‘The Glass Menagerie’ Starring Zachary Quinto and Cherry Jones Opens On Broadway: REVIEW

GM 1 


Director John Tiffany’s stylish and superbly acted revival
of The Glass Menagerie opened on
Broadway last week at the Booth Theatre. Arriving on Broadway after a
critically acclaimed run at the American Repertory Theatre in Cambridge, the
production is at once faithful to Tennessee Williams’ specific ideas about how
the play ought to be performed, and unmistakably revelatory.

GM 3The 1944 work that launched Williams’ career is a not so
thinly veiled autobiographical account with parallels to his own family life,
which the writer deems a ‘memory play.’ Tom (played here by Zachary Quinto)
acts as narrator, looking back on memories of his somewhat
delusional and heartily overbearing mother Amanda (Cherry Jones), and
physically impaired, isolated sister Laura (Celia Keenan-Bolger).

Cooped up together in a middle-class tenement of
St. Louis during the height of the Great Depression, the Wingfield family
inches by on Tom’s warehouse salary, their father having left when the children
were young. Amanda’s nostalgia for her glory days as a Southern belle blends
with her aspirations for her daughter Laura, so painfully shy that her
prospects for finding either a job or a husband to support her seem dire. 

In his production notes for the play, Williams writes:
“Expressionism and all other unconventional techniques in drama have only one
valid aim, and that is a closer approach to truth.” Tiffany’s use of stylized
movement and other carefully conceived ‘unconventional’ elements is both imaginative
and precise. Taken together, the overall effect is an evocation of memories so
far removed and yet immediate that the play feels like a vivid dream—with
emotional truth never far from the surface. 

GM 4With a softly lilting Southern cadence, Quinto brings out
the poetry in Williams’ language to captivating effect. As a son (and grown
man) looking back on loved ones he left behind and alternately reliving his
past, Quinto registers a rich spectrum of regret, restlessness, filial
affection, and an unspoken, deeply disguised longing. A frustrated poet widely accepted as a stand-in for Williams, Tom's buried desire is often interpreted as homosexual, as it is quite subtly here.

With her performance as Amanda, Ms. Jones demonstrates why
she is rightfully among the most celebrated stage actors of her (or really,
anyone’s) generation. By turns tender and smothering, pragmatic and delusional,
and garrulous without turning shrill—her Amanda quite viscerally inspires the
same complex gambit of emotions with which anyone who has a mother is familiar.   

Amanda’s assessment of her daughter, that “still water runs
deep,” may never have seemed more true. Ms. Keenan-Bolger’s careful, heartfelt
performance as Laura hints at the elaborate emotional turmoil swirling
underneath her surface stillness. It’s a metaphor that encompasses Tiffany’s
production, itself set on a small collection of rooms surrounded by dark waters—a
family marooned. 

GM 2Brian J. Smith is likewise excellent as Jim, the long
awaited Gentleman Caller. In the hands of Smith and Keenan-Bolger, the
oft-rehearsed courtship between Jim and Laura feels fresh and alive, with an
enchanting chemistry that makes the play’s conclusion that much more moving.

Joining Tiffany is the creative team with whom he also
collaborated on the Tony Award winning musical Once (with many taking home individual awards), including movement
director Steven Hoggett, designers Natasha Katz (lighting), Clive Goodwin
(sound), and Bob Crowley (scenic and costume). Together with a supremely
talented company, they deliver a haunting and extraordinary revival that’s sure
to become a benchmark for future productions.

Recent theatre features…
 ‘Romeo and Juliet’ Starring Orlando Bloom Opens On Broadway: REVIEW
 Ethan Coen’s ‘Women or Nothing’ Opens Off Broadway: REVIEW
 New Musical ‘First Date’ Opens on Broadway: REVIEW
‘Harbor’ with Randy Harrison Opens Off Broadway: REVIEW
 ‘A Kid Like Jake’ Opens Off Broadway at LCT3: REVIEW

Follow Naveen Kumar on Twitter: @Mr_NaveenKumar (photos: michael j. lutch)


  1. Derrick from Philly says

    I wish somebody had filmed Laurette Taylor in the original production. or atleast a few scenes. All actors of that period say she was mesmerizing.

  2. Tboy says

    I saw this production twice when it premiered in the Boston area at the ART. It is stunning. Cherry Jones is amazing and Zachary Quinto is too. Also a major hottie.

  3. sundayboy says

    I saw this production last night. Cherry Jones was terrific, although her accent work occasionally made a line or two incomprehensible. The Gentleman Caller delivered a pitch perfect performance. John Tiffany’s direction created a few unnecessary distractions.
    Zacahary Quinto’s accent work wasn’t terrific. He was at his best when injecting a modern sensibility into the play. His performance wasn’t revelatory.
    I think that critical hosannas over this show were overegged, like the production. A production isn’t defacto great because a movie star plays a lead. The truth is this is a so-so production that fades as soon as it ends.

  4. Robert says

    @Gigi, congrats on being a humorless, hissing queen. If you actually looked up that sequence, you would understand the joke.

    He is following Leonard Nimoy’s career path.

  5. bravo says

    @John Normile – I always assumed Tom was cruising MSM in the dark at some of the movie houses he went. He joined the Merchant Marines to be around men and to escape his all-woman home.

    I’ve always wondered what happened to Amanda and Laura after he left.

  6. ThomT says

    For me this is the perfect Tennessee Williams play. This production is one of the finest I’ve ever seen with a cast of four that seems a perfect fit. I found this production to far exceed last season’s revival of “Death of A Salesman”. However, I’m still a bit confused about the need to surround the stage with water as I personally found the reflections at times very distracting from my seat in the mezzanine. I would have returned the next night for a second viewing had I not already purchased tickets for another event.

  7. ThomT says

    @Sundayboy – while you are certainly entitled to your opinion you should at least acknowledge that most Broadway shows are not showered with accolades (or defacto greatness) because of the inclusion of a “movie star”. These shows may receive an excessive amount of attention but this is not the same as being elevated to greatness. Actually it’s quite the contrary – most critics are overly bombastic of movie folks who turn to Broadway. Quinto, at least at the performance I attended, executed himself quite well and is deserving of all of the praise he has received.

Leave A Reply