• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox

Why Marriage Equality in Florida Is a Sign of Good Things to Come

Ari Ezra Waldman January 8, 2015

FloridaBY ARI EZRA WALDMAN

When last we spoke, the freedom to marry had just been handed a setback: the Sixth Circuit let stand marriage discrimination laws in Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky and Tennessee. Over the holiday season, though, we took many steps forward in defiance of that egregious and wrongheaded appellate court opinion: Marriage equality officially came to Montana and South Carolina. And although she tried every trick in her book, Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi could not stop the arc of justice from sweeping ashore in the Sunshine State.

The arrival of marriage freedom in Florida is particularly notable because of how it happened.

BondiIn Florida, a federal district court judge ruled in August that the state's marriage ban was unconstitutional; the judge stayed his decision until January 5, 2015. The Republicans running the state wanted to delay as much as possible as they appealed the judge's ruling to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. But neither the district court nor the circuit court would grant the state a stay beyond January 5. So, Attorney General Bondi asked the Supreme Court. The Court said no, with only Justice Scalia and Thomas willing to issue the stay.

Note the difference between South Carolina and Montana, on the one hand, and Florida on the other. South Carolina is under the jurisdiction of the Fourth Circuit, which declared Virginia's marriage ban unconstitutional some time ago. Montana is in the Ninth Circuit, which made a similar decision in Idaho's case in October. Because marriage equality was just steps away from all the other states in those jurisdictions as a result of the appellate court decisions, the Supreme Court declined to issue a stay in the South Carolina case.

Florida is in the Eleventh Circuit, which has not had occasion to rule on a gay marriage case. So the Supreme Court's refusal to grant a stay and to allow marriages to start in Florida was a stronger pro-equality signal than denying a stay in South Carolina.

CONTINUED, AFTER THE JUMP…

The denial of a stay in Florida was the first time the Court helped usher in marriage equality in a jurisdiction without a favorable appellate court decision. That several Florida clerks tried to resist the judiciary's rulings by refusing to comply with the law, their antics were just sideshows to the bigger picture. By the time the particularly hateful clerks were corralled into line, the bigger story remained: The Supreme Court is not in the business of stopping marriage equality.

It is inconceivable that the Supreme Court would be willing to let gay couples start marrying only to bitterly take away the right to marry several months later. 

But Florida's fight is now in the past. We won.

Marriage equality's broader journey through the federal courts comes to a head tomorrow, Friday, January 9, when two things happen simultaneously. In New Orleans, Robbie Kaplan, the attorney who represented Edie Windsor and successfully argued the Windsor before the Supreme Court, will argue for marriage equality at the Fifth Circuit. In Washington, D.C., the Supreme Court justices will meet in private to discuss whether to hear marriage equality cases from the Sixth Circuit, the only court to uphold state bans on the freedom to marry. 

Stay tuned to Towleroad for two columns on each development.

***

Follow me on Twitter and on Facebook.

Ari Ezra Waldman is a professor of law and the Director of the Institute for Information Law and Policy at New York Law School and is concurrently getting his PhD at Columbia University in New York City. He is a 2002 graduate of Harvard College and a 2005 graduate of Harvard Law School. Ari writes weekly posts on law and various LGBT issues.

Topics: Business, News, Republicans, Supreme Court More Posts About: Antonin Scalia, Ari Ezra Waldman, florida, gay marriage, Law - Gay, LGBT, Montana, News, Pam Bondi, south carolina, Virginia, Virginia

Related Posts
  • Oh. Florida! ‘Herald’ Shows Hypocrisy of Drag Demonizers; 2000 Disney Jobs Delayed. Why? DeSantis; Mayor Won’t Fly Pride Flag, Fears Satan Flag Follows
  • Deeply Disturbing Power grab. DeSantis got a militia and now wants to control sports, schools, more: Orlando Sentinel Opinion
  • Trump’s midterm revenge campaign faces new test in South Carolina
  • Chicago Pride Parade steps off for the first time since 2019 amid concerns over future of LGBTQ+ rights

    Chicago Pride Parade steps off for the first time since 2019 amid concerns over future of LGBTQ+ rights

    Published by Chicago Tribune CHICAGO — With rainbow flags adorning the streets around Montrose Avenue and Broadway Street and rainbow-clad people staking claims to sidewalk spots near colorful floats, it became official: The annual Chicago Pride …Read More »
  • Ohio Bill To Require Genital Examination For Athletes Suspected Of Being Trans Advances

    Ohio Bill To Require Genital Examination For Athletes Suspected Of Being Trans Advances

    Published by uPolitics.com A new Ohio bill that would allow for genital exams to be administered if the sex of a student was disputed is being debated by Ohio’s state representatives. Bill 151 is meant for …Read More »
  • Norway court names suspect in Oslo gay bar shooting ahead of Pride gathering

    Norway court names suspect in Oslo gay bar shooting ahead of Pride gathering

    Published by Reuters By Gwladys Fouche OSLO (Reuters) -A Norwegian court on Monday identified the suspect in a deadly rampage at a gay bar in Oslo as Zaniar Matapour, a Norwegian citizen of Iranian origin, as …Read More »
  • Panicked Pride revelers run from phantom gunshots in Washington Square Park

    Panicked Pride revelers run from phantom gunshots in Washington Square Park

    Published by New York Daily News NEW YORK — Fireworks sparked a mass panic in Washington Square Park Sunday, sending throngs of celebrants of Pride weekend scrambling from the area, police said. Thousands of Pride revelers …Read More »
Previous Post: « The Monastero Twins Present ‘Things Straight Guys Say to Gay Guys’ – VIDEO
Next Post: Shia LaBeouf Gets Cagey In Sia’s New Music Video ‘Elastic Heart’ – VIDEO »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Billie Eilish tells Glastonbury fans to scream away anxieties at history making headline slot

    Billie Eilish tells Glastonbury fans to scream away anxieties at history making headline slot

  • Landmark gun-safety bill heads to U.S. House after Senate passage

    Landmark gun-safety bill heads to U.S. House after Senate passage

  • Prosecutors seek 25-year prison sentence for Chauvin over breach of Floyd’s rights

    Prosecutors seek 25-year prison sentence for Chauvin over breach of Floyd’s rights

RSS Partner Links

  • Jodie Sweetin Got Knocked Down By Police At A Pro-Choice Protest In Los Angeles
  • OMG, LISTEN TO THIS: Kim Petras ‘Treat Me Like A Slut (Sampladelic ‘Slutty’ Extended Mix)’
  • Kanye West Made A Surprise Appearance At The BET Awards Last Night
  • Ben Affleck’s 10-Year-Old Son Backed A Lamborghini Into A BMW
  • OMG, quote of the day: Anderson Cooper says Richard Gere helped him realize he was gay
  • Amy Schumer Says She Fired Her Doula For Being Too Beautiful
  • OMG, PAPPED! Hosted by Robin Thicke being THICC on a yacht

Most Recent

  • UAE children magazine retracts ‘gay issue’ after outcry

    UAE children magazine retracts ‘gay issue’ after outcry

  • Chicago Pride Parade steps off for the first time since 2019 amid concerns over future of LGBTQ+ rights

    Chicago Pride Parade steps off for the first time since 2019 amid concerns over future of LGBTQ+ rights

  • Ohio Bill To Require Genital Examination For Athletes Suspected Of Being Trans Advances

    Ohio Bill To Require Genital Examination For Athletes Suspected Of Being Trans Advances

  • Norway court names suspect in Oslo gay bar shooting ahead of Pride gathering

    Norway court names suspect in Oslo gay bar shooting ahead of Pride gathering

  • Panicked Pride revelers run from phantom gunshots in Washington Square Park

    Panicked Pride revelers run from phantom gunshots in Washington Square Park

  • Pink tells fans who support abortion ruling to never listen to her music again

    Pink tells fans who support abortion ruling to never listen to her music again

  • U.S. Supreme Court endorses football coach’s on-field prayers

    U.S. Supreme Court endorses football coach’s on-field prayers

  • Turn UP VOLUME  To Feel A Bit Better: Olivia Rodrigo And Lily Allen Dedicate F*** You Song to 6 Justices Of The Supreme Court At Glastonbury  Festival

    Turn UP VOLUME To Feel A Bit Better: Olivia Rodrigo And Lily Allen Dedicate F*** You Song to 6 Justices Of The Supreme Court At Glastonbury Festival

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in