• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Body
  • Daily Resist
  • POLITICS
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Film
  • TV
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Men
  • Marriage Equality
  • Space
  • Trans Rights
  • Books
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • TowleREAD

After Massachusetts City Recognizes Polyamorous Relationships, Right-Wingers Blame the Gays

July 3, 2020 by John Wright Leave a Comment

Somerville, Massachusetts, became the first city in the U.S. to recognize polyamorous relationships this week.

CNN reports: The domestic partnership ordinance was brought to the city council recently as a means to help residents who are not married to visit their partners who are sick with coronavirus at the hospital, according to [Councilor Lance] Davis. Right before the meeting last Thursday where the ordinance was going to be voted on, Councilor JT Scott suggested to Davis it should include partnerships of more than two people. The domestic partnership ordinance was brought to the council by Davis to encompass this change in a virtual meeting Thursday evening. Davis recommended tweaking the ordinance so that partners weren’t required to live together or inform the city of change of address. Mayor Joseph Curtatone signed the ordinance into law Monday, according to Davis.

Not surprisingly, right-wing commentators are resurrecting their “slippery slope” arguments — blaming the Somerville ordinance on the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2015 Obergefell decision in favor of nationwide marriage equality.

At the Christian site LifeSite News, Jonathan Van Maren compared Somerville’s ordinance to Utah’s recent decision to decriminalize polygamy, which he also blamed on Obergefell. Van Maren’s article is titled, “Massachusetts city approves polyamory, the inevitable consequence of gay ‘marriage.’”

“Once marriage was redefined and placed in a panoply of morally acceptable romantic arrangements, it was only a matter of time before the number of partners would mean as much as the sex of the partners. Which is to say, nothing. Even promiscuous multi-taskers can demand that the government endorse and financially support their sexual arrangements,” Van Maren wrote. “The word ‘family’ now has no readily available meaning, and as such, the goalposts are shifting accordingly. … Once again, a government body is throwing its weight behind a new definition of family—and making a moral statement in the process. By claiming that we do not know what a ‘family’ is, they are claiming we cannot know what a family is—and that, by definition, means it is whatever you want it to be. After all, if gender is fluid, why not marriage?

Ryan T. Anderson, a senior research fellow at the Heritage Institute, told the Catholic News Agency: “Of course it was never going to stop with same-sex couples. Once you redefine marriage to eliminate the male-female component, what principle requires monogamy? … Once the law and culture says the male-female aspect of marriage violates justice and equality, we haven’t ‘expanded’ marriage, we’ve fundamentally redefined what it is. And those redefinitions have no principled stopping point.”

2013: "If the law redefines marriage to say the male-female aspect is arbitrary, what principle will be left to retain monogamy? If justice demands redefining marriage to include the same-sex couple, [what about] the throuple? Love equals love, after all." https://t.co/0VJT1CxrXH

— Ryan T. Anderson (@RyanTAnd) July 2, 2020

On Twitter, Anderson claimed that he predicted the recognition of polyamory in 2013. Texas Republican Congressman Chip Roy retweeted Anderson, adding: “Really not gratifying being correct, is it?”

Really not gratifying being correct, is it? https://t.co/KFX9zy7Bcq

— Chip Roy (@chiproytx) July 3, 2020

A few more examples from Twitter below.

Slippery slope arguments are no longer fallacies. pic.twitter.com/oFWd2Jbl9i

— Derek Rishmawy (@DZRishmawy) July 2, 2020

I warned about this years ago and was mocked for saying it, but if love is love, why not legally recognize polyamorous relationships? Well, a Massachusetts city has done just that, "broadening the definition of domestic partnership to include relationships btw. 3 or more adults."

— Dr. Michael L. Brown (@DrMichaelLBrown) July 2, 2020

So I take the July break from #TheBriefing and by July 2 a Mass. city recognized “polyamorous” relationships. Just as we predicted. Five years after sane-arm marriage was legalized by SCOTUS decrees, here in polyamory remanding recognition, and getting it. https://t.co/Pc64Xk3ybc

— Albert Mohler (@albertmohler) July 2, 2020

Slippery slope is true when the underlying change is larger than understood. Marriage is man and woman. Liberals said no, it is 2 people. They said a definition held for all of human history is wrong, and think they will be able to defend the number 2. Wrong. Why not 3, bigot?

— Waiting for Cromwell (@lziics) July 3, 2020

Filed Under: towleroad Tagged With: Gay, gay marriage, marriage equality, Massaschusetts, Obergefell, polyamorous, same-sex marriage, Somerville, Supreme Court

Recent Posts

  • Klete Keller, Eric Trump, Bobby Christine, Prince Harry’s Ponytail, Ellen’s COVID, Adam Newbold, Mo Brooks, Paul Gosar: HOT LINKS

    Klete Keller, Eric Trump, Bobby Christine, Prince Harry’s Ponytail, Ellen’s COVID, Adam Newbold, Mo Brooks, Paul Gosar: HOT LINKS

    5 hours ago
  • Brendan Fraser to Play Reclusive, Morbidly Obese Gay Man in Darren Aronofsky’s ‘The Whale’

    Brendan Fraser to Play Reclusive, Morbidly Obese Gay Man in Darren Aronofsky’s ‘The Whale’

    8 hours ago
  • New Video Shows Insurrectionists Discussing Layout of U.S. Capitol, Coordinating Plan of Attack: WATCH

    New Video Shows Insurrectionists Discussing Layout of U.S. Capitol, Coordinating Plan of Attack: WATCH

    9 hours ago
  • Ayanna Pressley’s Chief of Staff Says Panic Button Unit Was Torn Out of Congresswoman’s Office Prior to US Capitol Attack

    Ayanna Pressley’s Chief of Staff Says Panic Button Unit Was Torn Out of Congresswoman’s Office Prior to US Capitol Attack

    9 hours ago
Previous Post: « GOP Elections Official Sounds Alarm: ‘The Blacks are Having Lots of Events for Voter Registration’ (VIDEO)
Next Post: Mt. Rushmore, Redskins, Dr. Fauci, Peter Thiel, Tucker Carlson, Ellen DeGeneres, Godzilla, Yvie Oddly, RuPaul, Alanis Morissette, Kelly Clarkson: HOT LINKS »

Primary Sidebar

  • Klete Keller, Eric Trump, Bobby Christine, Prince Harry’s Ponytail, Ellen’s COVID, Adam Newbold, Mo Brooks, Paul Gosar: HOT LINKS

  • Brendan Fraser to Play Reclusive, Morbidly Obese Gay Man in Darren Aronofsky’s ‘The Whale’

  • New Video Shows Insurrectionists Discussing Layout of U.S. Capitol, Coordinating Plan of Attack: WATCH

Recent Posts

  • Klete Keller, Eric Trump, Bobby Christine, Prince Harry’s Ponytail, Ellen’s COVID, Adam Newbold, Mo Brooks, Paul Gosar: HOT LINKS

    Klete Keller, Eric Trump, Bobby Christine, Prince Harry’s Ponytail, Ellen’s COVID, Adam Newbold, Mo Brooks, Paul Gosar: HOT LINKS

    5 hours ago
  • Brendan Fraser to Play Reclusive, Morbidly Obese Gay Man in Darren Aronofsky’s ‘The Whale’

    Brendan Fraser to Play Reclusive, Morbidly Obese Gay Man in Darren Aronofsky’s ‘The Whale’

    8 hours ago
  • New Video Shows Insurrectionists Discussing Layout of U.S. Capitol, Coordinating Plan of Attack: WATCH

    New Video Shows Insurrectionists Discussing Layout of U.S. Capitol, Coordinating Plan of Attack: WATCH

    9 hours ago
  • Ayanna Pressley’s Chief of Staff Says Panic Button Unit Was Torn Out of Congresswoman’s Office Prior to US Capitol Attack

    Ayanna Pressley’s Chief of Staff Says Panic Button Unit Was Torn Out of Congresswoman’s Office Prior to US Capitol Attack

    9 hours ago
  • MAGA Karen Heckles Chuck Schumer, Says Trump Insurrection Made Her ‘Sexually Excited’ — WATCH

    MAGA Karen Heckles Chuck Schumer, Says Trump Insurrection Made Her ‘Sexually Excited’ — WATCH

    10 hours ago
  • NYC Mayor Says City is Severing All Trump Organization Contracts: ‘Inciting an Insurrection Against the US Govt Clearly Constitutes Criminal Activity’ — WATCH

    NYC Mayor Says City is Severing All Trump Organization Contracts: ‘Inciting an Insurrection Against the US Govt Clearly Constitutes Criminal Activity’ — WATCH

    10 hours ago
  • Amid Reports McConnell Backs Trump Impeachment, GOP Leader Urged to Prove It By Starting Trial ‘Immediately’

    Amid Reports McConnell Backs Trump Impeachment, GOP Leader Urged to Prove It By Starting Trial ‘Immediately’

    11 hours ago
  • House Takes Up Second Impeachment of Donald Trump for ‘Incitement of Insurrection’ — WATCH LIVE

    House Takes Up Second Impeachment of Donald Trump for ‘Incitement of Insurrection’ — WATCH LIVE

    11 hours ago
  • Rachel Maddow Lets Trump Have It in Withering Monologue: ‘What Did You Think Was Going to Happen? Did You Think It Would Work?’ — WATCH

    Rachel Maddow Lets Trump Have It in Withering Monologue: ‘What Did You Think Was Going to Happen? Did You Think It Would Work?’ — WATCH

    11 hours ago
  • GOP Lawmakers Flipping Out Over New Metal Detectors Outside House Chamber: WATCH

    GOP Lawmakers Flipping Out Over New Metal Detectors Outside House Chamber: WATCH

    12 hours ago

Most Commented

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Footer

Copyright © 2021 · Log in