• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Body
  • Daily Resist
  • POLITICS
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Theatre
  • Film
  • TV
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Men
  • Marriage Equality
  • Space
  • Trans Rights
  • Books
  • Science
  • Gay Iconography
  • TowleREAD

Sexual History of Plaintiffs Challenging Pennsylvania’s Gay Marriage Ban Sought by Lawyers

December 19, 2013 by Andy Towle

The lawyers defending Pennsylvania's ban on same-sex marriage from a court challenge brought by the ACLU are seeking ridiculous and undue requests for information on the sexual histories and relationship background of the plaintiffs in the case, Think Progress reports:

Vic_walczakAmong the requests, said [Witold] Walczak (pictured), are whether any of the plaintiffs were ever in a relationship with a person of the opposite sex and names and contact information for every person with whom they resided over the last 10 years. The state is also seeking the identity of all health care providers from whom the plaintiffs sought treatment or counseling for harm they allegedly suffered as a result of allegations in the lawsuit, Walczak wrote. […]

Other information requests by the state’s lawyers are unduly burdensome, including correspondence, letters, notes, records, reports, diaries or any other writings that pertain to the subject or events on which the lawsuit is based, Walczak wrote.

Adds Think Progress:

It’s unclear how this kind of personal information about the plaintiffs would be pertinent in a case about whether it’s constitutional for Pennsylvania to not recognize the marriages of same-sex couples. Details such as when they came out, whether they identify as exclusively gay (as opposed to bi), or whether or not they’ve ever struggled because of the impact of homophobia do not impact the validity of their current families. It’s possible that the $400/hour lawyers are planning to argue that the court should not consider sexual orientation with heightened scrutiny, which would require demonstrating that sexual orientation is not “immutable.” If any of the plaintiffs did, in fact, have opposite-sex partners at a previous point in life, they could try to argue that this is evidence of “change.”

Filed Under: News, Pennsylvania Tagged With: aclu, ACLU, gay marriage, Gay Marriage, News, Pennsylvania

Recent Posts

  • ‘Drag Race’ Serves Rom-Coms, Drama and Murder on the Runway [RECAP and RANKINGS]

    ‘Drag Race’ Serves Rom-Coms, Drama and Murder on the Runway [RECAP and RANKINGS]

    4 hours ago
  • Lesbian Mom Who Made Bernie Sanders’ Viral Mittens Overwhelmed with Requests

    Lesbian Mom Who Made Bernie Sanders’ Viral Mittens Overwhelmed with Requests

    6 hours ago
  • Teen YouTuber JoJo Siwa and ‘Dance Moms’ Star Comes Out as Gay

    Teen YouTuber JoJo Siwa and ‘Dance Moms’ Star Comes Out as Gay

    7 hours ago
  • Dr. Anthony Fauci Describes ‘Chilling’ Resistance to Science in Trump Administration, Tells Rachel Maddow They Blocked Him from Her Show: ‘It Was a Tough Situation. It Really Was’ — WATCH

    Dr. Anthony Fauci Describes ‘Chilling’ Resistance to Science in Trump Administration, Tells Rachel Maddow They Blocked Him from Her Show: ‘It Was a Tough Situation. It Really Was’ — WATCH

    7 hours ago
Previous Post: « Italian Democrats to Introduce Civil Partnership Bill
Next Post: Figure Skater Brian Boitano Comes Out as Gay After Appointment to Sochi Delegation »

Primary Sidebar

  • ‘Drag Race’ Serves Rom-Coms, Drama and Murder on the Runway [RECAP and RANKINGS]

  • Lesbian Mom Who Made Bernie Sanders’ Viral Mittens Overwhelmed with Requests

  • Teen YouTuber JoJo Siwa and ‘Dance Moms’ Star Comes Out as Gay

Recent Posts

  • ‘Drag Race’ Serves Rom-Coms, Drama and Murder on the Runway [RECAP and RANKINGS]

    ‘Drag Race’ Serves Rom-Coms, Drama and Murder on the Runway [RECAP and RANKINGS]

    4 hours ago
  • Lesbian Mom Who Made Bernie Sanders’ Viral Mittens Overwhelmed with Requests

    Lesbian Mom Who Made Bernie Sanders’ Viral Mittens Overwhelmed with Requests

    6 hours ago
  • Teen YouTuber JoJo Siwa and ‘Dance Moms’ Star Comes Out as Gay

    Teen YouTuber JoJo Siwa and ‘Dance Moms’ Star Comes Out as Gay

    7 hours ago
  • Dr. Anthony Fauci Describes ‘Chilling’ Resistance to Science in Trump Administration, Tells Rachel Maddow They Blocked Him from Her Show: ‘It Was a Tough Situation. It Really Was’ — WATCH

    Dr. Anthony Fauci Describes ‘Chilling’ Resistance to Science in Trump Administration, Tells Rachel Maddow They Blocked Him from Her Show: ‘It Was a Tough Situation. It Really Was’ — WATCH

    7 hours ago
  • Talk Show Legend Larry King Dead of Complications from COVID-19 at 87

    Talk Show Legend Larry King Dead of Complications from COVID-19 at 87

    8 hours ago
  • Billie Eilish, Diet Coke Button, Fleet Foxes, Jane Krakowski, Faultline Bar, Dave Chappelle, Miley Cyrus: HOT LINKS

    Billie Eilish, Diet Coke Button, Fleet Foxes, Jane Krakowski, Faultline Bar, Dave Chappelle, Miley Cyrus: HOT LINKS

    1 day ago
  • Visit Key West Like a Queen: Drag Icons Give Their Tourist Tips

    Visit Key West Like a Queen: Drag Icons Give Their Tourist Tips

    1 day ago
  • Chuck Schumer Grimaces After Saying Donald Trump ‘Incited the Erection’ — WATCH

    Chuck Schumer Grimaces After Saying Donald Trump ‘Incited the Erection’ — WATCH

    1 day ago
  • GOP Rep. Madison Cawthorn Lied About Training for Paralympics

    GOP Rep. Madison Cawthorn Lied About Training for Paralympics

    1 day ago
  • Senate to Get Article of Impeachment from House on Monday

    Senate to Get Article of Impeachment from House on Monday

    1 day ago

Most Commented

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Footer

Copyright © 2021 · Log in