• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Film/TV/Stream
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Tech/Science
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox

Why This Week’s EEOC Ruling That Federal Law Bans Anti-Gay Job Discrimination is So Important

Ari Ezra Waldman July 19, 2015 Leave a Comment

The EEOC is the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission; its job is to stop employment discrimination and to hold companies accountable when they do discriminate.

EEOC rulingOn Friday, in a 3-2 party-line ruling, the Commission held that discrimination against gay persons violates Title VII’s ban on discrimination on the basis of sex. This is potentially groundbreaking: until Friday, there was no federal law protecting gay workers if they are discriminated against because they are gay, and although only the Supreme Court can issue a definitive ruling on the subject, the EEOC’s view is given substantial weight by the courts. Plus, the decision may influence state courts on the matter, as well. Still, this huge step forward is unstable: We still have work to do to ensure that sexual orientation discrimination protections are codified in both state and federal laws.

Title VII, part of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, bans discrimination “on the basis of sex.” An employer cannot, for example, treat women different than men. Nor can they allow people to behave in a way that creates an environment hostile to women because they are women.

How discrimination “on the basis of sex” also covers discrimination of gays is pretty simple: discrimination against gays only occurs because of the victim’s gender. That is because the status of someone being gay or lesbian is defined relative to the person he or she loves. I am gay because I love a man; if I were a woman, I would be heterosexual and, thus, not the subject of anti-gay discrimination. Consider this example: Sam works for Big Corp. Last Sunday, Sam married Patrick and their announcement was in the New York Times. Today, Sam is fired because Sam is short for Samuel. If Sam were short for Samantha, he wouldn’t be fired. That’s sex discrimination. It is worth noting that this argument was at the core of an Obergefell amicus brief, submitted by two law professors, and criticized here.

Notably, this interpretation of Title VII is on top of a decades-old interpretation that Title VII bans gender expression discrimination. This, too, is discrimination on the basis of sex: Alice, in accordance with her gender expression, dresses more like a man than a woman. Her employer can neither make her work environment hostile by hurling slurs at her nor fire her because she doesn’t wear high heels. But this is only a problem because Alice is a woman. If Alice were named Albert and dressed like a man and didn’t wear high heels, there would be no basis for discrimination (unless that workplace decides to discriminate against men who behave like men).

This is a groundbreaking development because federal judges listen closely to EEOC decisions. The EEOC is the agency in charge of interpreting and implementing Title VII; the Commission is the expert in the law of employment discrimination. And basic principles of administrative law state that the judiciary should give significant deference to agency conclusions because, unlike generalist judges, EEOC commissioners are the experts in this field of law. So, although we would feel better if this ruling were handed down by a federal court, the EEOC has taken an enormous jump in that direction.

The EEOC case involved a federal employee, so the Commission’s decision gives federal employees an avenue for justice. But for those who work for most private companies, things are not so certain. True, the decision does not directly apply to them and their employers. However, the basis for private companies’ decisions to discriminate against gays is that Title VII allows it. It will be hard to make that argument now: at least according to the EEOC, Title VII does not permit anti-gay discrimination.

Still, more work needs to be done. We need to take this decision to the Supreme Court to ensure it applies to all workers. We also need a comprehensive anti-gay discrimination law passed at the federal level because this decision (and Title VII) only applies to employment discrimination. Gays are discriminated against in the provision of housing, education, and a host of other social services. But remember this EEOC decision. It will pop up again, and again, as we march further toward full equality.

Topics: Education, Supreme Court More Posts About: Ari Ezra Waldman, discrimination, EEOC, employment discrimination, ENDA, Law - Gay, LGBT, News

Related Posts
  • This Arab is Queer celebrates diversity of LGBTQ+ experience
  • Thousands gather in Tel Aviv for LGBT Pride march
  • Activists Rally, Make Case For Thailand Marriage Equality; Present Rewritten Version of Constitutional Court’s Ruling On Marriage Law
  • U.S. Supreme Court asks Maryland to bar protests at justices’ homes

    U.S. Supreme Court asks Maryland to bar protests at justices’ homes

    Published by Reuters By Jonathan Landay WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Supreme Court’s top security officer has asked Maryland Governor Larry Hogan to enforce laws barring picketing outside the Maryland homes of high court justices, saying …Read More »
  • New York moves to enshrine abortion rights in state constitution

    New York moves to enshrine abortion rights in state constitution

    Published by AFP The New York state senate — seen here in June 2011 — took action on Friday July 1, 2022 to add the right to an abortion to the state's consitution. New York (AFP) …Read More »
  • As ‘don’t say gay’ law takes effect in Florida, confusion reigns over classroom rules

    As ‘don’t say gay’ law takes effect in Florida, confusion reigns over classroom rules

    Published by Orlando Sentinel ORLANDO, Fla. — The new Florida law dubbed “don’t say gay” by its critics kicked in Friday, banning instruction on sexual orientation and gender identity in primary grades — and creating fears …Read More »
  • What charges might Trump face for trying to overturn 2020 election?

    What charges might Trump face for trying to overturn 2020 election?

    Published by Reuters (Corrects paragraph 15 to attribute testimony about Trump throwing a plate to Cassidy Hutchinson, not Kayleigh McEnaney; corrects name of judge in paragraph two to David Carter, not Andrew Carter) By Luc Cohen …Read More »
Previous Post: « Stockton, California PD Reaches Out To LGBT Community In Wake of Lieutenant’s Hateful Anti-Gay Letter
Next Post: Terrifying Video Shows Surfer Attacked by Shark During Championship in South Africa: WATCH »

Primary Sidebar

News

  • Trump foe Liz Cheney has not ruled out 2024 US presidential run

    Trump foe Liz Cheney has not ruled out 2024 US presidential run

  • New York bans guns in many public places after Supreme Court ruling

    New York bans guns in many public places after Supreme Court ruling

  • Ohio police officers shot fleeing Black man dozens of times, lawyer says

    Ohio police officers shot fleeing Black man dozens of times, lawyer says

RSS Partner Links

  • Happy Fourth of July!
  • Weekend Tennis Roundup
  • Jay Hernandez Thanks Fans After 'Magnum P.I.' Gets Picked Up By NBC
  • A Second 'A League of Their Own' Movie Almost Happened & Here's What It Would've Been About
  • Jennifer Lopez & Ben Affleck Support Local Artisans During The Holiday Weekend
  • 'Married At First Sight' Couples Still Together Today - Only 14 Out of 54 Couples Are Still Going Strong!
  • OMG, Priscilla Presley breaks down 15 looks from 1960 to now with ‘Vogue’

Most Recent

  • Silvio Berlusconi’s ex-partner Francesca Pascale marries singer girlfriend Paola Turci amid global Pride celebrations

    Silvio Berlusconi’s ex-partner Francesca Pascale marries singer girlfriend Paola Turci amid global Pride celebrations

  • U.S. Supreme Court asks Maryland to bar protests at justices’ homes

    U.S. Supreme Court asks Maryland to bar protests at justices’ homes

  • New York moves to enshrine abortion rights in state constitution

    New York moves to enshrine abortion rights in state constitution

  • As ‘don’t say gay’ law takes effect in Florida, confusion reigns over classroom rules

    As ‘don’t say gay’ law takes effect in Florida, confusion reigns over classroom rules

  • What charges might Trump face for trying to overturn 2020 election?

    What charges might Trump face for trying to overturn 2020 election?

  • Kenny Goss: I didn’t want to be Mrs George Michael

    Kenny Goss: I didn’t want to be Mrs George Michael

  • Adele feels ‘mortified’ over Las Vegas residency

    Adele feels ‘mortified’ over Las Vegas residency

  • Biden predicts states will try to arrest women who travel for abortions

    Biden predicts states will try to arrest women who travel for abortions

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Copyright © 2022 · Log in