heterosexual males use to oppress others. Statistics show that most mass shooters also have a history of domestic violence. And white men are far more able to exercise their gun rights in this country than black men, some of whom are shot for having legal firearms. Queer persons are on the receiving end of gun violence at far higher rates than almost every other minority group, and those rates are increasing as we hear more about the deaths of transgender individuals every year.

The Hitler gun control myth is not just an insult to reality, it’s an insult to his victims. The notion that the Jews, whether in the Warsaw ghetto uprising or long before, could have used the rifles and handguns that were in the legitimate and black markets for guns to stop the SS from herding them like cattle to their deaths, is offensive. Hitler deployed military-trained units to destroy Europe’s Jews; handguns and rifles would not have made a dent. To suggest that it would have implies that the Jews had a path to resist the Nazis’ Final Solution. They didn’t. Nor would the Warsaw ghetto uprising have had a different result. Those resistors had guns, and still only managed to kill 20 Germans. More than 13,000 Jews were killed by Hitler’s forces by the end of the uprising, with the rest carted off to death camps.

This story, that Hitler’s taking away of gun from the Jews is a lesson against reasonable gun safety legislation, is peddled by everyone from Holocaust deniers as well as Jews themselves, not to mention by Republicans in Congress. It is, however, a canard, a misdirection away from the fact that Republicans in Congress are bought and paid for by the NRA and are comfortable with a lot of white Christians having guns. Notably, so was Hitler.

Topics: Deaths, History More Posts About: Adolf Hitler, Ari Ezra Waldman, Gun Contol, Guns, Law - Gay, LGBT, NRA

Related Posts
  • This Arab is Queer celebrates diversity of LGBTQ+ experience
  • Thousands gather in Tel Aviv for LGBT Pride march
  • Activists Rally, Make Case For Thailand Marriage Equality; Present Rewritten Version of Constitutional Court’s Ruling On Marriage Law
  • US Capitol assault panel to hear from key White House aide

    US Capitol assault panel to hear from key White House aide

    Published by AFP Former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson has already featured in videotaped depositions at two of the committee's hearings Washington (AFP) – A former top White House aide with unique access to Donald Trump …Read More »
  • Mac Engel: If you support HS coach who prayed after game, then then you must back Colin Kaepernick

    Mac Engel: If you support HS coach who prayed after game, then then you must back Colin Kaepernick

    Published by Fort Worth Star-Telegram Given the nature of our third branch of government, the United States Supreme Court, the ruling is no surprise. Before the court goes after the gay marriage, interracial marriage and a …Read More »
  • Cara Delevingne loves being able to ‘represent’ the gay community

    Cara Delevingne loves being able to ‘represent’ the gay community

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Cara Delevingne loves being able to “represent” the queer community in ‘Only Murders in the Building’. The 29-year-old model – who identifies as pansexual and is currently thought to be dating …Read More »
  • US abortion ruling roils midterm election campaign

    US abortion ruling roils midterm election campaign

    Published by AFP Nadine Seiler was one of thousands of protesters attending weekend rallies for and against abortion rights across the United States Washington (AFP) – The US Supreme Court’s ruling ending the nationwide right to …Read More »
Previous Post: « ‘Shade,’ ‘Scandal,’ Sam Smith Does ‘SNL’ and More TV this Week
Next Post: International Male Athletes Strip Down to Nothing for the 2018 Dieux Du Stade Calendar: WATCH »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Ghislaine Maxwell’s sentencing hearing for sex trafficking kicks off

    Ghislaine Maxwell’s sentencing hearing for sex trafficking kicks off

  • Former Nazi concentration camp guard, now 101, given 5 years in jail

    Former Nazi concentration camp guard, now 101, given 5 years in jail

  • Defy this Supreme Court. Smuggle abortion pills to women in Texas. | Moran

    Defy this Supreme Court. Smuggle abortion pills to women in Texas. | Moran

RSS Partner Links

  • Morning Wood
  • Nude Awakening: A Review Of BROADWAY BARES XXX
  • Johnny Sibilly on his surreal 2022: “Need to lay down but the happiest guy in the world”
  • Kelly Clarkson's Producer Explains Why She Wasn't at Daytime Emmys 2022 After Winning Two Awards
  • Machine Gun Kelly & Megan Fox Match in Pink at His 'Life in Pink' Premiere!
  • “Justin Timberlake & Jessica Biel went to the Louis Vuitton show” links
  • Prince Charles accepted literal suitcases full of cash from shady billionaires

Most Recent

  • Steve-O: Jackass was a bad influence

    Steve-O: Jackass was a bad influence

  • US Capitol assault panel to hear from key White House aide

    US Capitol assault panel to hear from key White House aide

  • Mac Engel: If you support HS coach who prayed after game, then then you must back Colin Kaepernick

    Mac Engel: If you support HS coach who prayed after game, then then you must back Colin Kaepernick

  • Cara Delevingne loves being able to ‘represent’ the gay community

    Cara Delevingne loves being able to ‘represent’ the gay community

  • US abortion ruling roils midterm election campaign

    US abortion ruling roils midterm election campaign

  • Elliot Page applauds Umbrella Academy’s transgender storyline

    Elliot Page applauds Umbrella Academy’s transgender storyline

  • Chris Hemsworth preserved modesty with a sock during Thor nude scene

    Chris Hemsworth preserved modesty with a sock during Thor nude scene

  • ‘They’re As Safe As They Are In A Classroom’: Sarah Huckabee Sanders Faces Intense Backlash Over Bizarre Abortion Comparison

    ‘They’re As Safe As They Are In A Classroom’: Sarah Huckabee Sanders Faces Intense Backlash Over Bizarre Abortion Comparison

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in