• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox

Meryl Streep Sings Perfectly Horribly in ‘Florence Foster Jenkins’ – Weekend Movie Review

Nathaniel Rogers August 12, 2016 Leave a Comment

Meryl Streep Florence Foster Jenkins review
Meryl streep about to break a leg / pierce ear drums on stage in “florence foster jenkins”

It takes a gifted singer to sing this horribly. Every other note is wrong. No phrasing goes unmangled by shortness of breath. No lovely moment meant to soar cannot be shattered by a flat ear-piercing decibel.

The central conceit of Stephen Frears new comedy Florence Foster Jenkins is that Florence, a considerably wealthy patron of the arts played by Meryl Streep, lives for music but is ghastly at it. The inside joke, given the casting, is that we all know La Streep can sing with the best of them.

She followed the “is there nothing she can’t do?” revelation of Ironweed‘s tragic showstopper “He’s Me Pal” (1987, Oscar-Nominated) with transcendent country crooner feeling in Postcards From the Edge (1990, Oscar-Nominated), and just kept on singing whenever a movie gave her the opportunity all the way up through last year’s Ricki and the Flash which was practically a concert film there were so many scenes of Streep at the mic, rocking out.

Florence Foster Jenkins doesn’t rock out. Florence is not that kind of girl and Florence, also, is not that kind of movie.

florencesings

florence-readingThe old woman is content to host parties (potato salad is a must!) and go to bed early with a chaste tucking in from her charming husband St Claire Bayfield (Hugh Grant, the best he’s been in ages) who is the rock star behind the scenes. He does all the heavy showmanship lifting to keep Florence dreamy and happy, rather than sad and sickly; for St. Claire and even for Florence, the movie argues, her ignorance is their bliss.

If only our ignorance was also bliss. The movie is right there with St Claire in assuming that everyone will be happier with fantasy than reality. But can’t we have equal portions of both? Florence Foster Jenkins is based on a true story but it’s tough to say which parts are fiction unless your expertise is eccentric American socialites of WWII era Manhattan. Much of the movie plays like it couldn’t possible be true but here we are.

The movie’s ignorance-is-bliss mantra extends even to the main storyline.

Florence’s dream is to perform at Carnegie Hall and we’re given little information as to how she moves from a high society figure to a divisive populist sensation that can sell that venue out. Frankly, the occasional peaks at harder truths like the couple’s sexless open marriage and Florence’s subtle manipulations (especially with her money) are so compelling that it’s easy to wish the film wasn’t quite so docile and satisfied within the comfort of the broadly comic.

florence-anothertake

Not that there’s anything wrong with fanciful comedy. You know that Streep and Grant excel at it, and they’re well supported by a lively turn from stage goddess Nina Arianda (Venus in Fur Tony winner) as the tactless new wife of one of their richest friends.

She can’t believe her ears when she first hears Florence sing. Simon Helberg (The Big Bang Theory) is less successful as Florence’s chosen accompanist who is essentially the third lead. He’s gifted with so many closeups that you need more from the performance than awkward nervousness. That’s particularly problematic when the movie throws in a very gay party but his own sexuality remains opaque or perhaps non-existent.

All told this is a rather old fashioned trifle of a star vehicle and what depth it does have comes from what can be inferred in performance rather than what the movie delivers.

That’s as we’ve come to expect from the director Stephen Frears. Though his breakthrough came with the rather daring and sociopolitically savvy My Beautiful Laundrette (1985), he’s mostly abandoned the former bite of his early work.

Florence is another in his recent line of more comforting star vehicles for Great Actresses surrounded in fussy manners or plum period finery (or both): Judi Dench in Mrs Henderson Presents and Philomena, Michelle Pfeiffer in Chéri and Helen Mirren in The Queen. The new film is a handsome production, too, and one that could easily be mistaken for a glossy “For Your Consideration…” ad in Variety.

florence-floating

Perhaps it doesn’t add up to much but it’s lovely to look at and touching. That the one joke conceit doesn’t wear out its welcome is often thanks to Streep’s pitch-perfect off-pitch singing. She somehow makes that funny every single time but we shouldn’t be surprised that when the role calls for “blue” Meryl will bring “cerulean.”

And it’s not just Meryl. The movie as a whole balances well on a very thin wire between its potentially mean-spirited premise and real affection for delusional dreamers. Nicholas Martin’s screenplay and Stephen Frears direction actually go so far as to lionize delusions as life-saving coping mechanisms. Which… well, I’m not a psychotherapist so no judgments, but I am a movie fan and Florence Foster Jenkins is a good time.

Topics: Film/TV/Stream, Music, Society More Posts About: Film, Hugh Grant, Meryl Streep, Nathaniel Rogers, Nina Arianda, Simon Helberg

Related Posts
  • LGBTQ Pro Wrestling Documentary ‘Out In The Ring’ Wins Best Canadian Feature at Inside Out Toronto Film Festival
  • Viola Davis was called by director’s maid’s name
  • The Week in Pictures: May 13 – May 20
  • Disney CEO Bob Chapek’s Contract Extension Awakens Twitter

    Disney CEO Bob Chapek’s Contract Extension Awakens Twitter

    Published by The Street By Veronika Bondarenko “The board has full confidence in him and his leadership team,” Disney’s board announced on Wednesday. When it comes to leadership of a company as big as Disney (DIS) …Read More »
  • Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas Under Fire: Petition To Have Him Resign Or Be IMPEACHED Surpasses 450K Signatures

    Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas Under Fire: Petition To Have Him Resign Or Be IMPEACHED Surpasses 450K Signatures

    Published by Radar Online MEGA An online petition demanding that Justice Clarence Thomas must resign from the Supreme Court immediately or else be impeached is quickly gaining traction, Radar has learned. More than 450,000 signatures have …Read More »
  • Unilever sells Ben & Jerry’s Israeli business to defuse BDS row

    Unilever sells Ben & Jerry’s Israeli business to defuse BDS row

    Published by Reuters UK By Henriette Chacar JERUSALEM (Reuters) -Unilever on Wednesday sold its Ben & Jerry’s ice cream business in Israel to its local licensee for an undisclosed sum, aiming to smooth over a potentially …Read More »
  • London Pride to feature Snapchat-powered AR art exhibition

    London Pride to feature Snapchat-powered AR art exhibition

    Published by BANG Showbiz English London Pride will feature a Snapchat-powered AR art exhibition to celebrate queer artists. The annual event – which is set to take place in the capital on Saturday 2 July – …Read More »
Previous Post: « Boxers or Briefs? Shirtless Cat Lovers Drop Their Shorts and Spill – WATCH
Next Post: Petition Hopes to Revoke IOC Press Credentials from Nico Hines and The Daily Beast »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Horseshoe crabs: ‘Living fossils’ vital for vaccine safety

    Horseshoe crabs: ‘Living fossils’ vital for vaccine safety

  • ‘A Disgusting Sight In Any Case’: Vladimir Putin Fires Back After G7 Leaders Joke About His Infamous Horse-Riding Picture

    ‘A Disgusting Sight In Any Case’: Vladimir Putin Fires Back After G7 Leaders Joke About His Infamous Horse-Riding Picture

  • Russia abandons Snake Island in victory for Ukraine

    Russia abandons Snake Island in victory for Ukraine

RSS Partner Links

  • Kim Kardashian Has Officially Been Sued Over Her Skincare Line, SKKN
  • OMG, Marvel Studios is really teasing us with more shirtless Thor side-ass and pelvis-peeking fuckery
  • Halsey Responded To Fans Who Walked Out Of Their Concert In Reaction To Pro-Choice Speech
  • OMG, coming up for air: Professional British swimmer Dan Jervis comes out
  • Greg In Hollywood among those honored by City of West Hollywood with Rainbow Key Award
  • Today’s Insta Hunk: Jason Moattar!
  • Thursday Round-Up: Tom Ford; Kristen Stewart; Cara Delevingne & Selena Gomez; Randy Rainbow & more!

Most Recent

  • Marvel to introduce first gay Spider-Man in upcoming ‘Edge of Spider-Verse’

    Marvel to introduce first gay Spider-Man in upcoming ‘Edge of Spider-Verse’

  • Disney CEO Bob Chapek’s Contract Extension Awakens Twitter

    Disney CEO Bob Chapek’s Contract Extension Awakens Twitter

  • Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas Under Fire: Petition To Have Him Resign Or Be IMPEACHED Surpasses 450K Signatures

    Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas Under Fire: Petition To Have Him Resign Or Be IMPEACHED Surpasses 450K Signatures

  • Unilever sells Ben & Jerry’s Israeli business to defuse BDS row

    Unilever sells Ben & Jerry’s Israeli business to defuse BDS row

  • London Pride to feature Snapchat-powered AR art exhibition

    London Pride to feature Snapchat-powered AR art exhibition

  • Top 10 Trixie Mattel Songs

    Top 10 Trixie Mattel Songs

  • Kit Conner says attending his first fashion show was ‘surreal’

    Kit Conner says attending his first fashion show was ‘surreal’

  • Dad Storms Out of Sister’s Wedding After She Deadnames His Transgender Son

    Dad Storms Out of Sister’s Wedding After She Deadnames His Transgender Son

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in