Education | Gay Rights | Ireland | News | Ohio

Suspended UT Administrator Crystal Dixon Fired, Will Sue

Earlier this month, I posted about University of Toledo associate vice president of human resources Crystal Dixon, who was suspended after writing an article in the Toledo Free Press slamming gays. Late last week, UT decided to fire her. 13ABC interviewed Dixon on Friday, about an hour after she was let go, calling the decision a "lack of courageous leadership." She also says she's suing the university.

DixonSaid Dixon in the article, "As a Black woman ... I take great umbrage at the notion that those choosing the homosexual lifestyle are civil rights victims. I cannot wake up tomorrow and not be a Black woman. Daily thousands of homosexuals make a life decision to leave the gay lifestyle."

She concluded: "My final and most important point. There is a divine order. God created human kind male and female (Genesis 1:27). God created humans with an inalienable right to choose. There are consequences for each of our choices, including those who violate God's divine order."

Said Dixon: "I have great faith. This is a far bigger picture than just Crystal Dixon....I have a wonderful, absolutely wonderful legal team. I have received hundreds of emails from across the country. Even received an email from Iceland, today. Basically encouraging me, basically telling me to stand strong...There are three issues - first of all, my right to free speech. Anyone has the freedom in this country to express their opinion as an individual. And secondly, clearly, religious discrimination, and also race discrimination at the very least."

As for what she wants from the university, Dixon said: "We're just going to see how this plays out."

UT administrator fired for speaking out [13abc]

Feed This post's comment feed


  1. What about my religious right as a (gay) Christian to get married and have the legal right to protect my family from harm? There's no one out there fighting in the courts for my religious right to get married to another man, the one I love, the one to whom God has led me. I'm sick of people crying out about "free speech" when they are just out to promote hate. I would rather God judge me for loving too much than for promoting injustice.

    Posted by: ekay | May 12, 2008 5:54:13 PM

  2. She can too wake up tomorrow and not be a black woman. She can have a sex change and it looks to me like she could pass, at least for Latino.

    Probably she can't wake up and be any smarter, though. Human resources is certainly not her calling. Can you imagine hiring an open racist or misogynist for that position on the grounds of free speech?

    Posted by: kevinvt | May 12, 2008 6:06:28 PM

  3. I woke up this morning and considered pulling the parachute on the Gay lifestyle but then realized: Holy Toledo! Who is going to plan Crystals’ pity party in Iceland? Also, everyone should support efforts to free her heart from the Icelandic glacier in which it is imprisoned.

    UT's case against her will rest on her role as a human resource professional and her publicly stated belief that homosexuals are not entitled to civil rights. UT will argue that some of their customers and employees are Gay and that they cannot trust Ms. Dixon to treat them fairly. Free speech has consequences and we see those consequences when a politician or celebrity loses their job or credibility when they spew out hate. Why should Ms. Dixon be treated differently?

    Posted by: mikeinmaryland | May 12, 2008 6:19:59 PM

  4. I dont know why I find the expression "as a black woman"... or better yet
    "as as strong black woman" so amusing... blah... blah... blah... As a strong gay white handsome man I blah blah blah. not as catchy

    Posted by: Olaf- | May 12, 2008 6:20:38 PM

  5. I'm black and I'm gay and I hate this woman like poison. Love to have nickel for those just like her I've tripped over in my 61 years -- kicking every one that I couldn't manage to grab hold of personally and bitch-slap silly.

    Hey Crystal -- your God is a greedy, manipulative bottom!

    Posted by: David Ehrenstein | May 12, 2008 6:22:40 PM

  6. The same free speech right that protects us also protects her. She shouldn't be fired for having an opinion. She should be fired for comparing the incomes of a college educated gay male to a non-college educated black male. Now that is just stunningly idiotic.

    Posted by: yoshi | May 12, 2008 6:26:55 PM

  7. Michael Jackson went to sleep and woke up a white woman and so did LaToya.

    Also, EQUAL OPPORTUNITY does not benefit me as a White Gay Man. Maybe Ms. Dixon should thank her lucky stars that she landed the job she had because I am sure she was hired because of EQUAL OPPORTUNITY! UT passed over much more qualified candidates because she was born an IGNORANT BLACK RACIST WOMAN.

    There I said it! YES AFRICAN AMERICAN's/ BLACKS can be and are RACIST!

    Posted by: John | May 12, 2008 6:27:03 PM

  8. ANON and LANDON BRYCE are correct. This woman is casting a VERY negative light on the university, especially if they are trying (as most colleges are) to attract out-of-state faculty, students, and staff.

    DP benefits look great to potential collegians; bigoted HR personnel - not so much.

    The university did the right (and, since it deals w/ their reputation and future ability to hire personnel and attract PAYING students) and LEGAL thing in this case.

    Posted by: neff | May 12, 2008 6:36:35 PM

  9. I can not believe Ms. Dixon! Can't we deport her to Iceland?

    Dear Ms. Dixon.

    My Great Grandfather was taken in the middle of the night from his home and family by the Nazi's in 1942 and sent to the Sauchenshousen Concentration camp. He was tattooed and a Pink Triangle was sewn onto his camp uniform. My Grandfather was a Political Advocate a Lawyer who stood up to racism for Jews, Foreigners and his fellow Germans, but was branded a Homosexual by the Nazi's because THE BIBLE SAID Homosexual's were BAD and because it was EASY for the Nazi's to say to eliminate those that stood against their policies of extermination and racism.

    My Grandfather was rectally violated, subjected to medical experiments that included the removal of one of his kidneys and a portion of his liver. All so the Nazi's could find the Gay Gene. He was beaten, starved and eventually sent to Auschwitz for castration by the Nazis. All because the Bible said so and he dared to stand against Racism, Genocide and hatred.

    He died in Auschwitz. My Grandmother was too afraid to claim his remains for fear her children would be taken by the Nazi's! When the war ended and my Grandmother and my father and uncles moved to the United States they did everything they could to eradicate HATE around them.

    My Grandmother marched with M.L. King! To her Hate was Hate.

    Dear Ms. Dixon. When I came out as a Gay Man my Grandmother cried. Not tears of pain , but tears of JOY because my Grandfather died so I could have Equal Rights and could be proud to be myself. Ms. Dixon you disgust me!

    Finally, ever last Nazi Doctor from the Camps had a Great Legal Team too! Good Luck, god bless and I forgive your words. I hope you can live with yourself.

    Posted by: AngryGayMan | May 12, 2008 6:42:18 PM

  10. It's amazing how everyone in this nation has freedom of speech... UNLESS you question someone's "right" to spew their "religious dogma" and belittle, insult, or offend someone who doesn't hold the same beliefs.

    Question a X-ian, question a cathlick, then you're a mean, old, nasty bigot. A hater.

    Just ask Bill "I can't read my tele-prompter! How can I battle the War on Xmas?" O'Lielly

    Posted by: MikeinSanJose | May 12, 2008 6:49:01 PM

  11. Cynthia,

    There was a time, not very long ago, that if you dared to look disrespectfully at a White Man or Woman you were considered in violation of God's Divine Order.

    There was a time, not very long ago, that if you dared to speak to a White Man or Woman you were considered in violation of God's Divine Order.

    And the KKK would tell you right before they slipped the noose around your neck and set fire to the cross. "Cynthia. God gave you the right to choose, but you choose wrong. Now deal with the consequences."

    I agree with AngryGayMan. She just wants to further polarize America. Create another Nazi regime. I was stationed in Frankfurt Germany for 4 years and let me tell you Cynthia - The new NeoNazis given a choice between beating a Gay or a Black. They'd pick the Black Man or Woman.

    You are full of hate and need deported.

    Posted by: Darren | May 12, 2008 7:07:07 PM

  12. @AngryGayMan:
    The Nazis didn't believe in the Bible. They were against gay people because they believed in eugenics.

    Posted by: Chris | May 12, 2008 7:11:21 PM

  13. I hope she realizes that all she is doing is serving the Hate Mongers in Politics. Giving them strength!

    There will come a day when Cynthia Dixon will think that she's invited to the Oval Office for her service to rid America of the Big Ol' Gay Threat and the Secret Police will be waiting for her. She will then learn that it is the White Man, the Blue Blooded American, that needed her hate to come to power, but they're done with her inferior skin color or genetic make up. And waiting for her will be a cattle car to take her to a nice friendly work camp. There she will meet the new Dr. Mengele. She might go to sleep a Black Woman, but the new Dr. Mengele will douse her with battery acid, bleach and other chemicals. She'll wake up a white woman, but be half dead and suffering on her way to the gas chambers!

    You worked at a University! Check out the library! Learn about history! Hate groups use people like you to come to power then they cast away everyone that is not like them. Why don't just blame Jewish people too!

    Posted by: Ugh | May 12, 2008 7:15:48 PM

  14. "The Nazis didn't believe in the Bible. They were against gay people because they believed in eugenics." .... THE party leaders MAY have not believed in the bible - but the GERMAN PEOPLE who ALLOWED the NAZI thugs to remain in power - allowed them to remain in power IN THE NAME OF GOD AND THE BIBLE. The GERMAN PEOPLE were made to believe supporting NAZI POWER was following the word of GOD - just like what is happening in this country today. It is not the NAZI PARTY that is to blame for the 1940's attrocity in Germany and the world - the GERMAN PEOPLE who believed the GOD LIE and believed a POLITICAL PARTY that said it was GODS PARTY. Just like BUSH and the NEOCONS are not to blame for the destruction of America in this decade. The people who voted for Bush are to blame(rigged elections or not). The people who support lie of RELIGION in POLITICS are to blame.

    Posted by: rjp3 | May 12, 2008 7:18:56 PM

  15. As VP of Human Resources, she would be responsible for carrying out the university's equal opportunity policy, which covers both sexual orientation and gender identity. Her comments indicate that it is questionable as to whether or not she could faithfully adhear to the policy, and therefore be unable to perform her job. Also, as an officer of the university, she is a representative to the public and any actions on her part, whether or not in an official capacity, reflect on the university as a whole. So I do think that her statement does constitute a valid reason for possible dismissal.

    Her speech evidences her inability to do her job so I don't think this is a free speech issue at all.

    Posted by: matteo | May 12, 2008 7:21:54 PM

  16. Why is bisexuality - and the bisexuals who decide to live "straight" - never addressed by these people.

    Gays do not become straight.

    Bisexuals decide to suppress their same sex desired and claim to be ex-gay - or gay people delude themself and become assexual.

    No homosexual has ever become straight, or they were not homosexual.

    Posted by: RJP3 | May 12, 2008 7:22:07 PM

  17. She's right on at least one count. I'll give her the free speech one, cause while what she said was hurtful, it wasn't particularly hateful. But this is hardly religious/racial discrimination although she'd like it to be. It has nothing to do with her blackness and everything to do with her being misinformed. And that has everything to do with her taking her scientific information from a book that at its oldest predates the guy she sees as the central figure: Jesus. It also has everything to do with her not looking at the world around her.

    The question is: can she believe as she does and still make fair decisions? I'm doubtful. People generally don't leave their biases at the office door. And people with prejudices are apt to have more than one prejudice. (Ever notice how the Klan seems to hate everybody?)

    It is an interesting point about black civil rights being intertwined with gay ones (imagine the world gay black men live in.) And she's right that some gay people choose to live straight lives. Some gay men live amoral, unsafe lives and cry discrimination. But she overlooks some things. Like the fact that many mixed people lived under the radar, passing as white. What of that? Is it that its more obvious when a person is black than when a person is gay? Well, then she dismisses the diversity within the gay community. Is it easier to pass as straight when your gay than it is to pass as white when you're black? I would say probably not. Just as those passing biracial people lived with their blackness on the inside, so do the ex-gay men live with their sexuality. ALSO: ex-gay programs and the participants fail everyday.

    She also gets a demerit for downplaying the role sexuality plays in life. But, this is in following with her fundamentalist beliefs. Of course you'll think that you can escape homosexuality if you believe that sex barely matters in life and that it should be reserved for procreation. Then, its easy to see how one could fail to see that discrimination for one is discrimination for all.

    Posted by: Pragmatist | May 12, 2008 7:35:21 PM

  18. She is an administrator for a governmental agency. The university probably has a very distinct policy regarding discrimination of any kind that she is responsible for upholding and mirroring. As an administrator, she doesn't have an "off" time. She is 24/7 in that capacity. I would imagine that she was not fired for first amendment but for not following clauses in her contract. What is the MOST sad is that she is a "Vice-President for Human Resources." Not very human, if you really think about it.

    Posted by: mike/ | May 12, 2008 7:38:42 PM

  19. Finally, we hear the old cunt speak and it ain't pretty!

    She may be black tomorrow morning, but hopefully one day not so biblically brainwashed and ignorant.


    Posted by: Marc | May 12, 2008 8:11:03 PM

  20. What seems to have been lost in all the brouhaha was that Dixon wrote her letter to the editor in response to a letter/editorial that criticized U of Toledo for the discrepencies in their policies of nondiscrimination (same-sex partners are not eligible for certain benefits). That was her mistake. Given her position at U of Toledo, her letter showed a distinct conflict of interest. It doesn't matter that she wrote the letter as a "private citizen". Under different circumstances, she probably would have kept her job.

    Posted by: AggieCowboy | May 12, 2008 8:21:02 PM

  21. AGGIECOWBOY is right...I missed the part of the story in which Dixon wrote her editorial in response to another editorial. I read both editorials and, yes, in her editorial Dixon does blur the lines between private citizen and employee of the University of Toledo. I now see exactly why the University of Toledo could legally get away with firing her. Now that I know more of the story, I support their decision to do so.

    Posted by: peterparker | May 12, 2008 8:44:33 PM

  22. i hope the ACLU defends her, she is entitled to her opinion and she did so outside of school.

    Posted by: queerunity | May 12, 2008 9:18:34 PM

  23. I always ask myself the question "If a white person said the same thing about an African-American, Latino or Asian, what would happen?" I have a feeling that if the head of HR of my company which has a stated nondiscrimination policy and is located in a city with a nondiscrimination law were to say that African-Americans were inferior and should not receive equal rights, that person would be fired.

    I remember in the 60's when the bible was used to justify racial discrimination and racial segregation. I doubt that an HR director who publicly stated that according to the bible, Latin Americans were inferior and did not deserve the same rights as white people would keep her job for long either.

    Posted by: hamp | May 12, 2008 9:27:21 PM

  24. The school has every right to fire her. She has espoused beliefs in public counter to the university's mission. The university positions itself with a mission statement to communicate and reach out to its customers (students). By her words and actions, she does not line up ideologically with them. She can speak freely, with no fear of arrest, but of course, she risks her employment if she publically goes against thier policy. ITs quite simple and the lawsuit is a distraction to gain publicity. Anti gay groups work in mysteriouis ways my friends.

    Posted by: Vi Agara | May 12, 2008 10:12:19 PM

  25. I don't agree with this crazy woman, but I think the university is going to have a hard time supporting its case for firing her, unless there is other information we're not privy to. They're going to have to show with demonstrable evidence that her personal opinions affected her professional conduct, and past performance evaluations will shed some light there. Just because she expressed some beliefs that the university might not agree with, doesn't mean she can't be professional and do her job. Plus, if she were a tenured faculty member and said the same thing, there would be no question that she'd still have her job.

    Beeyotch is crazy and stupid, but she'll probably walk away with a healthy settlement. Universities don't like litigation. Believe me, I know. I work at one.

    Posted by: Steven | May 12, 2008 10:46:10 PM

  26. « | 1 2 3 »

Post a comment


« «Towleroad Guide to the Tube #288« «