• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer
  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!
  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

Roberts, Alito, Thomas, Scalia: The SCOTUS Dissenters on Marriage Equality Chose Bigotry Over Respect

Ari Ezra Waldman June 29, 2015

 |— Promoted by Human Rights Campaign —|SCOTUS equality dissenters

The SCOTUS dissenters lost the case. But rather than being respectful and offering sound legal arguments for their views, the Justices chose to show their distaste for LGBT equality. Even the Chief Justice, whose writing skills and professional demeanor helped him draft an argument that sounded reasonable on the surface, wrote a dissent that even conservatives found “heartless.” Specifically because his opinion is couched in some professional and reasonable language, it is the most insidious. I will discuss his dissent separately in my next column.

Antonin ScaliaHis colleagues did not disappoint. No one expected Justice Scalia to vote in favor of equality. Nor did anyone expect him to be nice about it. He called my right to marry the man I love a “threat to democracy,” resurrecting the judicial abdication of the Sixth Circuit. He called Justice Kennedy's opinion “pretentious” and “egotistic,” vomiting back talking points from conservatives who think liberals talk down to them. And he considered the entire case “of no special importance,” as if spitting on the men, women, and children so earnestly fighting for their equality.

His disrespectful tone is matched only by his lack of imagination. He sarcastically criticizes the supposedly high-handed majority for “see[ing] what lesser legal minds—minds like Thomas Cooley, John Marshall Harlan, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., Learned Hand, Louis Brandeis, William Howard Taft, Benjamin Cardozo, Hugo Black, Felix Frankfurter, Robert Jackson, and Henry Friendly—could not.” True, none of these great jurists declared that the Constitution protects a gay person's right to marry the person that he or she loves. But they never had the occasion to do so.

_HRCContrary to Scalia's implication, many of these jurists would have been at the forefront of social justice, as they were for their times. Louis Brandeis was one of the Court's greatest progressive champions before William Brennan. Hugo Black, a southerner, was a Constitutional absolutist: if the Fourteenth Amendment said all people are equal, then all people are equal. Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. was ahead of his time on issues of privacy, federal power, and individual rights. Justice John Marshall Harlan was the lone dissenter in Plessy v. Ferguson, and his grandson, John Marshall Harlan II, though a member of the Warren Court's conservatives, vigorously supported desegregation and an expansive interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment. Given Harlan's Fourteenth Amendment jurisprudence, it would probably have been easy for him to side with Justice Kennedy.

Samuel AlitoFor his part, Justice Alito wasn't worried about young gay, lesbian, and transgender kids (and their parents), many of whom have been and will continue to be a tiny maligned minority in a threatening world. No, he's concerned about the traditional majority. By supporting equality, the majority, Alito has the audacity to say, “facilitates the marginalization” of Christians. Marginalized from what? From the privileges into which they are born? Are Christians in any way victimized by a decision that has absolutely zero to do with them? At a minimum, Alito's concern is misplaced. At worst, he is doing what he and Scalia do best: fear monger and predict gloom and doom. Such overreaction is more appropriate for a teenager, not a Supreme Court justice.

Clarence ThomasBut Justice Thomas wins the award for the most forehead-slapping, shocking line in a dissent full of disgusting comments. As we've discussed, Justice Kennedy's majority opinion rested on the “equal dignity” of all persons, which requires equal access to the “fundamental” institution of marriage. Justice Thomas couldn't understand the concept of dignity, leading him to craft this undignified statement:

Slaves did not lose their dignity (any more than they lost their humanity) because the government allowed them to be enslaved. Those held in internment camps did not lose their dignity because the government confined them. And those denied governmental benefits certainly do not lose their dignity because the government denies them those benefits. The government cannot bestow dignity, and it cannot take it away.

This tortured logic, which appears to absolve those who permitted and enshrined slavery while simultaneously reducing our quest for marriage equality to “governmental benefits”, seems to suggest that even slaves, the unjustly imprisoned, and the marginalized can carry themselves with dignity. Dignity, he holds, comes from within. Sure, I suppose, to an extent. But that dignity is damaged by institutionalized racism, hatred, and discrimination. And besides, the issue before the Court was whether the Constitution, which protects the equal dignity of all persons, allows states to damage that sense of humanity. The Court got it wrong in Dred Scott and Plessy, both of which would have been appropriate homes for Justice Thomas's line above, and Justice Thomas (and fellow conservatives) got it wrong in Obergefell.

Follow Ari Ezra Waldman on Twitter!

________________________________________________________________________________

This post is promoted by the Human Rights Campaign. HRC envisions a world where lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people are embraced as full members of society at home, at work and in every community.

Topics: Society, Supreme Court, towleroad, World More Posts About: Antonin Scalia, Ari Ezra Waldman, Clarence Thomas, gay marriage, John Roberts, Law - Gay, LGBT, marriage equality, News, Samuel Alito

Related Posts
  • Mayor of Athens Officiates First Same-sex Married; Respected Novelist and Partner Are First Under Recent Legislation. Congrats! WATCH
  • Beyond the Verdict: Unpacking the Fallout of the Supreme Court’s 303 Creative v. Elenis Decision
  • US Supreme Court bans the use of race in university admissions
  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Mel B will “always be open” when it comes to her sexuality. The Spice Girls singer, 48, who reunited with her bandmates including the group's ex-singer Victoria Beckham for the fashion …Read More »
  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Megan Thee Stallion is being sued for allegedly creating a hostile work environment and forcing her cameraman to watch her having lesbian sex. The 29-year-old ‘Savage' rapper faces the salacious claims …Read More »
  • Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Jonathan Bennett's life was “changed forever” by his role in ‘Mean Girls'. The 42-year-old actor starred as heartthrob Aaron Samuels in the 2004 cult classic – which followed Lindsay Lohan, Rachel …Read More »
  • Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass a gift basket after he came out as gay. The 44-year-old NSYNC star revealed the legendary singer showed his support when Lance decided to reveal …Read More »
Previous Post: « John Oliver Schools America On Transgender Rights: VIDEO
Next Post: Police Officer Dirty Dances During the NYC Gay Pride Parade: VIDEO »

Primary Sidebar

Most Recent

  • Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer

    Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer

  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

  • Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

  • Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

  • Relationship status influences heterosexual women’s sexual prejudice towards lesbians

    Relationship status influences heterosexual women’s sexual prejudice towards lesbians

  • JoJo Siwa had a challenge transitioning to new grown-up image

    JoJo Siwa had a challenge transitioning to new grown-up image

  • Liz Hurley defends lesbian sex scene in new movie that was directed by her son

    Liz Hurley defends lesbian sex scene in new movie that was directed by her son

Partner Links

  • People: Princess Charlotte ‘is quite a strong character, almost wise beyond her years’
    I’ve been saying this for years and I’ll probably still be […]
  • “Prime Minister Mark Carney said that Canada will never be for sale” links
    Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney told Donald Trump that Canada will […]
  • Fed Chair Powell: Trump Tariffs Lead To Higher Inflation, Higher Unemployment
    Fed Chair Jerome Powell issued dire warnings on lowering interest rates, […]
  • Huh. How Did Traders Buy $MELANIA Coin Before It Went Public?
    A small group of crypto traders made nearly $100 million by […]
  • Despite living a long distance apart, comedy star Fortune Feimster making time for her parents
    View this post on Instagram A post shared by Fortune Feimster […]

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

About

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Ptown Hacks 2018

Read

  • Travel
  • Film
  • Law – LGBT Rights
  • Columns
  • Specials

About

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 · Log in

×
×