• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Body
  • Daily Resist
  • POLITICS
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Film
  • TV
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Men
  • Marriage Equality
  • Space
  • Trans Rights
  • Books
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • TowleREAD

District Judge Hears Gay Rights Case in Montana

January 26, 2011 by Andy Towle

The first court hearing for six of gay couples seeking "civil unions, domestic partnerships or another system that ensures they're not denied those rights" took place yesterday in Helena, Montana, the Billings Gazette reports:

Montana They say they have been denied those rights in violation of the state constitution's equal protection and privacy clauses. They asked Sherlock to grant an injunction and require the state to create the statutory framework to give them those protections.

"You don't get to deny those rights based on a policy that infringes on the Montana Constitution," said Bozeman attorney James Goetz, who spoke for the plaintiffs Tuesday.

The question appears to hinge in part on how the Montana Constitution's marriage amendment, which defines marriage as being between a man and a woman, is interpreted. State solicitor Anthony Johnstone argued that Montana can't extend spousal benefits to gay couples because those benefits are limited to married couples by definition.

"Montana law provides spousal benefits to spouses and only spouses," Johnstone said.

The marriage amendment, which Montana voters approved in 2004, coupled with the separation of legislative and judicial powers, means Sherlock should dismiss the lawsuit, Johnstone said. The state Legislature is free to create a new, separate class for couples regardless of sexual orientation, he said. But that's a policy choice for the state to make, not something that can be mandated by the court, he said.

Originally there were seven couples involved in the case, but one has dropped out for personal reasons, the paper reports.

Filed Under: News Tagged With: discrimination, gay marriage, gay rights, Montana, News

Recent Posts

  • Enrique Tarrio, Nick Robinson, Omar Sy, Kristen Stewart as Lady Di, Pence Couch-Surfing, Elliot Page, Hydroxychloroquine: HOT LINKS

    Enrique Tarrio, Nick Robinson, Omar Sy, Kristen Stewart as Lady Di, Pence Couch-Surfing, Elliot Page, Hydroxychloroquine: HOT LINKS

    4 hours ago
  • QAnon GOP Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Stalks and Taunts Parkland Shooting Survivor David Hogg in Disturbing Video: WATCH

    QAnon GOP Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Stalks and Taunts Parkland Shooting Survivor David Hogg in Disturbing Video: WATCH

    6 hours ago
  • FOX News’ Maria Bartiromo Cries to Josh Hawley Over Her Loss of More Than 100K Twitter Followers Since the Election: WATCH

    FOX News’ Maria Bartiromo Cries to Josh Hawley Over Her Loss of More Than 100K Twitter Followers Since the Election: WATCH

    9 hours ago
  • Lady Gaga Shares Video of Gay Nightclub in ‘COVID-Free’ Australia Partying to Chromatica: WATCH

    Lady Gaga Shares Video of Gay Nightclub in ‘COVID-Free’ Australia Partying to Chromatica: WATCH

    9 hours ago
Previous Post: « George Michael ‘Impostor’ Social Networking in Sydney
Next Post: Hawaii Governor Nominates Out Lesbian Judge to Supreme Court »

Primary Sidebar

  • Enrique Tarrio, Nick Robinson, Omar Sy, Kristen Stewart as Lady Di, Pence Couch-Surfing, Elliot Page, Hydroxychloroquine: HOT LINKS

  • QAnon GOP Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Stalks and Taunts Parkland Shooting Survivor David Hogg in Disturbing Video: WATCH

  • FOX News’ Maria Bartiromo Cries to Josh Hawley Over Her Loss of More Than 100K Twitter Followers Since the Election: WATCH

Recent Posts

  • Enrique Tarrio, Nick Robinson, Omar Sy, Kristen Stewart as Lady Di, Pence Couch-Surfing, Elliot Page, Hydroxychloroquine: HOT LINKS

    Enrique Tarrio, Nick Robinson, Omar Sy, Kristen Stewart as Lady Di, Pence Couch-Surfing, Elliot Page, Hydroxychloroquine: HOT LINKS

    4 hours ago
  • QAnon GOP Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Stalks and Taunts Parkland Shooting Survivor David Hogg in Disturbing Video: WATCH

    QAnon GOP Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Stalks and Taunts Parkland Shooting Survivor David Hogg in Disturbing Video: WATCH

    6 hours ago
  • FOX News’ Maria Bartiromo Cries to Josh Hawley Over Her Loss of More Than 100K Twitter Followers Since the Election: WATCH

    FOX News’ Maria Bartiromo Cries to Josh Hawley Over Her Loss of More Than 100K Twitter Followers Since the Election: WATCH

    9 hours ago
  • Lady Gaga Shares Video of Gay Nightclub in ‘COVID-Free’ Australia Partying to Chromatica: WATCH

    Lady Gaga Shares Video of Gay Nightclub in ‘COVID-Free’ Australia Partying to Chromatica: WATCH

    9 hours ago
  • NYPD Seeks Information on Suspect Who Punched Man, Said ‘I’m Gonna Kill You, You F—king Homo’

    NYPD Seeks Information on Suspect Who Punched Man, Said ‘I’m Gonna Kill You, You F—king Homo’

    10 hours ago
  • Giuliani’s Cuckoo Election Fraud Witness Melissa Carone is Running for Office

    Giuliani’s Cuckoo Election Fraud Witness Melissa Carone is Running for Office

    10 hours ago
  • Senate Panel Holds Confirmation Hearing for Transportation Secretary Nominee Pete Buttigieg: WATCH LIVE

    Senate Panel Holds Confirmation Hearing for Transportation Secretary Nominee Pete Buttigieg: WATCH LIVE

    10 hours ago
  • Sean Hannity Accuses Democrats of Inciting the Insurrection, Says He’s Considering Joining COVID Anti-Vaxxers: WATCH

    Sean Hannity Accuses Democrats of Inciting the Insurrection, Says He’s Considering Joining COVID Anti-Vaxxers: WATCH

    10 hours ago
  • Transphobic, Insurrection-Supporting Former MLB Pitcher Curt Schilling Wants Off Ballot After ‘Hall of Fame’ Rejection, Defends His Character in Facebook Post

    Transphobic, Insurrection-Supporting Former MLB Pitcher Curt Schilling Wants Off Ballot After ‘Hall of Fame’ Rejection, Defends His Character in Facebook Post

    11 hours ago
  • QAnon GOP Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Indicated Support for Executing Nancy Pelosi and Other Democrats in Social Media Posts

    QAnon GOP Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Indicated Support for Executing Nancy Pelosi and Other Democrats in Social Media Posts

    12 hours ago

Most Commented

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Footer

Copyright © 2021 · Log in