• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Tina Turner was ‘prepared’ for Sir Mick Jagger ripping her skirt off at Live Aid
  • Texas attorney general lashes out at impeachment against him
  • Jane Fonda Claims Robert Redford ‘Didn’t Like Kissing’ Her in Movies: ‘He Just Has an Issue With Women’

Supreme Court LGBTQ: This Season’s Final Report: Minor Victories, Could-Have-Been-Worse Losses, Trepidation About Future

Lisa Keen, Keen News Service July 16, 2021 Leave a Comment

supreme court lgbtq
Supreme court lgbtq wins and losses can be tallied with end of the session last week.

Trends

The U.S. Supreme Court session that just ended amounted to mostly a “tread water” experience for LGBT people—with several little victories and no spectacular losses. But there are sharks in these legal waters, nipping at equal protection for LGBT people in the name of religion, and prospects for the future are unsettling.

The days of the blockbuster wins for LGBT people seem over, at least for the foreseeable future. No more triumphs, like the 2015 decision to strike state bans on marriage for same-sex couples (Obergefell v. Hodges) or the 2013 decision to strike a federal law (DOMA) which banned recognition of such marriages (U.S. v. Windsor). No surprise epic, like last year’s ruling that “sex discrimination” prohibited by the federal civil rights law includes discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity (Bostock v. Clayton).

ACB is no RBG, Champion of Supreme Court LGBTQ Wins

In the 2020 session, which adjourned July 2, the composition of the court curdled to the right and, more specifically, to the religious right. The court’s most pro-LGBT justice, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, died and was replaced by Amy Coney Barrett just as the session got underway. This alone brought a sense of dread and gloom for LGBT prospects going forward. Ginsburg had voted pro-LGBT 90 percent of the time; many expected Barrett to vote just as frequently against LGBT people.

“You cannot write anyone off on the court at this point,”

David Cole, ACLU Legal Director


Barrett had only two LGBT-related opinions to weigh in on this session. In one, Americans for Prosperity v. California, she voted with other conservatives to hold that California’s law requiring that the identities of major donors to tax-exempt organizations be reported to the state violates the First Amendment right of association for donors.

In the other, Fulton v. Philadelphia, she voted with a unanimous bench to hold that Philadelphia’s interest in eradicating discrimination against LGBT people “cannot justify denying [Catholic Social Services] an exception for its religious exercise” in excluding gay couples from foster care. She, Chief Justice John Roberts, and Justice Brett Kavanaugh voted the same way on both cases.

Bridge, Golf, 4-Square, And Supreme Court Appeals…

And Barrett, Roberts, and Kavanaugh apparently withheld their consent to grant review of several lower court decisions that LGBT people had won below. It takes four justices to agree to hear an appeal before the court will accept it for review. Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas wanted to hear four different appeals where LGBT people won in the lower courts. In one of those four appeals, the Alito-Thomas duo had a third vote from Justice Neil Gorsuch. But they didn’t get the critical fourth, and that left the pro-LGBT rulings below intact.

Appeals Refused: Lower Court LGBTQ Wins That Stuck

The appeals that were snubbed included:

• Arlene’s Flowers v. Washington—in which the Washington Supreme Court ruled that a state non-discrimination law does not violate the First Amendment free exercise rights of a florist who claimed her religion required her to deny service to same-sex couples seeking flowers for their weddings. In this case, Justice Gorsuch joined Alito and Thomas, wanting to hear the appeal.

• Gloucester v. Grimm—in which the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled that, following the Supreme Court precedent in Bostock, a Virginia school district did violate Title IX of the federal Education Amendments Act when it refused to allow a transgender male student to use the boys’ restroom and locker room.

Kim Davis county clerk refusing a marriage licence to David Ermold and David Moore
Supreme Court LGBTQ: Many-times divorced Kim Davis denies marriage license and kept trying

• Texas v. California—in which the state of Texas sought to file a “bill of complaint” directly with the U.S. Supreme Court, challenging a California law that prohibited state-funded travel to certain states, including Texas, which had policies hostile to LGBT people.

• Kim Davis v. Ermond—in which the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled that a county clerk in Kentucky could not refuse to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples after the Obergefell decision. Once again, Justices Thomas and Alito dissented. (Note: Barrett was not yet on the court when this case was rejected for review.)

Clear Conservative Shift

Gary Buseck, senior adviser to GLBTQ Advocates & Defenders (GLAD), said he was heartened by Barrett’s concurrence in Fulton. Barrett wrote a brief concurring opinion, explaining why she did not go along with the request to overturn a Supreme Court precedent called Employment Division v. Smith. Justices Alito, Thomas, and Gorsuch urged the court to do so, saying Smith burdens the free exercise of religion.

In Smith, the Supreme Court ruled that a state could deny unemployment benefits to a person fired for using illegal drugs as part of a religious ceremony. The 1990 decision said a state law denying benefits to employees fired for “misconduct” (illegal drug use) was generally applicable to all persons.

supreme court lgbtq
Supreme Court LGBTQ future is not the brightest with the arrival of Amy Coney Barrett

Barrett said she was “skeptical” about the idea of “swapping Smith’s categorical anti-discrimination approach for an equally categorical strict scrutiny regime….” She said the Supreme Court “has been much more nuanced” in its approach and there was no reason in the Fulton conflict to overturn Smith.

Justices Kavanaugh and Stephen Breyer signed onto Barrett’s concurrence.

“You cannot write anyone off on the court at this point,” said ACLU legal director David Cole, in a post-session discussion.

Cole noted that the Supreme Court has had a majority of Republican-appointed justices since 1972 and yet has made “substantial progress” on issues such as marriage equality. The key, he said, is that the Supreme Court “doesn’t depart very far from where country is” and, “because the country had moved to a point where there was just not a good reason to deny marriage equality in 2015,” the court ruled for marriage equality in 2015.

Look Out. Outlook for Next Season

University of California-Berkeley School of Law Professor Erwin Chemerinsky, speaking at a Supreme Court analysis session by the National Constitution Center on July 8, said he sees a Supreme Court “in transition,” since Barrett replaced Ginsburg. He said it is clear there won’t be any 5 to 4 decisions with liberals in the majority, and the conservative majority now means most cases will be more conservative appeals.

New York University School of Law Professor Melissa Murray, speaking at the same session, predicted a continued “move toward religion as having ‘most favored nation’ status” at the Supreme Court.

Two cases are already in the queue for next session: One asks whether a Catholic-run hospital can deny a hysterectomy to a female-to-male transgender patient. Another asks whether Boston, which allows LGBT Pride flags to fly on city property during pride month, can deny a Christian group to fly its flag on the same property.

© 2021 Keen News Service. All rights reserved.
Kim Davis pooto by By davidvmoore1976 –

Supreme Court LGBTQ previously on Towleroad

Topics: Education, Featured, Law/Justice, Supreme Court More Posts About: 2020, Amy Coney Barrett, Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Related Posts
  • RBG’s death set off a pattern of ‘distrust and discord’ that still plagues the Supreme Court today
  • A transformed US Supreme Court pays tribute to Justice Ginsburg
  • Supreme Court ponders the fate of pigs, high cost of bacon
  • Texas attorney general lashes out at impeachment against him

    Texas attorney general lashes out at impeachment against him

    Published by Reuters By Brad Brooks and Daniel Trotta LUBBOCK, Texas (Reuters) – Republican Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton lashed out on Friday against his critics trying to impeach him, saying that removing him from office …Read More »
  • Jane Fonda Claims Robert Redford ‘Didn’t Like Kissing’ Her in Movies: ‘He Just Has an Issue With Women’

    Jane Fonda Claims Robert Redford ‘Didn’t Like Kissing’ Her in Movies: ‘He Just Has an Issue With Women’

    Published by OK Magazine mega Despite playing Robert Redford‘s love interest in a handful of movies, Jane Fonda believes the actor despised filming physical scenes with her. The Grace & Frankie alum made the confession while …Read More »
  • Caitlyn Jenner heartbroken over mother’s death

    Caitlyn Jenner heartbroken over mother’s death

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Caitlyn Jenner has paid tribute to her late mother after her memorial service. The 73-year-old reality TV star her heartbreak at the loss at her mom Esther Jenner (née McGuire), who …Read More »
  • Beyonce pays Tina Turner tribute at Paris concert

    Beyonce pays Tina Turner tribute at Paris concert

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Beyonce paid another tribute to Tina Turner during her concert in Paris. The 41-year-old star hailed the late music legend at her show at the Stade de France on Friday (26.05.23) …Read More »
Previous Post: « 11 Must-See Miami Spots for Gay Travelers with Children
Next Post: ‘RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars’ Season 6 Spills Tea All Over the Pink Table »

Primary Sidebar

Adjacent News

  • Scientists use deep learning algorithms to predict political ideology based on facial characteristics

    Scientists use deep learning algorithms to predict political ideology based on facial characteristics

  • Kristi Noem pushes for South Dakota college board to prohibit drag shows, pronoun preferences on campuses

    Kristi Noem pushes for South Dakota college board to prohibit drag shows, pronoun preferences on campuses

  • Los Angeles Dodgers Announce ‘Christian Faith and Family Day’

    Los Angeles Dodgers Announce ‘Christian Faith and Family Day’

Good Trash: Going to Read It Somewhere, Y'know

  • Tina Turner’s Deathbed Confession to Cher Revealed

    Tina Turner’s Deathbed Confession to Cher Revealed

  • Disco the Weekend: Dua Lipa’s “Dance the Night” Drops for ‘Barbie’: FutureRetro Disco Video is A Delight : WATCH NOW

    Disco the Weekend: Dua Lipa’s “Dance the Night” Drops for ‘Barbie’: FutureRetro Disco Video is A Delight : WATCH NOW

  • Diana Ross, Dolly Parton and more remember Tina Turner

    Diana Ross, Dolly Parton and more remember Tina Turner

Partner Links

  • “Route 66″ star and early Playgirl centerfold George Maharis has died; he never came out professionally
  • Sunday Comics
  • Mystery Butt + Texas AG Ken Paxton Impeached + Céline Dion's Last Tour Official Canceled + MORE! — 6-PACK
  • Late Night Music Club With Tina Turner
  • On his 33rd birthday, let’s enjoy the singing of “Glee” alum and best-selling author Chris Colfer!

Most Recent

  • Tina Turner was ‘prepared’ for Sir Mick Jagger ripping her skirt off at Live Aid

    Tina Turner was ‘prepared’ for Sir Mick Jagger ripping her skirt off at Live Aid

  • Texas attorney general lashes out at impeachment against him

    Texas attorney general lashes out at impeachment against him

  • Jane Fonda Claims Robert Redford ‘Didn’t Like Kissing’ Her in Movies: ‘He Just Has an Issue With Women’

    Jane Fonda Claims Robert Redford ‘Didn’t Like Kissing’ Her in Movies: ‘He Just Has an Issue With Women’

  • Caitlyn Jenner heartbroken over mother’s death

    Caitlyn Jenner heartbroken over mother’s death

  • Beyonce pays Tina Turner tribute at Paris concert

    Beyonce pays Tina Turner tribute at Paris concert

  • Two more Oath Keepers sentenced to prison over US Capitol attack

    Two more Oath Keepers sentenced to prison over US Capitol attack

  • Lauren Jauregui’s ‘instant chemistry’ with Sasha Mallory

    Lauren Jauregui’s ‘instant chemistry’ with Sasha Mallory

  • In Azerbaijan, violence against LGBTQ+ people continues unabated

    In Azerbaijan, violence against LGBTQ+ people continues unabated

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Copyright © 2023 · Log in

×