• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Towleroad Gay News

Gay Blog Towleroad: More than gay news | gay men

  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Law/Justice
  • Celebrities
  • Republicans
  • Madonna
  • Books
  • Men
  • Trans Rights
  • Royals
  • Monkeypox
  • Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer
  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!
  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

U.S. Supreme Court Unanimously Upholds Gay Adoption Rights: A Legal Analysis

Ari Ezra Waldman March 7, 2016 Leave a Comment

Roy Moore supreme court gay adoption

The Supreme Court of Alabama is losing its anti-gay crusade. Over the last few months, Alabama's Chief Justice Roy Moore has vowed to defy the United States Supreme Court‘s Obergefell v. Hodges decision and ordered all Alabama probate courts to continue to enforce marriage discrimination. More recently, his court denied the the adoption rights of a gay parent. Today, the Supreme Court slapped him down: Alabama cannot deny a valid adoption order from another state regardless of how much Chief Justice Moore may dislike gay people.

The case — V.L. v. E.L. — has practical and doctrinal implications. As a practical matter, a woman who adopted and raised two children should now be able to see her kids again. As a doctrinal matter, the Supreme Court's very quick, unsigned per curiam decision reinforces both the equality of the gay family and the Constitution's Full Faith and Credit Clause. It is not clear that this pro-equality decision has anything to do with the absence of the late-Justice Antonin Scalia; the decision was unanimous. But it does suggest that reactionaries like Roy Moore, Ted Cruz, and Donald Trump are increasingly being marginalized by a growing consensus around equality.

V.L. and E.L. (it is common for cases like this to proceed under pseudonyms to protect family privacy) had been in a long-term, committed relationship for 17 years. During that time, and while they lived in Alabama, the couple had three children by donor insemination. E.L. was the biological mother. V.L., seeking to protect her family in the years before Obergefell, formally adopted the three children in Georgia, with E.L.'s approval. Then the couple broke up. E.L. tried to keep the children away from V.L. and then ensued an all-too-common, yet tragic fight. V.L. wanted to maintain some relationship to the children she had loved and raised for so many years. E.L. went to court and argued that the Georgia adoption was not valid in Alabama, where the couple lived.

That argument had to hurt. V.L. must have felt completely destroyed that her ex-partner was not just breaking up with her, but also trying to erase V.L. from the very beginning of her children's lives.

It was also an unprecedented legal argument. Adoptions are court orders and valid court orders deserve full faith and credit from the courts in other states. That's a term of art from Article IV, Section 1 of the Constitution: “Full faith and credit shall be given in each state to the public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of every other state.” The provision is meant to ensure comity among the states. It says that court orders that are valid in the states in which they are issued have to be recognized in all other states, as well. There would be chaos otherwise. For over one hundred and fifty years, state courts have been recognizing adoption orders from their sister states. That is, until Roy Moore and the Alabama Supreme Court decided otherwise.

Alabama Supreme Court
Alabama Supreme Court

The majority of the Alabama Supreme Court had argued that the original Georgia court that issued that adoption order did not have jurisdiction to address the matter. It's not quite clear how; the ruling was based on a rather arcane interpretation of Georgia law that even the Georgia courts didn't agree with.

The Supreme Court clarified that the Georgia adoption was indeed valid, stating as follows:

Under Georgia law, as relevant here, “[t]he superior courts of the several counties shall have exclusive jurisdiction in all matters of adoption.” Ga. Code Ann. §19–8–2(a) (2015). That provision on its face gave the Georgia Superior Court subject matter jurisdiction to hear and decide the adoption petition at issue here.

The decision was unanimous, suggesting that even the Court's hardcore conservatives were not willing to upend centuries of full faith and credit law just to spite a gay adoptive parent. It also suggests that the late-Justice Scalia would have had no impact on the outcome. The case now proceeds back to Alabama. A court will have to issue an order recognizing the adoption in accordance with the Supreme Court's decision. The saga isn't over, however: E.L. and V.L. will probably continue their fight; E.L. shows no sign of relenting. But, eventually, some visitation agreement will have to be worked out. That is for the parties to decide.

More broadly, the per curiam decision cements the reality of same-sex family equality (at least when it comes to marriage and adoption). And even the Court's conservatives are prepared to accept it.

Topics: Supreme Court, towleroad More Posts About: Alabama, Antonin Scalia, Ari Ezra Waldman, Donald Trump, gay adoption, gay marriage, Georgia, law, Law - Gay, LGBT, Roy Moore, Ted Cruz

Related Posts
  • US restores handful of wildlife protections axed by Trump
  • Kathy Griffin Says Donald Trump Supporters Are ‘Crazed Over Me’ Years After Gruesome Head Photo Went Viral
  • Federal judge dismisses Disney’s lawsuit against DeSantis
  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Mel B will “always be open” when it comes to her sexuality. The Spice Girls singer, 48, who reunited with her bandmates including the group's ex-singer Victoria Beckham for the fashion …Read More »
  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Megan Thee Stallion is being sued for allegedly creating a hostile work environment and forcing her cameraman to watch her having lesbian sex. The 29-year-old ‘Savage' rapper faces the salacious claims …Read More »
  • Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Jonathan Bennett's life was “changed forever” by his role in ‘Mean Girls'. The 42-year-old actor starred as heartthrob Aaron Samuels in the 2004 cult classic – which followed Lindsay Lohan, Rachel …Read More »
  • Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Published by BANG Showbiz English Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass a gift basket after he came out as gay. The 44-year-old NSYNC star revealed the legendary singer showed his support when Lance decided to reveal …Read More »
Previous Post: « Monday Night News: Maria Sharapova, Australia, Brokered Convention, Bloomberg, ‘Baywatch’
Next Post: Furious Rubio Aide Blasts CNN Reports He’s Considering Dropping Out Before Florida: WATCH »

Primary Sidebar

Most Recent

  • Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer

    Sophia Bush’s girlfriend ‘proud’ the actress has opened up about coming out as queer

  • Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

    Mel B declares she’ll ‘always be open’ when it comes to her sexuality!

  • Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

    Megan Thee Stallion being sued for ‘forcing cameraman watch her having lesbian sex!’

  • Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

    Mean Girls star Jonathan Bennett recalls the moment his life ‘changed forever’

  • Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

    Sir Elton John sent Lance Bass gift basket to celebrate coming out

  • Relationship status influences heterosexual women’s sexual prejudice towards lesbians

    Relationship status influences heterosexual women’s sexual prejudice towards lesbians

  • JoJo Siwa had a challenge transitioning to new grown-up image

    JoJo Siwa had a challenge transitioning to new grown-up image

  • Liz Hurley defends lesbian sex scene in new movie that was directed by her son

    Liz Hurley defends lesbian sex scene in new movie that was directed by her son

Partner Links

  • Born On This Day: Don Rickles
    Born on this day in 1926. Married to Barbara for 52 […]
  • Nathan Lane says his Hulu comedy ‘Mid-Century Modern’ is more than “the gay Golden Girls”
    Nathan Lane joined Deadline on The Actor’s Side to discuss his […]
  • Princess Kate repeated an Alessandra Rich dress for the VE Day service at the Abbey
    The Windsors gathered at Westminster Abbey earlier today for the service […]
  • “Leonardo DiCaprio did not want to be photographed at the Met Gala” links
    Leonardo DiCaprio actually attended the Met Gala with Vittoria Ceretti, his […]
  • OMG, he’s naked RETRO EDITION: Antoine Basler goes full-frontal in ‘Paris s’éveille’ (1991)
    If you’re a fan of vintage bush, check out Antoine Basler […]

Most Commented

Social

Twitter @tlrd | Facebook | Instagram @tlrd

About

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy
[towleroadmr] [towleroadtn]

Footer

Ptown Hacks 2018

Read

  • Travel
  • Film
  • Law – LGBT Rights
  • Columns
  • Specials

About

  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Towleroad
  • Towleroad on Social Media
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 · Log in

×
×