Federal Appeals Court Upholds California Ban on Gay Conversion Therapy for Minors

A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld SB1172, California's law banning gay reparative therapy for minors.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco ruled Thursday that the state's ban on so-called conversion therapy for minors doesn't violate the free speech rights of licensed counselors and patients seeking treatment. The ban's supporters maintain that the methods therapists use to try to change youngsters' sexual orientations are unethical and ineffective.


The AP reported back on April:

The cases before the appeals court — brought by professionals who practice sexual orientation change therapy, two families who say their teenage sons benefited from it and a national association of Christian mental health counselors — argue that the ban infringes on their free speech, freedom of association and religious rights, and in the case of the counselors, jeopardizes their livelihoods.

"The state has determined that the only permissible message (is that) same-sex attractions, behavior or identity are to be accepted, supported and understood, thus suppressing all other viewpoints to the detriment of licensed professionals and their vulnerable minor clients," lawyers for the families, several practitioners and the professional group said.

"The viewpoint of counselors who in their professional judgment determine that same-sex attractions conflict with the religious and moral beliefs of clients and are not desired, is silenced by SB 1172. This raises a serious constitutional question."

Chief Judge Alex Kozinski (pictured), who was appointed by Ronald Reagan in 1985, Judge Susan Graber, a 1998 appointee of Bill Clinton's, and Judge Morgan Christen, a 2012 appointee of President Barack Obama, are set to hear the case. U.S.

District Court Judge William Shubb blocked the law banning the harmful therapy in December. It was scheduled to go into effect January 1 but was put on hold by the 9th Circuit.

Read today's ruling, AFTER THE JUMP...

9th Circuit opinion on CA 'ex-gay' ban

Feed This post's comment feed


  1. The ruling is here:


    Posted by: Matt N | Aug 29, 2013 1:58:33 PM

  2. "...and in the case of the counselors, jeopardizes their livelihoods."

    Best excuse ever for allowing immoral behavior to continue: "We can't stop the death penalty...think of the executioners job!"

    Posted by: Jay Dwyer | Aug 29, 2013 3:25:08 PM

  3. This may end up at the Supreme Court. Similar argument have been made in favor of prostitution, but the courts have ruled that "tradition" dictates that prostitution can be curbed. "Tradition" is a sideline to "compelling state interest" that can abridge free speech.

    Posted by: anon | Aug 29, 2013 3:37:54 PM

  4. Judge Graber wrote the opinion. You should really include a picture of her, not Judge Kozinski, who only joined the opinion.

    Posted by: Todd | Aug 30, 2013 1:39:57 AM

  5. You religious nutballs and your false religions lost again. Keep your crap in your bigoted churches where it belongs.

    And when the hell is the IRS going to investigate these false churches and tax them?

    Posted by: Mmike1969 | Aug 30, 2013 8:41:44 AM

Post a comment


« «With the Kremlin Cup in Moscow in October, Will the WTA Take a Stand Against Russia's Anti-Gay Laws?« «